• For a Limited Time the R2R Partner Membership is NOW OPEN! Get some cool swag and chances to win part of over $20,000 in prizes! Click here for more details

Shrooms, The Latest Hot Trend???

Legendary Corals

Vendor Extraordinair
View Badges
Joined
Dec 25, 2013
Messages
1,456
Reaction score
803
Location
San Jose/Bay Area, CA
Shrooms, The Latest Hot Trend???

Hello fellow reefers,

Darwin here with another blog like story time post! I've been talking about this subject with a couple of friends and it's very noticeable that the demand for these squishies has skyrocketed in the past couple of years. Some people even make it a mission to collect every new piece that comes out now (or even some people who make a vow to collect all the nicest jawbreakers out there *cough cough*). But it wasn't always like this, and I thought it would be interesting to dive a little deeper into what makes these shrooms so intriguing all of a sudden along with a couple of highlights on the hottest pieces going out. :)

A long time ago, in a reef tank far far away, mushroom corals have been passed down for generations as being the ultimate beginner's corals to the point where reefers would be telling each other to never keep one in their reef in fear of an invasion. That simple red or blue shroom that looked good in the local fish store quickly became more annoying than aptasia and was branded off as being a pest.

3.jpg

It all started with one harmless little blue shroom... That's now the size of a tang.

But oddly enough, lately it's been the opposite. There's been a surge of demand for all sorts of mushrooms from rhodactus, discosoma, ricordeas, st thomas, and the latest demand, bubbly sp. unknown. We've gone past the point where we see these corals as pests geared only towards beginners and started to scarf up any type of variety we can. Any unique kind of coloration demands top dollars now. Groups started to appear specifically made to appreciate these corals, and the amount of activity in these groups are growing everyday. These easy to care for softies are starting to get love from all over the country.

4.jpg

Over 2000 members and growing everyday! Who knew so many people would specifically love these squishies?

But it's not just the United States that's started to love these corals. People overseas are even creating groups just for shrooms! The trend and demand for mushrooms is definitely noticeable, and something that's only recently occurred in this scale.

5.jpg

People over in the UK are creating new groups to enjoy these squishies along with their cup of tea.

Where this latest craze came from is unknown. But thinking back on it, I believe what sparked this new found interest in mushrooms was the introduction of the WWC Bounce Shroom, which became the latest high end shroom since the Jawbreaker/ Tye Dye. Ever since the introduction of this unique shroom, the interest for all sorts of mushrooms started to appear. Simple shaggy looking mushrooms and rhodactus that just happened to get bubbly became top dollar pieces, sought after for the bubbly trait that makes the WWC Bounce so unique. Can we imagine what the demand for bubbly shrooms would be without the WWC Bounce??? I personally don't think it would be any where near what it is now.

6.jpg

A simple green and orange rhodactus. But now worth 10x as much because it's gained one bubble? The thirst for bubbles is real.

7.jpg

It's brown and grey in base coloration, but those sweet looking bubbles sure make up for it. IMO, the shroom that started the craze.

With the bounce setting a firey passion for mushrooms, hobbyist began to notice mushrooms again when new pieces came in. Let's view some of the unique pieces that have been hitting the scene, listed by species!

Discosoma
This was the first shroom species to start the craze with the infamous Jawbreaker/ Tye Dye. Now there are a couple of other heavy hitters that have joined the spotlight and are sought after by reefers all over (I believe this is the group that has the most famous pieces). These shrooms are characterized by their smooth shiny bodies. In my experience, these are the most finicky and most likely to float off when upset (all you disco collectors know this pain, especially those JB hunters).

The Jawbreaker:
This shroom is the first high end shroom to hit the hobby. Collected from Vietnam, this mushroom is infamous for gaining more colors as it matures. The colorations typically starts with orange/yellow, red, green, and (if you're lucky) purple. This is what I know of for how it got into the hobby (I'd love it if someone else who knew more about this shroom could shed light on it as well). The mushroom came into the Bay Area, California and went under the care of Dr. Lee of Aquatic Gallery. From there, pieces of the babies sold locally and the jawbreaker strain was spread. Now we'll go into the infamous The Tye Dye/ Jawbreaker debate. From what I've learned over the years, the Jawbreaker mother was purchased from Aquatic Gallery and sold through very few locals (1-2 people) until it got into the hands of TDF. When I was young, I do recall seeing a shroom that looked just like the infamous photo from TDF of the Tye Dye at Aquatic Gallery. So from what I can recall, it does support this story that the original Jawbreaker and Tye Dye are the same. This is just what I know of, so if someone else who has talked to these fine folks of the older reefing days please chime in! Based on the stories I've heard, I believe that Jawbreakers and Tye Dyes are the same, for I've seen Jawbreakers that get the infamous purple that people believe only Tye Dyes get (like the one we own in the photo :angel:).

Excerpt from Kmaintl: In short, the original Jawbreaker is what is now sought after as Tye Dye.
"I am hardly ever on the forums nowadays... but someone (not RichieT) forwarded me this thread. BTW, Darwin, great writeup and looks like you and your partners are doing well with your new venture.

What you state is correct. I never disclosed Dr. Li's name nor the first hobbyist that purchased the original mother from Dr. Li because he asked me not to and I respected his wishes. The first hobbyist that owned the Mother Jawbreaker (assumed it was named by Dr. Li as he was first to receive this import around 9 years ago now) was one of my customers who purchase reef equipment and I purchased some corals from him for my other customers. He shall remain nameless until he changes his mind and would like to reveal his identity. He lived in San Jose area and I still remember the month he brought the Mother Jawbreaker home, my jaw dropped when I saw it. So, the name for the mushroom was appropriate.

My colony is shared ownership with my son-in-law's younger brothers and we still have our original 1st daughter that was produced by the original Mother Jawbreaker that now resides with Zack at TDF. Since we've owned the colony for 9 years now, we've kept at least 9 granddaughters with nice amount of green and one of them actually had purple before that tank crash and we lost her. 2 years ago, we split the mother colony among the 3 partners and each has several green polyps in their colony. We still keep a mother colony where we frag out for sales, so we do have frags throughout the year. The zoo location is SF is where our mother colony is located.


The 2nd daughter went to a hobbyist in Sacto area, who sold it 3 years ago when he was relocated to Hawaii. He sold everything before moving. The 3rd daughter is still in the San Jose area and I don't know much about the history behind the 3rd daughter. But as of 3 years ago, the hobbyist that owned the original Mother Jawbreaker said the 3rd owner never dropped a baby, just got very big and happily settled in one place in his tank.

Getting back to history, Rommel made the San Jose hobbyist an offer he couldn't refuse (to this day my San Jose customer regrets letting go of the Mother Jawbreaker) and Rommel flip it and sold to Zack at TDF. My only regret is seeing the original Mother Jawbreaker escape from the West Coast. Zack didn't know that the Jawbreaker already had a name and said that Rommel referred to it as a mystery mushroom, unknown and one of a kind. So, Zack named it Mystery TieDye as that's what the Mother looks like.

There is at least 3 lineages of mushrooms called Jawbreakers and that's what makes it confusing. Unless yours leads back to TDF's Mother, you don't have the one that grows to about 5"-6" across, comes in with green and purple as it matures. The other lineages that came in about 9 years ago only grows to about 2"-2.5" and only red and orange. The lineage that came in about 2 years ago is smooth and small, but has the 3 colors quickly. The newest lineage also faster grower. HTH so, yes, one of Jawbreaker lineage is the same as the Mystery TieDye, not the others. "

8.jpg


The Red Devil Shroom:
This shroom is one all hard core collectors know about. The red and blue version of a Jawbreaker... the Red Devil! This shroom starts off as all red and gains beautiful baby blue speckles on a maroon/ purple splotchy body as it matures. Very few reefers still have this unique mushroom.

9.jpg

The infamous Red Devil... This is the oldest photo I can find of this fine gem.

The Electus Mushroom:
The newest discosoma to make a hit in the reefing scene... The Eclectus Shroom! This one is very similar to the Jawbreaker but instead of red streaks it has unique looking spots. Whether or not it gets green or purple like the Jawbreaker does is unknown. It seems like the lucky few vendors that got their hands on one are growing them out.

10.jpg


The Vietnam Shrooms:
Vietnam is the origin of the Jawbreaker, so it's no surprise that there are lots of sweet shrooms coming in from Vietnam again. Most of these discosomas are a variation similar to the Jawbreaker (some even looking the same).

11.jpg


12.jpg


13.jpg


Let's talk about another shroom family now, this time it's going to get fuzzy!

Rhodactus
These guys are characterized by their fuzzy bodies. It's argued that the Bounce is a type of rhodactus based on its body. I mean, if you think about it... Pop the bubbles off a Bounce and you're left with a grey rhodactus (who wants to volunteer and cut those bubbles off? :nerd:). Rhodactus come in an assort of colors and patterns, even some with weird bodies.

14.jpg

This is one type of rhodactus, which is the smoother variety.

15.jpg

Yet this is also a rhodactus! This one is usually called a "hairy" rhodactus.

16.jpg

And this is also a rhodactus! This one is generally called a "carpet" rhodactus. They come in so many different body types.

17.jpg

And lastly... The debatable. Labeled as Rhodactus Sp. What reefers would do for such a rock now!

Ricordeas, Florida and Yuma
The last of the groups I'm going to be covering are the ricordeas. Sadly, this is the group that's been grouped altogether and uniqueness for these guys aren't as sought after anymore. They fall more so under a "grading scale" than desired traits. This is most likely because because the color variation from one piece to another is so different that it's hard for people to try to go after a specific strain of ricordea. These guys don't get any fancy names like the other shrooms but are still loved for their vibrant colors.

Florida:
These guys are collected mostly from Florida, but some strains are collected from Puerto Rico or Haiti which get colors we don't see too often (such as red mouths). Both have similar care, with the Florida pieces coming in rubble the Puerto Rican/ Haitian pieces coming in rock. These guys are still a mystery to me, as some reefers can keep them without any issues while others have constant problems and can't keep them happy even with a full blown mixed reef.

18.JPG

So much color on a shroom. It's no wonder why they're so popular with reefers of all experience.

19.jpg

The infamous red mouths of Haitan Ricordeas

Yuma:
These guys are the risk takers of the shroom family. Known for being infamous melters, reefers still buy them in the attempt of being able to find one healthy yuma to oggle at home. It's almost a checklist of all established reefs to have a sweet happy yuma. These guys come in all sorts of colors and also follow a similar grading scale to Floridas, with green being the low end to pink and rainbows being the most sought after. Yumas are have a more hairy appearance and are also much larger than Floridas.

20.jpg

Finding a pink yuma that won't melt is on the list for many reefers!

I hope you enjoyed my little cap on mushrooms, would love to hear your thoughts on this new trend along with photos of your favorite shroomy!

Cheers,
Darwin
 
Last edited:

saltyphish

Certified Sand Groomer
View Badges
Joined
May 9, 2014
Messages
2,622
Reaction score
698
Location
Middletown, Ohio
Agreed! Love my shrooms. Been trying to talk myself into buying that rainbow you posted earlier. Although I must admit I do not see what the craze is over the bounce shrooms. Just don't seem worth the money to me.......yet!
 

nassar0505

New Member
View Badges
Joined
Dec 9, 2013
Messages
4
Reaction score
0
Location
Alpharetta, GA
Good stuff.

This does seem to be the latest hot trend, I've been on SPS for years now and now have tank dedicated to shrooms. Marketing of rarities and unique corals does a number on our brains.

This truly is an ever evolving hobby and industry. I guess you can't tame the never ending evolution of life.

Please take my money shroom gods.
 

Wesley42079

Valuable Member
View Badges
Joined
Jun 7, 2011
Messages
1,931
Reaction score
232
Location
SAn Jose
Here is some info I found in an old Jawbreaker Mushrooms thread. Below is Zach's story on how he aquired and later renamed the Tie Dye mushroom.


I was actually the lucky fella that picked the original tie dye from Rommel. Never regretted that buy one bit. It is a slow grower, but that's never bothered me. It's amazing to watch the colors develop over time. When I got it from Rommel he simply called it The Mystery Mushroom. I felt Tie Dye was a very aprapos name, so I tacked it on (heck, I bought it, so I could call it what I wanted!). It didn't produce any babies for me for over a year, then slowly started pushing out polyps from the foot. I only get a couple to a few a year from the largest polyps even to this day, but I find that's plenty for me. I've never tried forced propagation as I wouldn't want to do such a thing to my prized shrooms.

I will say that after having acquired some of the other lineage commonly referred to as Jawbreakers, I'm convinced there are definitely at least two different kinds of mushrooms out there. From the very start the babies look very different and the color development is very different as well. I regularly get tie dye babies that show red stripes from the start, and even some that show green right away. Every polyp is different, so the colors develop uniquely on each one and time tables can vary a lot. The jawbreakers have yet to develop anything but red spots and a few stripes for me. The jawbreakers also get no where near as big, and babies are tiny compared to Tie Dye babies. Babies from the Tie Dye can be 1"+ at times, whereas jawbreakers are pencil eraser-sized and only golden orange. All this makes me think it's even more imperative to make sure there is a distinction between the two classes of Jawbreakers out there, and naturally I like the Tie Dye moniker.
 
OP
Legendary Corals

Legendary Corals

Vendor Extraordinair
View Badges
Joined
Dec 25, 2013
Messages
1,456
Reaction score
803
Location
San Jose/Bay Area, CA
Good read,,,, thanks for taking the time to post :)
Glad you enjoyed it! These coral articles are a lot of fun to write and it's nice to know people like to read them. What should I do next? :)


Great write up. I started in the hobby big in acros but now I'm way more into the shrooms for ease of keeping and large patches of vibrant colors in the tank :)
I'm actually going to dedicate a larger portion of my display to shrooms. I love how easy and colorful they are just like you, and if you're someone who sometimes gets too busy for sticks, these are a great trade off!

Agreed! Love my shrooms. Been trying to talk myself into buying that rainbow you posted earlier. Although I must admit I do not see what the craze is over the bounce shrooms. Just don't seem worth the money to me.......yet!
As a fellow shroom lover, I highly recommend that you pick it up. :wink:

There's actually a bunch of unique looking shrooms out right now that I personally love for their uniqueness, but the price on some of them make you go "huh" since they're mostly brown with just a few bubbles. My friends who aren't in the hobby always point at my PZ Godspawn (very similar to WWC Bounce) and say it's the dumbest thing in my tank. LOL.

Good stuff.

This does seem to be the latest hot trend, I've been on SPS for years now and now have tank dedicated to shrooms. Marketing of rarities and unique corals does a number on our brains.

This truly is an ever evolving hobby and industry. I guess you can't tame the never ending evolution of life.

Please take my money shroom gods.
But that's what makes this hobby so interesting. It's never ending surprises.

Great post, would also like to see some info on st thomas shrooms.
Is the WWC Bounce a St. Thomas mushroom?
I didn't include St. Thomas' because I thought not enough people would know about them (and also because I hit the limit on photos in one post lol) but I'll make an add on for them just for you guys! :)
@Maximus, I don't believe the Bounce is a St. Thomas shroom. St. Thomas is bubbly throughout the entire body has has a smooth underbody. The WWC Bounce only gains random spots that become the bubbles. If you cut all the bubbles off of a Bounce, you're only left with a grey shaggy shroom, which looks most likely a grey carpet rhodactus. Thinking of a Bounce this way, I think they are most likely a rhodactus. Perhaps there's a species of rhodactus that we just haven't grouped yet as hobbyist and all these bubbly types belong there.

Here's a couple more "bouncy" type shrooms that also have a shaggy body like most rhodactus but have bubbles. I think looking at these examples helps to group them under Rhodactus. Just remember to imagine that you cut those bubbles off... Then all you're left with is a shaggy rhodactus.









Compared to St. Thomas, which is smoother bodied and bubbly throughout. These guys are typically collected throughout the Caribbean just like Ricordea Floridas. These shroomies are one of my favorites, since they're so large and almost always come in a beautiful color. They are relatively hardy but do give them ample room since some pieces can get 4" across when fully grown. The grading scale on these are a bit odd, since they come in different shades of colors. I'd say the lower grades are the greyish blue, then green and solid blues, and then red being the most sought after. There are a couple of unique rainbow like pieces (like mine below) that also are hard to find.

There are two different types of St Thomas shrooms from what I've noticed, the bubbly and the shaggy, but I believe they are both collected in the Carribeans. AquaScapers collects their corals around Florida and offer both varieties, so using them as a reference helps support that they are both from the same place even if they look different.


It's just green, but man is it cool!


The much coveted Red St. Thomas variety. Definitely an eye catcher and a must have for any shroom lover. They come in once in awhile, and always have a high price tag.


And if you're lucky, maybe you'll snag a rainbow variety. ;)


One more type of shroom I'd like to mention is another beauty from the caribbeans, but not many people know of... The Carlgrenis!

Carlgreni:
These guys pack a PUNCH! These shrooms are a weird hybrid between a rhodactus and a discosoma. These guys are another personal favorite, but I haven't had much luck keeping them in captivity. They come in all sorts of colors and have a really unique body, which is my favorite part about them.


Look how many colors are on this guy!!!


Sweet little red carlgreni.


They even come in black and white!
 

kschweer

Zoas!!!
View Badges
Joined
Mar 25, 2011
Messages
12,036
Reaction score
30,558
Location
New Jersey
Nice write up Darwin! I was also curious about what kind of shroom the "bounce" type shrooms were. I thought it was simply a rhodactis that for some reason bubbled in certain conditions. Doing a little more research I think they may be a species of rhodactis, Rhodactis Sanctithomae. Not 100% positive but think it may be a possibility.
 
OP
Legendary Corals

Legendary Corals

Vendor Extraordinair
View Badges
Joined
Dec 25, 2013
Messages
1,456
Reaction score
803
Location
San Jose/Bay Area, CA
Here is some info I found in an old Jawbreaker Mushrooms thread. Below is Zach's story on how he aquired and later renamed the Tie Dye mushroom.
This actually helps support my theory that the jawbreaker and Tye Dye are the same. Rommel was based in San Jose. So he could have bought the mother from Aquatic Gallery and then it's already known that Zack/ TDF got it from Rommel. If that's true, this helps fill in some gaps in the mystery of the Jawbreaker vs Tye Dye.
 

RichieT

Valuable Member
View Badges
Joined
Feb 27, 2012
Messages
2,404
Reaction score
50
Location
San Francisco, CA
This actually helps support my theory that the jawbreaker and Tye Dye are the same. Rommel was based in San Jose. So he could have bought the mother from Aquatic Gallery and then it's already known that Zack/ TDF got it from Rommel. If that's true, this helps fill in some gaps in the mystery of the Jawbreaker vs Tye Dye.
Just give Ed a call and have him explain the backstory. Then compare that to mark's story.
 
OP
Legendary Corals

Legendary Corals

Vendor Extraordinair
View Badges
Joined
Dec 25, 2013
Messages
1,456
Reaction score
803
Location
San Jose/Bay Area, CA
Just give Ed a call and have him explain the backstory. Then compare that to mark's story.
Guess that'll be on the to do list. I think an article that explains the lineage of Jawbreakers and Tye Dyes and if there truly is a difference will be awesome.

Great post, thanks for the write up - And the great pics!
Thanks shornik! I can't take the credit for the photos, as most of them were just from google. :)
 

How many corals do you have in your reef tank?

  • 1 - 5

    Votes: 68 8.9%
  • 6 - 10

    Votes: 99 12.9%
  • 11 - 20

    Votes: 174 22.7%
  • 21 - 30

    Votes: 112 14.6%
  • 31 - 50

    Votes: 121 15.8%
  • 51 - 75

    Votes: 66 8.6%
  • 76 - 100

    Votes: 48 6.3%
  • 100+

    Votes: 77 10.1%

Online statistics

Members online
2,547
Guests online
5,418
Total visitors
7,965
GHL Advanced Technology
Top