Target Mandarin Eating, but Still Skinny

[Adamantium]

Hi all, I recently (maybe two weeks ago) got a target mandarin. I was PSYCHED to see him eat spirulina brine in the store, which he continues to eat in my tank. The problem is, he doesn't seem to be gaining any weight. Am I just getting too nervous too quickly? My other fish get big bellies when they eat, but this guy continues to look emaciated, even when I see him eat 5+ pieces of spirulina brine (he's only 1.5" or so).

My main concern/question is whether or not he may have a parasite. Any thoughts? Thanks, all.

 

[Alexreefer]

Hi all, I recently (maybe two weeks ago) got a target mandarin. I was PSYCHED to see him eat spirulina brine in the store, which he continues to eat in my tank. The problem is, he doesn't seem to be gaining any weight. Am I just getting too nervous too quickly? My other fish get big bellies when they eat, but this guy continues to look emaciated, even when I see him eat 5+ pieces of spirulina brine (he's only 1.5" or so).

My main concern/question is whether or not he may have a parasite. Any thoughts? Thanks, all.

Sadly you cannot feed him on brine. His main diet consists of pods. How big is your tank, and have you added pods?

 

[Adamantium]

Sadly you cannot feed him on brine. His main diet consists of pods. How big is your tank, and have you added pods?

Do you mean brine (even with spirulina) is just not nutritional enough for him? He's in a 40B, and no I have not added any, but it has my old live rock, a refugium, and my old pod hotel in it so there are definitely some in there.

 

[Reef AquaCult]

Your tank should be teeming with pods all over glass and live rock in order to have a fat mandarin. 40B is too small for long term success IMO

if you can get him onto Mysis that’s much better nutrition but still needs more pods

 

[Malifry97]

mysis, spirulina brine and pods would be enough. I'd say add pods once every three to four weeks and you'll be fine. Just try to get him on mysis

 

[Adamantium]

mysis, spirulina brine and pods would be enough. I'd say add pods once every three to four weeks and you'll be fine. Just try to get him on mysis

Is mysis more nutritional than spirulina brine? Could that be my issue?

 

[Adamantium]

Your tank should be teeming with pods all over glass and live rock in order to have a fat mandarin. 40B is too small for long term success IMO

if you can get him onto Mysis that’s much better nutrition but still needs more pods

So mysis are more nutritionally dense than spirulina brine? I also add selcon.

 

[Malifry97]

Is mysis more nutritional than spirulina brine? Could that be my issue?

Yea mysis is definetly more nutritionally dense. But I'd do both along with pods and your selcon

 

[Nep2nRevision3]

I have a wild caught Mandarin in a 45 cube (tied into a much larger +/- 300 g system) that's fat and happy. Live pods are the #1 choice food for sure but I also supplement every other day with Elos Cyclops (see Algae Barn) fed with a pipet. They used to sell a product called Can-O-Cyclops but I think they've switched over to the Elos exclusively now. It's a canned food that she eats with no hesitation. Basically suspended pods. I've had her for 9 months now and again, FAT and happy.
PS: Might also want to check out their Mandarin Feeder Kit.

 

[Adamantium]

Well this is a bit of a bummer. I just tried feeding PEMysis, and he seemed totally disinterested. I’m hoping it’s just because it’s pretty old. I’ll pick up some fresh Mysis and see what happens.

 

[najer]

Well this is a bit of a bummer. I just tried feeding PEMysis, and he seemed totally disinterested. I’m hoping it’s just because it’s pretty old. I’ll pick up some fresh Mysis and see what happens.

Pods, pods and pods as mentioned and live phyto to help feed them and the tank, it's instinct is to eat all day long, I got a little one inch rescue a couple of months ago and put it in my little tank to fatten up, if I can get her on prepared foods all well and good.

 

[pcon]

If you don't have a sufficient pod population, which a 40gal almost certainly will not without a large refugium attached, then they need supplemental feedings several times a day. Many sources recommend over 3 feedings a day to keep up with their fast metabolism. As stated by others they naturally feed throughout the day, so need food supplied frequently.

 

[Nick Steele]

Yeah how many times a day are you feeding? It needs more than just one feeding a day for sure!

 

[OrionN]

What other fish are in there. I agree that you are going to be a slave to him because if you want him to live it will be hard work to feed him.

 

[Adamantium]

Yeah how many times a day are you feeding? It needs more than just one feeding a day for sure!

2-3 times a day, and I feed enough that a good portion makes it to the sand bed for him.

 

[Big G]

2-3 times a day, and I feed enough that a good portion makes it to the sand bed for him.

They are constant grazers looking for food. Might want to check out the pods as mentioned. Important to source "clean" pods from places that don't have fish in their system that can carry parasites into your tank. Algaebarn might be a good place to take a look. Very nice people.

 

[Uncle99]

This ones over three years old now.
Eats nothing but PODs, just lets everything else go by.
Since he’s the only POD eater in a very mature tank, always plenty.

 

[calvertc425]

Feed frozen bloodworms and then start mixing in my sis with it they alway eat them
ive had several and they eat frozen bloodworms without fail I have found andmine Was super skinny when I bought it two months ago and now it has the fastest belly and I feed it twice a day but I also have a lot of pods and he’s in my 55 gallon reef

 

[Paul B]

2 or 3 times a day is not near enough to feed a mandarin. They need to eat constantly.

Paul B’s Unique Perspective on Keeping Mandarins

Hobby pioneer Paul “Paul B” Baldassano is not your grandfather’s reefkeeper (though he is old enough to be your grandfather!). In fact, Paul B’s perspective on just about any aspect of the marine a…

www.saltwatersmarts.com

 

[Adamantium]

Just wanted to give an update here. He’s fattening up nicely! I switched over to mysis, and he’s gotten noticeably chunkier. He eats like an absolute champ. Comes right up to the top of the water column with everyone else. I’m downright chuffed