Another thing I didn’t mention because it wasn’t pertaining to stability, is the higher potential for a tank leak with a calcium reactor. After having a $17k wood floor bill after a previous tank leak years ago, I’m always concerned about how a leak might occur. With my calcium reactor, there are 2 potential areas for tank water to leak into the stand and eventually on the floor. The reactor itself or plumbing to and from the reactor can leak, and it isn’t in a sump so it will go everywhere quickly. The masterflex tubing could also crack at the pump and create a leak.
I have dedicated 2 leak detection sensors to these areas, and even have my masterflex head perched over a 1 gallon critter keeper container with one of those sensors.
A dosing setup on the other hand may malfunction and cause a small leak, or may dose more or less of an element into the tank which could kill livestock...but the dangers of a catastrophic leak are much smaller than that of my reactor. I would rather lose my livestock than have to deal with another 20k house repair bill and the wrath of my wife if that happened again!
I have dedicated 2 leak detection sensors to these areas, and even have my masterflex head perched over a 1 gallon critter keeper container with one of those sensors.
A dosing setup on the other hand may malfunction and cause a small leak, or may dose more or less of an element into the tank which could kill livestock...but the dangers of a catastrophic leak are much smaller than that of my reactor. I would rather lose my livestock than have to deal with another 20k house repair bill and the wrath of my wife if that happened again!