Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Here's a quick look at the API with my tank water, and spiked to 0.10ppm NH3.Here is the color after 1.5 hours api with sodium citrate. In the hanna phoshate checker it read .12 ppm.
Nice. Im guessing ive got some ammonia in my system because its got a slight blue hue? Whats your tanks water reading on the hanna checker?Here's a quick look at the API with my tank water, and spiked to 0.10ppm NH3.
Left: blank, center: tank water, right: tank water +0.10 ppm NH3.
I would say the formation of a yellow color is a “fail”. You should not be able to detect any yellow color formation. I would be interested in hearing how you ran the test. A photo of the yellow test solution might clarify what you are seeing.I did the test on my tank water with api and sodium citrate. It turned an instant yellow color without any green hue. Am i supposed to put in the phosphate checker after an hour?
And here is the standard curve for the modified API NH3 test.API Modified Recipe for 10 ml sample:
10 mL sample
0.30 mL sodium citrate. white scoop from Red Sea kit. 6 red Salifert scoops add up to 0.30 mL
6 drops Reagent A
4 drops reagent B
Development time 1 hour
Color is a shade of sky blue
Ill just put this here for users to follow for 10ml bottle samples (the one from hanna checker is 10ml). If its not correct let me know ill change it.
I will run the measurement today.Instead of scoops, would it be possible to get milli/microgram weights?
--Gray
0.15 mL is 0.15 mg. This correlation depends on the coarseness of the crystals I measured, but the exact amount does not appear to matter, though undercharging sodium citrate gives a cloudy test solution.Instead of scoops, would it be possible to get milli/microgram weights?
--Gray
Undetectable color, so, I would say from this test total NH3 is < 0.01 ppm which means free NH3 around 0.001’ish ppm.Dan did your reef tank water/known cycled water test out at the lowest possible
or mid
i am currently practicing establishing nitrification capability in a tiny aquarium with Biospira. The ammonia oxidizing bacteria get to work rapidly, like days but nitrite oxidizing bacteria are taking weeks to reduce NO2 concentration.knowing accurately what nh3 does in a cycling tank, and by when, currently eludes the hobby
adjustments like this help to reveal truths, and truth affects the retail market in interesting ways. being able to plan and effect stark changes in reef tanks reliably such as home moves and upgrades all rely on accurate nh3 control, I’m interested in adjustments that reveal more consistency tank to tank when basic ammonia tests are ran. this is promising.
Cool.Here is the color after 1.5 hours api with sodium citrate. In the hanna phoshate checker it read .12 ppm.
You are correct. The salicylate method has a finicky zero though Red Sea seems better than API. Both are subject to the same issue.Dan P...very interesting post and it brings back a lot of lab experiments. When I look at the original target of "new aquarist thinking they have a stalled cycle", I wonder if they are using the entry level API test kit that notes on the box the range of acceptable inaccuracy, would the aquarist would have a Hanna checker to also use?
Exactly the condition that some deny the existence of, except in this thread, it appears. Usually a “false reading” proclamation ensues.i am currently practicing establishing nitrification capability in a tiny aquarium with Biospira. The ammonia oxidizing bacteria get to work rapidly, like days but nitrite oxidizing bacteria are taking weeks to reduce NO2 concentration.
Brandon. Make your mind up. Lots of other threads you’ve replied to said the old cycling charts are rubbish, only good for sewage treatment plants. Which is it?The ammonia oxidizing bacteria get to work rapidly, like days but nitrite oxidizing bacteria are taking weeks to reduce NO2 concentration.
-what I love about cycling charts is someone figured out the timings eighty years ago and even though we have much better gear nowadays, we keep finding they were pretty right. I like that reliability.
How i did it was add 10 mls tank water. Added 6 spoons of sodium citrate. Mixed it up until fully dissolved. It took quite a bit of violent shaking to get it moxed. Then i added the two chemicals in the api test and shook it up a 5 or six times. Then i let it sit for 1.5 hours. Did i do the test wrong?I would say the formation of a yellow color is a “fail”. You should not be able to detect any yellow color formation. I would be interested in hearing how you ran the test. A photo of the yellow test solution might clarify what you are seeing.
Sounds good! Development time is only one hour, but being consistent from test to test is important.How i did it was add 10 mls tank water. Added 6 spoons of sodium citrate. Mixed it up until fully dissolved. It took quite a bit of violent shaking to get it moxed. Then i added the two chemicals in the api test and shook it up a 5 or six times. Then i let it sit for 1.5 hours. Did i do the test wrong?
Yes when i shook it up it was yellow. Ill check if the kits expired or something and report back. Whats my result of .13 ppm mean? Ive got that much ammonia?Sounds good! Development time is only one hour, but being consistent from test to test is important.
When you said that you saw a yellow color I immediately assumed the worse. Your photo did not look like a bad yellow.