R2R Excellence Award
Photo of the Month
Article ContributorBuild Thread Contributor
- Jul 28, 2013
- Reaction score
- Corpus Christi, TX
This, to me - Sounds like you put a fish that was in 1.017 salinity water directly into 1.024 salinity water after 3 hours, as Jay stated above.I had to slowly acclimate b/c his salinity was only 1.017 . Mine was 1.0265 .. I was able to slowly get mine down to 1.024. After 3 hrs I put him in tank.
This fish was laying upside down in the bag before ever opening it. Likely nothing would have mattered much anyhow as the fish was very bad off. Asking about the salinity in my main post looking back was too much info. Before the fish acually died someone told me it's normal for radiants them to lie on their side. So thats really what I shoudl have asked about and just that. As the salinity difference really just added to confusion on this. Though at same time it didnt help the fish if it had any tiny chance of reviving.This, to me - Sounds like you put a fish that was in 1.017 salinity water directly into 1.024 salinity water after 3 hours, as Jay stated above.
You said you got yours down to 1.024 - Not sure what this means - You needed to get the store water the fish was in UP TO 1.026, to match yours.
Did you acclimate to the point the water the fish was in, in the bag or bucket was the same salinity as your tank?
Its either miscommunication or poor acclimation from what im reading.
TY Orion !Normally you don't really need that long to acclimated the fish. Temperature and salinity need to be match. If salinity about the same they can just go right in once temperature match by floating. If specific gravity (salinity) is low in the LFS like 1.018 (around 25 ppt) and your tank at 1.026 (around 35 ppt), then you should take about 20-30 mins or so only. The longer you do this the more stress to the fish.
Normally LFS keep their salinity low in FO tanks, about 25 ppt. I always keep my tank salinity at 35 ppt so I normally tank 20-30 mins to get the animals in at the most.
Long acclimation periord does not help the animals but stress them more.
That's true.. And I take responsibility for not asking to see the fish swim nor eat , etc. But he wouldnt stay out of the sand, so I could leave him there and have someone else get him or trust he was ok. I did the latter. But the LFS took it back almost no questions... I did call them as soon as I saw him in the unopened bag upside down. He just happend to be randomly upright when in the bag in the store.Most LFS do not guarantee salt water fish once they leave the store. At least LFS here in Corpus Christi.