Thinking about a big tank...advice on dimensions

[hatfielj]

I am considering starting up another tank. I found a couple of good deals on 2 different new tanks and wanted to see what everyone thought would be the better dimensions. I'm thinking I'd start it out as a FOWLR and later turn it into a full mixed reef.
One is a 300 DD from Marineland 72 x 36 x 27
the other is a 96 x 30 x 22

Both are priced about the same, except the 96" tank comes with a stand for a little more. I'm kind of leaning towards the 96" since its shallower....What would you do in a situation like this!?:bigsmile:

 

[Kworker]

As much as I like the 300DD I say the 8 foot tank wins. I like the shorter height which will give you an easier time when it comes to maintenance or moving things around. You have to think about if you will dread maintenance or if you wont mind having a tough time. I picked a 180 over a 210 because I knew the 30" height will be a pain even though it looks nice with the extra height.

 

[hatfielj]

Thats a very good point. I hate cleaning my current tank and its only 40" long. I have to keep maintenance in mind.

 

[Jimbo662]

+1 on what Kworker said. Shorter will make it so much easier to work in the tank whether it's cleaning or working with corals that will end up all over the tank.

 

[stiky]

I have a 180 for sale if you would like to take a look.

 

[stiky]

http://www.sdreefs.com/forums/showthread.php?t=112469

 

[LatinKing]

Go as biggest you can

 

[3Twinklets]

I had a 375 at one time. It was acrylic and way to deep. The ability to clean it is by far the most important factor I think. After having 2 large acrylic tanks, I will never have another. If I had to go out and buy another tank today, it would be the Marineland 300g DD.

 

[Sacohen]

How big is The Great Barrier Reef?

 

[lefkonj]

I would say the location in the house is a major factor in the sizing. As others have said if its against a wall, going too deep or too tall can impact the ability to clean it. But my dream spot is a room divider tank, 108x30x27. Since 3 out of four sides are easily accessible cleaning and reaching won't be a challenge. I would then have a center overflow as well.

 

[hatfielj]

The biggest factor for me is width. I can only fit a 36" wide tank down the stairs to the basement, so I know that's as wide as I can go. I don't want to go any taller than 24" for the reasons mentioned. I have a 22" tall tank now and I love how easy it is to maintain.
I'm thinking I'm going to wait rather than jump on one of these deals and IF I decide to upgrade I'll get a 96" or 120" L x 36" x 24" and I'll probably make it a pennisula style tank so all three sides will be easily accesible/viewable. Its going to depend on a few different things that I won't go into (mainly if I'm staying in my current house long term and if I stay with my current career long term as well). I'll have answers to those "if" scenarios in the next year or two most likely, so my wait won't be long. Meanwhile I can let my current tank grow out!

 

[chrishaire22]

Dream tank would be 120"x48"x48".

 

[hatfielj]

That would be a monster! Dont think I would do the 48" tall, but that width would be amazing! Not to mention 10ft long!!

Dream tank would be 120"x48"x48".

 

[LatinKing]

48" deep I want to be the first to swim in it!

 

[tyler1503]

Dream tank would be 120"x48"x48".

Haha you could snorkel in it!
It would be ridiculously expensive to get built though.

 

[Eienna]

DON'T get the DD!! There have been quality issues with the seals lately.

 

[LatinKing]

Seals issue, that would be scary, lots of water on your rug or wood floor. And the lost on your livestock, in the thousands of dollars. Few years back a friend and vendor his DT was approximately 400G located in the dining room, the most beautiful all SPS reef tank I ever seen in my 10 yrs in the hobby. This was an establish tanks for years. One day the tank crack, I guess I need not say anymore. I would love to have a big tank, but the horror stories scare me.

 

[Kworker]

Seals issue?!? nahh!

Just an excuse to really turn it into a fish room

 

[chrishaire22]

Well that's the dream. And one day it will happen.

 

[CoralFragZ]

I am very happy with the 8 footer on 36" stand I got for Great Lakes. My advice if you go with it is make sure you get the Oak Stand and clear center braces.