i cant think
Wrasse Addict
View BadgesExcellence Award
Reef Tank 365
Article Contributor
UK Reef Club Member
Rock Pool Reef Keepers
My Tank Thread
My Aquarium Showcase
I’m confused, you want to know what worked best for others? But you want to know 10 or so other tanks this also worked for?Remake this thread in the fish disease forum so it’s not safe zoned lemme see it on page three.
I notice all responses here come from the single reef owner perspective
this whole thread is about what people think worked best for their tank
whats missing: any data whatsoever that we can link to read what happens in others tanks, none of you have anything on the line for making the assessments and if you ran public work threads, you would and I could read that for proof myself without your summary being the sole proof.
it’s easy to lie, omit bad info outcomes when all the data comes from our own summaries, you all put too much focus on what you can do and there’s little focus on what you can do to stem problems others are having
if that’s wrong, or over generalized about this crowd, show me the work links, insert them right here for me to click —->
my comments come from managing countless linkable right now cycle productions for others, and the endpoint is massive disease issues. Thats where my data comes from, others tanks, this safety thread is just about owners reefs.
Elora
specifically a request for you: omit any example involving your own tank. Link here now a thread where you managed any aspect of reefing for others, they tried the recommend, and logged the results. If you don’t provide that, I’ll think all your data is made up with the bad parts omitted and the good parts played up. Yin yang, remake this exact post in the fish disease forum. If I take time to log outbound cycle work for a decade on others reefs solely and all that data is ready now, you can read it, and I tell you disease is the issue-you would get your notepad out vs give kickback. You wouldn’t take your first year of reefing practice as a go ahead to advise folks to skip qt.
don’t go to a place where clearly most entrants are opposed to disease preps and try and gain support using zero public tank examples.
What’s the point in the “What worked best for others” if you don’t rely on a good 1-9 minute write up on what happened in a person’s tank over the course of anywhere between 8 months to several years?