- Joined
- May 25, 2020
- Messages
- 628
- Reaction score
- 497
Hello,
I recently purchased an Apex EL system with Trident and ATKv2 for my Red Sea MAX Nano. I thought, "I'm into tank automation and I'd like a controller that I can centrally manage everything".
However, after purchasing this (working on social media videos now), there's just too many dang wires to connect these devices. I read the info about IOTA "Apex-compatible API" or the like and after speaking with Red Sea, my ReefLED50 will not function with the device since they no longer include AI branded lighting. I also had an Aqamai KPS Nano pump that also would not work with the device and other than AI, I found most of the solutions that were compatible just added more wires.
There are 8 power outlets on this energy bar and I have but only one remaining. I realize that there are many larger tank owners with vendor-specific (non-integration friendly) lighting that require specialized power connections (such as present on this power) bar but I feel that I should be able to power the ATK from the two devices themselves with no module/breakout board/etc. In fact, with voice friendly power options that exist these days - I really don't see a value in the power bar at all - except that the power bar seems like the only thing that is really shown on the dashboard of the Apex. Can't I get some tiles that are more useful (add larger charts, maybe overlay them with other data I have in the home or from peers, etc)?
I can power the Trident from the energy bar, why not the same 24v ATO and why not just make a USB dongle with two analog inputs to read values from the water level sensors?
I'm just not sure what to say here (1 Powerhead, 1 Red Sea Skimmer/Return Pump AIO combo, 1 Red Sea ReefLED 50, 1 Cobalt NeoTherm heater, 1 ATKv2 and 1 Jebao v3.4 Wireless Dosing Pump) except I could not purchase the DOS or related because they will not fit power-wise neither physically in the supplied stand with a 5g Trigger Systems tank.
I don't feel pictures would even really help clarify this further. The real question is how can I simplify this or do I need to look at another solution? I mean the PDU or essentially relayed switched surge protector with stepped up or down DC power is somewhat a turnoff for these newer 2020 onward designs that are smart enabled. I understand the need for them on much larger systems but for most of us, regardless of DC running 8+ hours our power brownouts/blackouts are typically less than a few hours max and my UPS does just fine. It's smart enabled, it has telemetry already and a smart app - I can talk to Alexa and ask it to turn off my heater too if it reads the therm temp is too hot. Why not just let customers plug in their own UPS (PDU or surge suppressor) and use open source to read and switch them?
If there is any options in this setup to reduce even but one aquabus/1link or other power cable?
I recently purchased an Apex EL system with Trident and ATKv2 for my Red Sea MAX Nano. I thought, "I'm into tank automation and I'd like a controller that I can centrally manage everything".
However, after purchasing this (working on social media videos now), there's just too many dang wires to connect these devices. I read the info about IOTA "Apex-compatible API" or the like and after speaking with Red Sea, my ReefLED50 will not function with the device since they no longer include AI branded lighting. I also had an Aqamai KPS Nano pump that also would not work with the device and other than AI, I found most of the solutions that were compatible just added more wires.
There are 8 power outlets on this energy bar and I have but only one remaining. I realize that there are many larger tank owners with vendor-specific (non-integration friendly) lighting that require specialized power connections (such as present on this power) bar but I feel that I should be able to power the ATK from the two devices themselves with no module/breakout board/etc. In fact, with voice friendly power options that exist these days - I really don't see a value in the power bar at all - except that the power bar seems like the only thing that is really shown on the dashboard of the Apex. Can't I get some tiles that are more useful (add larger charts, maybe overlay them with other data I have in the home or from peers, etc)?
I can power the Trident from the energy bar, why not the same 24v ATO and why not just make a USB dongle with two analog inputs to read values from the water level sensors?
I'm just not sure what to say here (1 Powerhead, 1 Red Sea Skimmer/Return Pump AIO combo, 1 Red Sea ReefLED 50, 1 Cobalt NeoTherm heater, 1 ATKv2 and 1 Jebao v3.4 Wireless Dosing Pump) except I could not purchase the DOS or related because they will not fit power-wise neither physically in the supplied stand with a 5g Trigger Systems tank.
I don't feel pictures would even really help clarify this further. The real question is how can I simplify this or do I need to look at another solution? I mean the PDU or essentially relayed switched surge protector with stepped up or down DC power is somewhat a turnoff for these newer 2020 onward designs that are smart enabled. I understand the need for them on much larger systems but for most of us, regardless of DC running 8+ hours our power brownouts/blackouts are typically less than a few hours max and my UPS does just fine. It's smart enabled, it has telemetry already and a smart app - I can talk to Alexa and ask it to turn off my heater too if it reads the therm temp is too hot. Why not just let customers plug in their own UPS (PDU or surge suppressor) and use open source to read and switch them?
If there is any options in this setup to reduce even but one aquabus/1link or other power cable?