Proper Dosing of Medicated Foods

Proper Dosing of Medicated Foods

Jay Hemdal
c. 2020
Oral medications are an excellent way to target internal diseases of fishes. Marine fish absorb aquarium water, so in certain cases, they “drink” enough medication from the water to effect a cure. However, freshwater fish actively export water from their tissues and do not take in aquarium water, so injectable or oral medications are really the only internal delivery system that works for them.

Years ago, there were a variety of commercially available medicated flake and pellet foods. Currently, there seems to be only one product on the market, so aquarists are faced with either forgoing medicated foods, or making their own.

Presently, many aquarists try to soak their fish food in medication and then feed that to their fish. The trouble is that this can never really work. Oral fish medications are always dosed on an “as fed basis”, usually milligrams of medication per kilogram of fish biomass. In the case of soaking food in medication; the amount of medication per gram of food is unknown, as is the weight of the fish, and so is the amount of food being fed. With that many variables, a proper dose simply cannot be formulated.

One drawback to oral medication is that the fish must be healthy enough to be feeding properly. A fish that is too sick to feed, may need to be either injected with medication, or tube-fed (see section below). In tube-feeding, since you have the fish in hand, it can be directly weighed in order to calculate an accurate dose.

1 - medicated foods - poidog.jpg

Photo of Anampses femininus by @poidog

The typical formula for medicated food is:

XX Milligrams of medication per Kilogram of fish mass in food, fed at 3% of the fish’s weight per day
  1. Select a medication and dose from the formulary below.​
  2. Estimate the weight of all of the fish to be treated​
  3. Prepare the medicated food – either gel diet, or dissolved with a solvent and sprayed on food​
  4. Feed at a rate of 3% of the fish’s total body mass daily, or as indicated in the formulary​
Formulary (derived from Noga 2010, in turn from various other sources)

Enrofloxacin (Baytril)
Active against Aeromonas, Vibrio. 10 mg/kg of body weight per day for ten days.

Erythromycin Useful in treating gram positive bacterial infections, notably kidney disease. 100 mg/kg of body weight per day for 21 days.

Kanamycin Broad spectrum activity against gram negative bacteria. 50 mg/kg body weight daily for five days.

Magnesium sulfate May inhibit gut protozoans such as Hexamita, Spironucleus. Add to gelatin recipe at a rate of 3%, feed daily for three days.

Metronidazole (Flagyl) Treats both intestinal flagellates and anaerobic bacteria. 100 mg/kg body weight daily for three days. Very bitter. Some fish learn to avoid food with this medication in it.

Oxytetracycline Active against a wide range of bacterial pathogens, including Columnaris, Aeromonas, Pseudomonas. Inactivated by seawater, best used orally, wide range of dosing. 83 mg/kg body weight daily for ten days.

Panacur (Fenbendazole) Active against nematodes in the digestive system. 50 mg/kg body weight weekly for two treatments. Do not use on bottom-dwelling fishes; darters, catfish, etc. Do not use on flashlight fish or pencilfish. Additional species may be found to react poorly to this medication. Affected fish will die post-treatment, despite water changes, over a period of days. Their mouths will be gaped open upon death.

Praziquantel (Droncit) Treats cestodes and Monogenean flukes. 50 mg/kg body weight every other day for three treatments.


Recipe for general formula gelatin fish food

To make 1 kilogram (2.2 pounds) of food:

1) Dissolve 3 ounces, (3 packets) of unflavored gelatin in 300 ml of very hot water (160 degrees F.)
2) Blend together the following ingredients:
  • 100 grams of smelt or other white fish flesh​
  • 50 g frozen mixed vegetables (or 20 grams of dried Nori algae for marine fish)​
  • 50 g shrimp tails, peeled​
  • 100 g small krill or mysid shrimp​
  • 30 g flake fish food, freeze dried foods, etc.​
  • 2 g Spirulina powder (optional)​
  • 1000 mg ascorbic acid (optional)​
  • 1 multi-vitamin tablet, crushed​
  • 300 ml water​
3) Once the gelatin has cooled to 110 F., fold the dissolved gelatin into the above mixture,
4) Fold in any additives, such as medications. Blend for 30 more seconds at low speed.
5) Pour mixture into ice cube trays. Place the trays into the freezer.
6) After about one hour, remove and cut each slightly hardened block in half, leaving the two pieces inside the tray.
7) Return to freezer for 6 or more hours. Remove blocks, and separate at the cut points. Return blocks to freezer for storage. The final product should probably not be kept longer than two months.
8) Mazuri, a subsidiary of Purina offers a line of powdered gelatin food pre-mixes to public aquariums. Different formulations are available (such as herbivore and carnivore varieties) and it is easy to add supplements to the mix such as HUFAs or vitamins. These mixes are much more convenient than making your own food from scratch, and they have had the obvious benefit of having been formulated by nutritional experts.


Solvent spray dosing

If a particular drug can be dissolved in a solvent, that solution can then be sprayed onto a flake, freeze-dried or pellet food with good assurance that the drug will soak in and bind with the food when allowed to dry. Pure ethanol is a common solvent. In some cases, distilled water can be used. Simply calculate the amount of drug to be added to the food item and dissolve it in the least amount of solvent as possible. Spread the food item out of a tray and spray evenly with the solvent/drug mixture and allow to dry.


Tube-feeding

The tube-feeding process can be employed to give the fish food energy during the time it is anorexic. In some cases, this gives the aquarist enough time to determine a permanent solution. This process uses simple equipment—a syringe and a flexible plastic tube. Feline urinary catheters or avian tracheal tubes can be used for small fishes. Larger fishes can be fed using standard airline tubing attached to a large syringe. A Luer-lock syringe will hold the feeding tube more securely to the syringe body. Placing the tube is easier if you first bevel the end of it. The tube should have marks on it at regular intervals so you can more easily judge the depth of insertion.

The basic food recipe is to create a liquid that will easily pass through the feeding syringe and tube but is thick enough to carry a high amount of calories to the animal’s digestive tract with the least amount of water. It is best to prepare this slurry in a blender, using components of the fish’s normal diet.

The amount of food administered at one feeding is generally 2 to 4% of the animal’s body weight, just enough food to cause a slight distension of the animal’s belly. In most cases, the use of an anesthetic, such as MS-222, is required to sedate the fish so the tube can be inserted. Holding the fish on its back, gently insert the tube into its mouth and try to locate the esophagus. If you are too far to one side or the other, the tube will miss and emerge from under one of the gill covers. Once in place, gentle pressure on the syringe plunger will move the liquid food into the fish’s stomach. Once fed, the tube is gently withdrawn and the fish is moved to a recovery tank.

Spontaneous regurgitation is the most commonly seen problem, though there are also reports of people accidentally rupturing the fish’s digestive tract. Like any medical procedure, there are subtle techniques for this process that need to be learned through practice—so please do not expect to read this basic introduction and suddenly be proficient at tube-feeding fish.


Fish Mass determination

Many oral and injectable medications require that the fish's body mass be known prior to the proper administration of these compounds. Calculating an aquarium's carrying capacity, specimen feeding rate, or food supplement concentration also require that the fish's mass be determined prior to such computations.

The following text describes three potential methods for determining the mass of living fishes, including the benefits and drawbacks of each technique.

1) Direct determination:

Obtaining the actual mass of a living fish is often problematical. Some species cannot tolerate the handling required to obtain such measurements; the physical stress involved may actually cause the death of a delicate specimen. In other cases, the fish are simply not retrievable due to the intricate physical structure of their aquarium. In yet other situations, the labor involved in directly weighing a given fish is greater than the potential benefit that might be gained from obtaining the data. These three factors, sometimes in combination, often result in a revision of a preferred oral or injectable medication treatment regime to a possibly less effective, but more easily administered one such as a static bath. There are four basic methods to directly measure the mass of a living fish:

a) The fish can be captured, moved to a small holding container, and anesthetized with Metomidate at 4 to 8 mg/l (or another anesthetic such as MS-222 at an appropriate dose). The fish is then transferred to a clean weighing pan (covered with a soft wet substrate) and weighed. The time that the fish is removed from the water, (without supplemental life support) should be less than five minutes - inclusive of any medical procedures that might be required at the same time. All anesthetics pose an inherent risk to the subject, and cost factors, (including time) must also be evaluated.​
b) A non-anesthetized fish can be captured, and moved to a small holding container with sufficient water, (One that has previously been measured or tared on the scale) and weighed. The weight of the container and the water can then be subtracted from the total, and the fish's mass be determined. The primary drawback to this method is that a scale that has a range wide enough to be tared with perhaps 9 kilograms of water plus the container, (roughly a full two gallon bucket) will not normally have sufficient accuracy to then be able to compute the mass of the fish it contains which might only weigh .5 kilograms. Limiting the amount of water in which the fish is held will reduce this problem, but will subsequently increase the stress to which the fish is exposed.​
c) A small non-anesthetized fish could be captured, and quickly placed directly on the weighing pan of a scale, and the weight measured. Movement of the fish will affect the results of such a measurement, and most aquarists would consider the stress to which the fish would be exposed to be unacceptable.​
d) A rarely used method for fish mass determination is volumetric displacement. In theory, a fish can be placed in a container of water that has volumetric graduations. The displacement of the water after the fish has been added could be used to calculate its mass. Most fishes are neutrally buoyant in water, so the weight of the water displaced can be considered equal to the mass of the fish. In practice, an extremely narrow cylinder would be required in order to obtain an accurate vertical resolution of the water displaced after the fish was placed in the container.​
For the two following mass estimation methods, the fish's length must be known: Holding a tape measure against the front of a tank as the fish swims nearby is perhaps the best means to determine its length. Taking an instant photograph of the fish alongside an object of known length is another possible method. The refraction of the water does not seem to affect these readings; as it does while SCUBA diving (where objects underwater appear 30% larger or 30% closer than they would in the air).

2) Observational estimate:

Using a fish's length alone, aquarists may sometimes attempt to estimate its mass. Typically, one needs a certain amount of data before attempting such an estimate; either anecdotal knowledge of the mass of similar fishes, or knowing the mass of comparable objects in terms of size and density. For example, an uncooked hamburger patty weighs about 110 grams. With a mental picture of this, the aquarist then estimates how many of these "hamburger patties" could be contained in the body of the fish. In practical use, without a sound frame of reference, observational estimates are often inaccurate to the point of being useless. Twelve aquarists were asked to estimate the mass of 6 fishes of known mass. Their estimates averaged 75% higher than the actual mass of the fishes. Not a single estimate was within 20% of that of a given specimen. Observational estimates are best used if one knows from previous experience, the mass of a same sized fish of an identical species derived from a previous direct weighing. Table one gives some examples of direct measured fish masses that aquarists might find helpful in refining their own observational estimates.

3) Direct Comparison against a known data set:

This is an improvement of the observational technique in which data previously compiled from fishes of similar length and body morphology is used to obtain a mass estimate of the specimen in question. Aquaculturists have long used this technique for commonly cultured species; for example, tables have been developed that show how many salmonid fry of a given size comprise a kilogram of biomass. Accuracy suffers when one attempts to estimate the mass of atypical fish, such as robust gravid females, or ill specimens that are in an emaciated condition. Nevertheless, such a database program can be used as an adjunct tool for the serious aquarist wishing to estimate the mass of a fish and avoid the inherent stress of direct weighing.

1 medicated foods.png

2 medicated foods.png

3 medicated foods.png

Direct Fish Length/Weight Relationships – use as examples for estimation

4 medicated foods.png


5 medicated foods.png


6 medicated foods.png


7 medicated foods.png


8 medicated foods.png


9 medicated foods.png


10 medicated foods.png

Mock fish – to be used as indirect comparison of fish length/weight estimates


11 medicated foods.png

An accurate scale is mandatory for any serious work with medicated foods.
This model only cost $17 US and can accurately measure from 0.05 to 200 grams.

Case history:

An aquarium housing 13 rather small fish needed to be treated with oral antibiotics. The veterinary recommendation was to use erythromycin, dosed at 100 mg/kg fish body weight in the diet for 14-21 days.

The first step was to estimate the fish mass in the aquarium (in this case, but comparing to a known weight data set). 10 platies (about 5 g total) 1 goldfish at around 40 g, one or 2 danios at 2 g and one large tetra and 10 g, for a total mass of around 57 grams.

For the erythromycin dose, that works out to be 5.7 mg of erythromycin fed to the whole tank each day.

One usually assumes that the fish will eat around 3% of their body mass each day, so for this system, that works out to be 1.7 grams of food per day. Therefore, we need 5.7 mg in 1.7 grams of food, or 670 mg in 200 grams of medicated food.

Erythromycin is soluble in ethanol. Dissolving 670 mg of erythromycin in the smallest amount of ethanol possible and then spray it on to 200 grams of flake food and allow it to evaporate. The fish were then fed 1.7 grams of food daily (spread over three feedings).
 
Last edited by a moderator:
OP
Jay Hemdal

Jay Hemdal

5000 Club Member
View Badges
Joined
Jul 31, 2020
Messages
6,642
Reaction score
6,270
Location
Dundee
That's some good information, but...is there more? Stuff like dosing quantities, etc? All that's showing up for me now is the bit about dosing medications in water vs feeding in freshwater vs. saltwater fish....

It should be a PDF with ten pages, with the 11th page blank. There is a formulary in the beginning. I only used solid references for that, and no brand names, because I'm not happy with the efficacy of some commercial products.

Jay
 
OP
Jay Hemdal

Jay Hemdal

5000 Club Member
View Badges
Joined
Jul 31, 2020
Messages
6,642
Reaction score
6,270
Location
Dundee
I'd love to know where the "fish eat 3% of their body mass" fact is from! Can you link to any studies about it?
It’s from aquaculture, pretty common ballpark figure. I actually backed it up with some data I collected on 2 species of Victorian cichlids...couple hundred fish and one species ate 3% body weight per day and the other ate 4%....calculated by weighing all the fish, and then weighing the food over one week time. This was frozen food, flakes or pellets would be less.
Jay
 

ichthyogeek

Valuable Member
View Badges
Joined
Jun 26, 2020
Messages
2,072
Reaction score
2,025
It’s from aquaculture, pretty common ballpark figure. I actually backed it up with some data I collected on 2 species of Victorian cichlids...couple hundred fish and one species ate 3% body weight per day and the other ate 4%....calculated by weighing all the fish, and then weighing the food over one week time. This was frozen food, flakes or pellets would be less.
Jay
Was the 3% a maximum? Did it matter if it was fed throughout the day vs. fed all at once? Did female fish ingest more in preparation for egg production? I'm thinking this could be applied to feeding efficiently towards breeding projects (i.e. If I have 100 grams of fish, to feed them for a week, I only need to have 3*7=21 grams of food for the week)
 
OP
Jay Hemdal

Jay Hemdal

5000 Club Member
View Badges
Joined
Jul 31, 2020
Messages
6,642
Reaction score
6,270
Location
Dundee
The way I measured it was to have a group of aquarists feed the cichlids their normal ration, weighing it first. Doing that for a week gave me a pretty solid reference for what the fish needed. There is certainly a lot of variables - small fish eat a higher percentage than adults, active species need more than inactive, etc. The 3% is the right order of magnitude to use in medicated food treatments.
Jay
 

ichthyogeek

Valuable Member
View Badges
Joined
Jun 26, 2020
Messages
2,072
Reaction score
2,025
Is there any benefit to injecting foods with medications? This is probably more relevant to feeding larger fish, but can you take say....a mysid shrimp or 3, and inject them with something like a praziquantel powder slurry in order to get the medication into a fish that's refusing gelatin food?
 
OP
Jay Hemdal

Jay Hemdal

5000 Club Member
View Badges
Joined
Jul 31, 2020
Messages
6,642
Reaction score
6,270
Location
Dundee
Is there any benefit to injecting foods with medications? This is probably more relevant to feeding larger fish, but can you take say....a mysid shrimp or 3, and inject them with something like a praziquantel powder slurry in order to get the medication into a fish that's refusing gelatin food?

Sure - we do that with whole seafood items fed to sharks, etc. You still need to calculate the dosage based on the animal's weight. There is some issue of loss, as the fish chews up the food, but still more accurate than just "soaking" food in an unknown amount of medication....

Jay
 

BighohoReef

A reefer in need is a friend indeed!
View Badges
Joined
Apr 14, 2020
Messages
4,008
Reaction score
11,324
Proper Dosing of Medicated Foods

Jay Hemdal
c. 2020
Oral medications are an excellent way to target internal diseases of fishes. Marine fish absorb aquarium water, so in certain cases, they “drink” enough medication from the water to effect a cure. However, freshwater fish actively export water from their tissues and do not take in aquarium water, so injectable or oral medications are really the only internal delivery system that works for them.

Years ago, there were a variety of commercially available medicated flake and pellet foods. Currently, there seems to be only one product on the market, so aquarists are faced with either forgoing medicated foods, or making their own.

Presently, many aquarists try to soak their fish food in medication and then feed that to their fish. The trouble is that this can never really work. Oral fish medications are always dosed on an “as fed basis”, usually milligrams of medication per kilogram of fish biomass. In the case of soaking food in medication; the amount of medication per gram of food is unknown, as is the weight of the fish, and so is the amount of food being fed. With that many variables, a proper dose simply cannot be formulated.

One drawback to oral medication is that the fish must be healthy enough to be feeding properly. A fish that is too sick to feed, may need to be either injected with medication, or tube-fed (see section below). In tube-feeding, since you have the fish in hand, it can be directly weighed in order to calculate an accurate dose.

1 - medicated foods - poidog.jpg

Photo of Anampses femininus by @poidog

The typical formula for medicated food is:

XX Milligrams of medication per Kilogram of fish mass in food, fed at 3% of the fish’s weight per day
  1. Select a medication and dose from the formulary below.​
  2. Estimate the weight of all of the fish to be treated​
  3. Prepare the medicated food – either gel diet, or dissolved with a solvent and sprayed on food​
  4. Feed at a rate of 3% of the fish’s total body mass daily, or as indicated in the formulary​
Formulary (derived from Noga 2010, in turn from various other sources)

Enrofloxacin (Baytril)
Active against Aeromonas, Vibrio. 10 mg/kg of body weight per day for ten days.

Erythromycin Useful in treating gram positive bacterial infections, notably kidney disease. 100 mg/kg of body weight per day for 21 days.

Kanamycin Broad spectrum activity against gram negative bacteria. 50 mg/kg body weight daily for five days.

Magnesium sulfate May inhibit gut protozoans such as Hexamita, Spironucleus. Add to gelatin recipe at a rate of 3%, feed daily for three days.

Metronidazole (Flagyl) Treats both intestinal flagellates and anaerobic bacteria. 100 mg/kg body weight daily for three days. Very bitter. Some fish learn to avoid food with this medication in it.

Oxytetracycline Active against a wide range of bacterial pathogens, including Columnaris, Aeromonas, Pseudomonas. Inactivated by seawater, best used orally, wide range of dosing. 83 mg/kg body weight daily for ten days.

Panacur (Fenbendazole) Active against nematodes in the digestive system. 50 mg/kg body weight weekly for two treatments. Do not use on bottom-dwelling fishes; darters, catfish, etc. Do not use on flashlight fish or pencilfish. Additional species may be found to react poorly to this medication. Affected fish will die post-treatment, despite water changes, over a period of days. Their mouths will be gaped open upon death.

Praziquantel (Droncit) Treats cestodes and Monogenean flukes. 50 mg/kg body weight every other day for three treatments.


Recipe for general formula gelatin fish food

To make 1 kilogram (2.2 pounds) of food:

1) Dissolve 3 ounces, (3 packets) of unflavored gelatin in 300 ml of very hot water (160 degrees F.)
2) Blend together the following ingredients:
  • 100 grams of smelt or other white fish flesh​
  • 50 g frozen mixed vegetables (or 20 grams of dried Nori algae for marine fish)​
  • 50 g shrimp tails, peeled​
  • 100 g small krill or mysid shrimp​
  • 30 g flake fish food, freeze dried foods, etc.​
  • 2 g Spirulina powder (optional)​
  • 1000 mg ascorbic acid (optional)​
  • 1 multi-vitamin tablet, crushed​
  • 300 ml water​
3) Once the gelatin has cooled to 110 F., fold the dissolved gelatin into the above mixture,
4) Fold in any additives, such as medications. Blend for 30 more seconds at low speed.
5) Pour mixture into ice cube trays. Place the trays into the freezer.
6) After about one hour, remove and cut each slightly hardened block in half, leaving the two pieces inside the tray.
7) Return to freezer for 6 or more hours. Remove blocks, and separate at the cut points. Return blocks to freezer for storage. The final product should probably not be kept longer than two months.
8) Mazuri, a subsidiary of Purina offers a line of powdered gelatin food pre-mixes to public aquariums. Different formulations are available (such as herbivore and carnivore varieties) and it is easy to add supplements to the mix such as HUFAs or vitamins. These mixes are much more convenient than making your own food from scratch, and they have had the obvious benefit of having been formulated by nutritional experts.


Solvent spray dosing

If a particular drug can be dissolved in a solvent, that solution can then be sprayed onto a flake, freeze-dried or pellet food with good assurance that the drug will soak in and bind with the food when allowed to dry. Pure ethanol is a common solvent. In some cases, distilled water can be used. Simply calculate the amount of drug to be added to the food item and dissolve it in the least amount of solvent as possible. Spread the food item out of a tray and spray evenly with the solvent/drug mixture and allow to dry.


Tube-feeding

The tube-feeding process can be employed to give the fish food energy during the time it is anorexic. In some cases, this gives the aquarist enough time to determine a permanent solution. This process uses simple equipment—a syringe and a flexible plastic tube. Feline urinary catheters or avian tracheal tubes can be used for small fishes. Larger fishes can be fed using standard airline tubing attached to a large syringe. A Luer-lock syringe will hold the feeding tube more securely to the syringe body. Placing the tube is easier if you first bevel the end of it. The tube should have marks on it at regular intervals so you can more easily judge the depth of insertion.

The basic food recipe is to create a liquid that will easily pass through the feeding syringe and tube but is thick enough to carry a high amount of calories to the animal’s digestive tract with the least amount of water. It is best to prepare this slurry in a blender, using components of the fish’s normal diet.

The amount of food administered at one feeding is generally 2 to 4% of the animal’s body weight, just enough food to cause a slight distension of the animal’s belly. In most cases, the use of an anesthetic, such as MS-222, is required to sedate the fish so the tube can be inserted. Holding the fish on its back, gently insert the tube into its mouth and try to locate the esophagus. If you are too far to one side or the other, the tube will miss and emerge from under one of the gill covers. Once in place, gentle pressure on the syringe plunger will move the liquid food into the fish’s stomach. Once fed, the tube is gently withdrawn and the fish is moved to a recovery tank.

Spontaneous regurgitation is the most commonly seen problem, though there are also reports of people accidentally rupturing the fish’s digestive tract. Like any medical procedure, there are subtle techniques for this process that need to be learned through practice—so please do not expect to read this basic introduction and suddenly be proficient at tube-feeding fish.


Fish Mass determination

Many oral and injectable medications require that the fish's body mass be known prior to the proper administration of these compounds. Calculating an aquarium's carrying capacity, specimen feeding rate, or food supplement concentration also require that the fish's mass be determined prior to such computations.

The following text describes three potential methods for determining the mass of living fishes, including the benefits and drawbacks of each technique.

1) Direct determination:

Obtaining the actual mass of a living fish is often problematical. Some species cannot tolerate the handling required to obtain such measurements; the physical stress involved may actually cause the death of a delicate specimen. In other cases, the fish are simply not retrievable due to the intricate physical structure of their aquarium. In yet other situations, the labor involved in directly weighing a given fish is greater than the potential benefit that might be gained from obtaining the data. These three factors, sometimes in combination, often result in a revision of a preferred oral or injectable medication treatment regime to a possibly less effective, but more easily administered one such as a static bath. There are four basic methods to directly measure the mass of a living fish:

a) The fish can be captured, moved to a small holding container, and anesthetized with Metomidate at 4 to 8 mg/l (or another anesthetic such as MS-222 at an appropriate dose). The fish is then transferred to a clean weighing pan (covered with a soft wet substrate) and weighed. The time that the fish is removed from the water, (without supplemental life support) should be less than five minutes - inclusive of any medical procedures that might be required at the same time. All anesthetics pose an inherent risk to the subject, and cost factors, (including time) must also be evaluated.​
b) A non-anesthetized fish can be captured, and moved to a small holding container with sufficient water, (One that has previously been measured or tared on the scale) and weighed. The weight of the container and the water can then be subtracted from the total, and the fish's mass be determined. The primary drawback to this method is that a scale that has a range wide enough to be tared with perhaps 9 kilograms of water plus the container, (roughly a full two gallon bucket) will not normally have sufficient accuracy to then be able to compute the mass of the fish it contains which might only weigh .5 kilograms. Limiting the amount of water in which the fish is held will reduce this problem, but will subsequently increase the stress to which the fish is exposed.​
c) A small non-anesthetized fish could be captured, and quickly placed directly on the weighing pan of a scale, and the weight measured. Movement of the fish will affect the results of such a measurement, and most aquarists would consider the stress to which the fish would be exposed to be unacceptable.​
d) A rarely used method for fish mass determination is volumetric displacement. In theory, a fish can be placed in a container of water that has volumetric graduations. The displacement of the water after the fish has been added could be used to calculate its mass. Most fishes are neutrally buoyant in water, so the weight of the water displaced can be considered equal to the mass of the fish. In practice, an extremely narrow cylinder would be required in order to obtain an accurate vertical resolution of the water displaced after the fish was placed in the container.​
For the two following mass estimation methods, the fish's length must be known: Holding a tape measure against the front of a tank as the fish swims nearby is perhaps the best means to determine its length. Taking an instant photograph of the fish alongside an object of known length is another possible method. The refraction of the water does not seem to affect these readings; as it does while SCUBA diving (where objects underwater appear 30% larger or 30% closer than they would in the air).

2) Observational estimate:

Using a fish's length alone, aquarists may sometimes attempt to estimate its mass. Typically, one needs a certain amount of data before attempting such an estimate; either anecdotal knowledge of the mass of similar fishes, or knowing the mass of comparable objects in terms of size and density. For example, an uncooked hamburger patty weighs about 110 grams. With a mental picture of this, the aquarist then estimates how many of these "hamburger patties" could be contained in the body of the fish. In practical use, without a sound frame of reference, observational estimates are often inaccurate to the point of being useless. Twelve aquarists were asked to estimate the mass of 6 fishes of known mass. Their estimates averaged 75% higher than the actual mass of the fishes. Not a single estimate was within 20% of that of a given specimen. Observational estimates are best used if one knows from previous experience, the mass of a same sized fish of an identical species derived from a previous direct weighing. Table one gives some examples of direct measured fish masses that aquarists might find helpful in refining their own observational estimates.

3) Direct Comparison against a known data set:

This is an improvement of the observational technique in which data previously compiled from fishes of similar length and body morphology is used to obtain a mass estimate of the specimen in question. Aquaculturists have long used this technique for commonly cultured species; for example, tables have been developed that show how many salmonid fry of a given size comprise a kilogram of biomass. Accuracy suffers when one attempts to estimate the mass of atypical fish, such as robust gravid females, or ill specimens that are in an emaciated condition. Nevertheless, such a database program can be used as an adjunct tool for the serious aquarist wishing to estimate the mass of a fish and avoid the inherent stress of direct weighing.

1 medicated foods.png

2 medicated foods.png

3 medicated foods.png

Direct Fish Length/Weight Relationships – use as examples for estimation

4 medicated foods.png


5 medicated foods.png


6 medicated foods.png


7 medicated foods.png


8 medicated foods.png


9 medicated foods.png


10 medicated foods.png

Mock fish – to be used as indirect comparison of fish length/weight estimates


11 medicated foods.png

An accurate scale is mandatory for any serious work with medicated foods.
This model only cost $17 US and can accurately measure from 0.05 to 200 grams.

Case history:

An aquarium housing 13 rather small fish needed to be treated with oral antibiotics. The veterinary recommendation was to use erythromycin, dosed at 100 mg/kg fish body weight in the diet for 14-21 days.

The first step was to estimate the fish mass in the aquarium (in this case, but comparing to a known weight data set). 10 platies (about 5 g total) 1 goldfish at around 40 g, one or 2 danios at 2 g and one large tetra and 10 g, for a total mass of around 57 grams.

For the erythromycin dose, that works out to be 5.7 mg of erythromycin fed to the whole tank each day.

One usually assumes that the fish will eat around 3% of their body mass each day, so for this system, that works out to be 1.7 grams of food per day. Therefore, we need 5.7 mg in 1.7 grams of food, or 670 mg in 200 grams of medicated food.

Erythromycin is soluble in ethanol. Dissolving 670 mg of erythromycin in the smallest amount of ethanol possible and then spray it on to 200 grams of flake food and allow it to evaporate. The fish were then fed 1.7 grams of food daily (spread over three feedings).
I love this article it’s fantastic!!! I need this in book form:)
 

threebuoys

Active Member
View Badges
Joined
Nov 24, 2020
Messages
254
Reaction score
203
Location
Avon, NC
Jay,

I'm a little confused by this statement in your article: "Presently, many aquarists try to soak their fish food in medication and then feed that to their fish. The trouble is that this can never really work. Oral fish medications are always dosed on an “as fed basis”, usually milligrams of medication per kilogram of fish biomass. In the case of soaking food in medication; the amount of medication per gram of food is unknown, as is the weight of the fish, and so is the amount of food being fed. With that many variables, a proper dose simply cannot be formulated.".

You then give a thorough explanation of how it is done. So, is it even worthwhile to try to make your own medicated food? That's what I've tried to do, but now I wonder if I've wasted my time? I've tried to use fish weight formulas to determine the amount of food to feed similar to what you've included in the article and feel they are reasonably useful as a starting point to avoid over/underfeeding.

I'm going to assume it is worthwhile to do and that I've misinterpreted the above quoted statement.

Thanks
 
OP
Jay Hemdal

Jay Hemdal

5000 Club Member
View Badges
Joined
Jul 31, 2020
Messages
6,642
Reaction score
6,270
Location
Dundee
Jay,

I'm a little confused by this statement in your article: "Presently, many aquarists try to soak their fish food in medication and then feed that to their fish. The trouble is that this can never really work. Oral fish medications are always dosed on an “as fed basis”, usually milligrams of medication per kilogram of fish biomass. In the case of soaking food in medication; the amount of medication per gram of food is unknown, as is the weight of the fish, and so is the amount of food being fed. With that many variables, a proper dose simply cannot be formulated.".

You then give a thorough explanation of how it is done. So, is it even worthwhile to try to make your own medicated food? That's what I've tried to do, but now I wonder if I've wasted my time? I've tried to use fish weight formulas to determine the amount of food to feed similar to what you've included in the article and feel they are reasonably useful as a starting point to avoid over/underfeeding.

I'm going to assume it is worthwhile to do and that I've misinterpreted the above quoted statement.

Thanks
What I am describing is the technique some people use of just soaking their food in medication as opposed to the proper way of measuring it and mixing it into a gel diet that is then fed on a prescribed basis.
When you soak food in medication, you have no way of knowing the dose, and you also have no way to know how much rinses right off when you add it to the tank.
Jay
 

Have you ever had a Angelfish in your reef tank?

  • Yes and it was a model citizen (tell us which one)

    Votes: 105 32.2%
  • Yes but it did nip from time to time

    Votes: 47 14.4%
  • Yes but I had to remove it because it went rogue

    Votes: 27 8.3%
  • No but I would like to try one

    Votes: 93 28.5%
  • No and not interested

    Votes: 42 12.9%
  • Other (please explain)

    Votes: 12 3.7%
Frag Farm
Top