Take time to chart out where this tank went: to corals and fish. The cycle was never stalled
Added to page sixteen of thread in post seven, not stalled.
Added to page sixteen of thread in post seven, not stalled.
Cycling new tank - Nitrite won't go down (week 6.5)
- Thread starter fishermanaurl
- Start date
- Tagged users None
PeterZammetti
Active Member
Attachments
PeterZammetti
Active Member
28 years 100+ tanks 35 stalls from nitrite. Yes it will stall a cycle.
observe april 25-30 the minute the WC was done it resumed
observe april 25-30 the minute the WC was done it resumed
Written notes can't be used for proofing against sixteen pages of live fish and corals, that's test misreads above commuted onto notes / non seneye data always looks like a stall
Last edited:
we need to see dead fish from inability to control ammonia, anyone's posted cycle
There isn't one link from anyone on the internet to show one single failed cycle we'll never get a single link example, its the trend
implied consequence but no actual consequence
we need to see a failed cycle: gray water, dead fish, one single link will do
Consider the example link for this actual tank, they went on to add corals anemone and fish. That's how it always goes down. If they were stalled the animals could not live
I promise the issue investigated about nitrite isn't just to ruffle old rules or be mean, if nitrite presence causes a delayed start date then we want to know legitimately, that's why am asking for links- so we can chart outcomes that's all. Every outcome I collect is a good outcome, that's the pattern am relaying
There isn't one link from anyone on the internet to show one single failed cycle we'll never get a single link example, its the trend
implied consequence but no actual consequence
we need to see a failed cycle: gray water, dead fish, one single link will do
Consider the example link for this actual tank, they went on to add corals anemone and fish. That's how it always goes down. If they were stalled the animals could not live
I promise the issue investigated about nitrite isn't just to ruffle old rules or be mean, if nitrite presence causes a delayed start date then we want to know legitimately, that's why am asking for links- so we can chart outcomes that's all. Every outcome I collect is a good outcome, that's the pattern am relaying
Last edited:
Here's the tanks update history after claimed stall, full of corals and fish
www.reef2reef.com
When bottle bac sellers make the rules, the implied consequences don't line up with anything in reality, we show. I think it's a fair claim considering there's about a hundred work examples we can track out in post #7
*** we barely recently figured out nitrite never matters in marine cycles and for thirty years before, the hobby legit thought it did so there's no harm in following prior rules*
We started smelling some doubt though when all the marine conventions could start on time with 400 entrant ready tanks, no stalls. It was then apparent that sellers didn't have to play by same rules as buyers- forum cyclers are buyer trained to always stall never attain timely start dates
Is my rbta a lost cause? New reefer needs help
Hello reef community, I know there’s a lot of forums out there but I can’t seem to find the answer... any help appreciated i got a rose bubble tip anemone and it’s very unhappy or dying. It never settled from day 1 I got it (this is day 14) and it went in between my rocks (not getting much...
www.reef2reef.com
When bottle bac sellers make the rules, the implied consequences don't line up with anything in reality, we show. I think it's a fair claim considering there's about a hundred work examples we can track out in post #7
*** we barely recently figured out nitrite never matters in marine cycles and for thirty years before, the hobby legit thought it did so there's no harm in following prior rules*
We started smelling some doubt though when all the marine conventions could start on time with 400 entrant ready tanks, no stalls. It was then apparent that sellers didn't have to play by same rules as buyers- forum cyclers are buyer trained to always stall never attain timely start dates
Last edited:
For what it’s worth, my daughter started a cycle on a new Freshwater tank and the nitrites wouldn’t come down, 3 weeks after cycle start with stability, crushed food for ammonia. (Yes, tested with freshwater master kit,API). Dosed the tank with MB7 and nitrite collapsed in 5 days.
That’s neat input as I don’t have any patterns logged for freshwater whatsoever. Neat to hear bottle bac cleared it that fast. Randy had mentioned it’s highly toxic in fw, I bet nitrite would have indeed caused a full stall there with consequence were it not for that bac added
we get away with cheating only in sw thats ironic
we get away with cheating only in sw thats ironic
Similar threads
