I have to be honest, I would keep the T5! Here is why: Like you mentioned, it does help with shading, but where I find the T5 to be worth they're money is in the variance of colors that the corals can produce with having them. I added a 2 bulb t5 fixture over my 75 gallon DT, which have Kessil lights on them and Par wasn't an issue. But in the 3 weeks time of having the t5 on for 4 hours a day, my Dragon Soul torch looks a lot more gold now, and I noticed some bounce mushrooms appearing with more color too! T5 for the win. Nothing else changed in the tank