The (Almost) "Full Monti": A biased and overly-opinionated look at the genus Montipora...

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Total: 1, Members: 0, Guests: 1)

uniquecorals

UniqueCorals
View Badges
Joined
Nov 23, 2006
Messages
12,791
Reaction score
10,593
Location
Los Angeles
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Ahh, the genus Montipora…Popular, yet somehow always seen as the forgotten little brother to the genus Acropora, right? They don't get all the glamour and press of the Acros, but the Monties are certainly interesting and worth keeping in their own right. The sheer variety of species and colors in the genus alone make it worth keeping. They range from the simply super easy to keep to the challenging. Some are just dumb, though. Really. I've made that conclusion.

I distinctly recall that, in the So Cal area, when you started a reef tank, you were literally “issued” at least a few frags of Orange Montipora capricornus, and a couple of digitata as well! Our little ritual..Sort of like getting the keys to your first car, or getting your first razor…. A right of passage as a reefer! And, when your colony grew large enough, you fragged it and “paid it forward” to someone else. It could be argued that the basis for the modern frag swap as we know it evolved around the genus Montipora!


UC1inch-uc-red-monti-cap-32-inventory-6.jpg

No! No! No! No! No!

One thing I must admit: What used to turn me off the most about this genus is the obligatory “Monti Cap Blend” that every reef tank in the history of the hobby has tried: You know, the result of mixing a Green and an Orange Monti Cap together to swirl into each other….If I see another one of those, I swear I’ll hurl on my keyboard…total reef FAIL, if you ask me. Just LAME!

(OK, the “insult portion” of this piece was dispatched early, for a change…!)

Ahh- random fact: Did you know that Charlie Veron named M. capricornus in 1985? Kinda cool, huh? A product of the cool decade..but I still am kinda over this species...

Oh, I hate M. digitata, too! It was the first species I actually "fragged." In the wild, no less. Unintentionally, actually. Yeah, ran over it with my surfboard in Fiji in 1987, and it destroyed the bottom of my brand-new board, and gave me a nice permanent scar on the bottom of my ankle...on day TWO of my 14-day dream surf trip...Had to ride my backup board after the third-world-style stitch job on my foot..Perhaps that's why I have severe anger management issues with this genus? Maybe. But I digress...

Rather than a detailed taxonomic and scientific review of every aspect of the genus and it's care, which you would stone me to death for anyways, let’s do it MY way, and just skip around all over the place in my typical ADD fashion ( meaning that we cover an aspect of keeping this coral when it pops into my head), and briefly review some of the practical aspects of Montipora care in the reef aquarium.

Oh, my spell check on my MacBook constantly corrects M. digitata to "digital." Apparently, Apple hates this species, too!

First off, most Montipora don’t like to get just blasted with light. I say this while biting my tongue, because, as you know- making sweeping general statements just horrifies me. The reality is that some species can take bright light quite well. Although, I have to tell you, we found through hard-won trial and error that some species and color morphs, such as the Sunset Monties, were not particularly thrilled being placed right under 400 watt halides, and they let us know their displeasure rather overtly. Others, like Montipora aequatuberculata, and Montipora capricornus, seem to like baking a bit. I’d throw M. digitata, M. confusa, and M. spongodes into that category.

UC1inch-sanjay-neon-green-monti-confusa-38-inventory-6.jpg

Sanjay...we still have your M. confusa!

Gadget freaks rejoice, because Monties benefit from respectable Ca levels, which means that you get to keep the calcium reactor going. All the joy of regulators, bubble counters, and media replacement! Woo Hoo!

Most Monties seem to tolerate strong water movement okay, but they definitely do NOT like getting slammed with current directly onto their tissues. When we say “moderate” flow, we mean areas of your reef where water movement is significantly reduced from the volume it’s at when it emerges from your returns or powerbeads. Flow is still important to Montipora, as it helps keep them sediment- free, provides gas exchange, and encourages growth.

Ohhh- random fact: Monties are like the wimpiest corals around, the proverbial geek on the playground- and most just get the crap kicked out of them by more aggressive corals, so be sure to provide them with space between them and their neighbors!

We talk a lot in this forum about keeping your reef clean, but not sterile, as most corals seem to do well under these conditions, and Montipora are no exception. They show the best colors and growth in water than has some nutrients in it. Again, this is not a call to kick the nitrate up to 50ppm and phosphates to 10ppm- it’s a call for some common-sense, slightly more relaxed husbandry, where you won’t run off, screaming into the night when your Salifert indicates 5ppm nitrate!

Montipora respond beautifully to the addition of amino acid supplements (We LOVE AcroPower!) and potassium in their water. You’ll notice a darned-near “miraculous” change in their growth and coloration when you do the “before/after” comparison, trust me! The encrusting varieties, like M. undata, M. danae, and the like really show a great response!

monti-danae-purple-haze-monti.jpg

"Excuse me, while I kiss the sky..." The "Purple Haze", M. danae rocks!

Most Monties frag really easily, and recover well. The key is to give them a gentle dip after fragging, and allow sufficient time for them to recover before you start giving them to friends or trading them at the next swap. “Fresh cut” Monties are particularly susceptible to bacterial infections, so this is quite important. Colonies typically are non the worse for wear after fragging, and this includes the poster child M. capricornus, unfortunately...

Random thought #13,454: I think it would be cool to create a “Montipora Tank”, because there is such variety and contrast between members of this genus. Not just species, but color morphs and even growth forms within a species. Ok, do it…But no Monti Cap “Blends!”

Some of the real weirdos of the genus include Montipora mollis, AKA the “Pink Cadillac Monti”, which has a cool color and a “strawberry-skinned” appearance that’s just plain cool, Montipora confusa, which looks simply alien (if SPS existed on Mars, they would be confuse, for sure), and my personal fave, Montipora stellata, which looks almost Acropora-like. And then, there is the “Sand Dollar Monti, M. venosa...A crazy looking coral, too. I like M. setosa because reefers get true "grafts" out of different color morphs, which is cool. hey, "venosa" and "setosa"- Sounds like a law firm, huh?


UC1andhalfinch-pink-cadillac-monti-monti-mollis-58.jpg

The "Pink Cadillac..."

ORA produces the "Elkhorn" Montipora, M. hirsuta, which is pretty funky as well. Not to be outdone by the "Sunset Montipora", M. danae, which has become an "LE" coral in some parts...That's funny, because they are found in the ocean- not sure why they are "LE". Someone must have been at it genetically engineering a new coral again...Oh, wait, no- someone just found a couple of really colorful pieces in a wild shipment, hoarded them and named them, and charged a much higher price for them because...um, because..? Well...whatever...Not sure why, actually. Besides, it's a Monti...Man, even I'm dissing this genus.

UC1andquarterinch-DR-sunset-monti-48.jpg

The "Sunset Monti." They call it "LE." Science calls it M. danae.

I haven't taken my morning run yet, so I'm obviously wound up here...

One of the nicest things about Monties is that they are remarkably adaptable. In our experience, adaptation to new lighting regimens seems to be the only real challenge we encounter with different species. Other than that, they cheerfully acclimate to new systems with an ease that I should envy. And, they do have remarkably rapid growth in many cases, which is a benefit for us commercial types, and a real benefit to- well- themselves- because if we really are on our game, we can count many Monties among the species that we will ultimately not need to bring in from the wild reefs any more to satisfy demand.

Okay, I can go on and on about this genus, and I would, seriously, but I'm just still ticked off by my recollection of the Fiji/digitata thing, so I'm calling it for now...:crazy:

As always, this is ridiculously open source, so feel free to inject your stories, pics, and observations on Monties! I know at least a few of you wise guys/girls are gonna post up your Monti Cap swirls just to tick me off....LOL

So go hack up your Caps, glue your Digis, and drool over your setosas. And most important of all..

Stay Wet!

See you Monday!


Scott Fellman
Unique Corals
 
Last edited:

GHill762

Valuable Member
View Badges
Joined
Sep 18, 2012
Messages
1,177
Reaction score
18
Location
Illinois/Midwest
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
I love my montis.. I've got an elkhorn that grows like a weed, a red digi that loves getting blasted with light, a brown confusa, and several different caps.. one cap just up and rtn'd on me for no reason the other day, its' actually starting to re-grow though.. my confusa absolutely refuses to color up, as does my green with blue polyp cap (it's got bright blue polys, grows fairly well, has great PE, but the "body" has no color - it's nearly white - always has been).

great read, as always..
 
OP
OP
uniquecorals

uniquecorals

UniqueCorals
View Badges
Joined
Nov 23, 2006
Messages
12,791
Reaction score
10,593
Location
Los Angeles
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
I love my montis.. I've got an elkhorn that grows like a weed, a red digi that loves getting blasted with light, a brown confusa, and several different caps.. one cap just up and rtn'd on me for no reason the other day, its' actually starting to re-grow though.. my confusa absolutely refuses to color up, as does my green with blue polyp cap (it's got bright blue polys, grows fairly well, has great PE, but the "body" has no color - it's nearly white - always has been).

great read, as always..

Thanks for the kind words...

Yeah, they sometimes go into what I like to call a "safe mode", where they just sorta don't look so good all the sudden...then, inexplicably, they re-blossom into their former glory yet again...A weird phenomenon! Like doe many things in reefing- patience is the key, I suppose!

-Scott
 

stylaster

Reefer since '90
View Badges
Joined
Jun 3, 2008
Messages
1,951
Reaction score
670
Location
Kelso, WA
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Great monti writeup, and i gotta say my favorite of the genus is the montipora stellatas
 

Railcar79

Well-Known Member
View Badges
Joined
Jun 4, 2013
Messages
550
Reaction score
6
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Nice read, good to know someone else isnt a fan. I am one of the few reefers that has never had and, god willing will never have a montipora. To me it is far too common, everyone has it, not that interesting. Please let loose on my favorite Acan Lordhowensis...
 

Greenstreet.1

5000 Club Member
View Badges
Joined
Oct 16, 2013
Messages
5,719
Reaction score
3,242
Location
Li New York
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Well can't say I feel the hate cause it's hard for me to hate on sps and I do have a small thing for monti's lol.


a6u4ypeh.jpg


e4e3ypa9.jpg


u7e6eryr.jpg


yny5ypy4.jpg


apuveser.jpg
u3evujy5.jpg
 
OP
OP
uniquecorals

uniquecorals

UniqueCorals
View Badges
Joined
Nov 23, 2006
Messages
12,791
Reaction score
10,593
Location
Los Angeles
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Nice read, good to know someone else isnt a fan. I am one of the few reefers that has never had and, god willing will never have a montipora. To me it is far too common, everyone has it, not that interesting. Please let loose on my favorite Acan Lordhowensis...

I just dislike Monti Caps and digis, but the rest are sort of cool...particularly the oddball ones. But some of the encrusting forms would be finalists in the ugly corals competition for sure! LOL
-Scott
 

Railcar79

Well-Known Member
View Badges
Joined
Jun 4, 2013
Messages
550
Reaction score
6
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Only one I would consider is the Jason fox beach bum. That one....yeah.... Coral **** at its finest
 

Eienna

5000 Club Member
View Badges
Joined
Feb 9, 2013
Messages
5,758
Reaction score
549
Location
Eddyville, KY, USA
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
I managed to be one of the few who have managed to kill their monti frags...the first bleached during my Great Algae Bloom (of 2012?) My water was completely green and I moved it closer to the light, afraid it wasn't getting enough. Probably in too much flow, too. By the time I got my water cleared, my orange cap was completely dead. I left it in but it soon covered with algae, cementing its sad demise.

I got a purple haze monti from the Cherry Corals Summer Spectacular live sale, and loved it...but it died too. Quick tip - don't dip montis in H2O2. My bad. :'( I think that one was probably getting blasted, too, in my newbie attempt to give it the "high flow" I thought it needed.

So much for that.

Maybe I'll try again...but I'm going to wait for a lovely rich purple cap, that will give me that cool horizontal fan-shape they get.
 

Velodog2

Well-Known Member
View Badges
Joined
Aug 7, 2013
Messages
759
Reaction score
14
Location
Central Maryland
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
I don't like the caps and especially the digitata - too weedy. But the thicker encrusters, especially undata types me loves. The subtle shading and totally unique bluish white polyps of the "true undata" are sublime!
 

DecanoLA

Community Member
View Badges
Joined
Oct 22, 2012
Messages
65
Reaction score
16
Location
Los Angeles
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Ok Scott, I generally love your articles, but I really don't understand what you are talking about... I love montiporas!
If you show pictures of those little frags, well yeah, not that impressive... I'm sure you could have found a beautiful big colony to post.

Also, is the point of reef keeping is to feel special and cool by owning a 1 inch frag of super "**RARE**", "***NAMED***", "***LE*** and ***EXPEN$$IVE***??? Do we just want to "show off" our expertise and wallet???....Or do we want to recreate a natural looking reef, full of different colors, shapes, movement, etc?

What could be better than a genus that is easy to keep, adaptable, grows very well, comes in many different shapes and colors, easy to frag, etc etc...????
And when those plates get big they actually give the impression of a real reef!
 
OP
OP
uniquecorals

uniquecorals

UniqueCorals
View Badges
Joined
Nov 23, 2006
Messages
12,791
Reaction score
10,593
Location
Los Angeles
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Ok Scott, I generally love your articles, but I really don't understand what you are talking about... I love montiporas!
If you show pictures of those little frags, well yeah, not that impressive... I'm sure you could have found a beautiful big colony to post.

Also, is the point of reef keeping is to feel special and cool by owning a 1 inch frag of super "**RARE**", "***NAMED***", "***LE*** and ***EXPEN$$IVE***??? Do we just want to "show off" our expertise and wallet???....Or do we want to recreate a natural looking reef, full of different colors, shapes, movement, etc?

What could be better than a genus that is easy to keep, adaptable, grows very well, comes in many different shapes and colors, easy to frag, etc etc...????
And when those plates get big they actually give the impression of a real reef!

Also, is the point of reef keeping is to feel special and cool by owning a 1 inch frag of super "**RARE**", "***NAMED***", "***LE*** and ***EXPEN$$IVE***??? Do we just want to "show off" our expertise and wallet???....Or do we want to recreate a natural looking reef, full of different colors, shapes, movement, etc?

Hey, I'm right there with you! I'm only trashing the "capricornus cliche"; to be honest, I love the genus other than that species...I agree- to see a fully-grown colony of M. confuse or M. mollis is INSANE! I actually think Monties are the perfect SPS coral for many people...OF course, I think that about Pocillopora, Stylpora, etc...LOL

-Scott
 

Nano sapiens

Valuable Member
View Badges
Joined
Apr 25, 2010
Messages
2,493
Reaction score
3,681
Location
East Bay, CA
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
I have a couple different types on a single rock and it's fascinating to watch the variety of offense and defensive methods that they use against one another.

On the surface, Montis do appear 'wimpy' when they go up against most other corals. But, when attacked they tend to quickly 'ooze' out in another direction and in this way keep on expanding territory.

Using this technique, I had a M. capricornis and a Leptastrea pruinosa circle each other many times around the same rock pinnacle for nearly eight years and neither could defeat the other.
 

Battlecorals

Aquaculturist
View Badges
Joined
Oct 15, 2009
Messages
6,914
Reaction score
16,106
Location
Wisconsin
Rating - 100%
2   0   0
The true orenji is in my top five Sps of all time. One of the best. And I had a monster purple tip spongodess back in the day that was as cool looking as it gets. It was the centerpiece of the tank even. Then there's the ultimate oddball. The BC metal polyp!



metal.jpg


I have always had a soft spot for monties. Especially unique ones!

Bunch of old classics stuffed in a look down in 2010

abde4886-12e9-48e5-8e79-9dc945a9d1d9_zpseb9be9ca.jpg
 
Last edited:

Caring for your picky eaters: What do you feed your finicky fish?

  • Live foods

    Votes: 21 31.8%
  • Frozen meaty foods

    Votes: 53 80.3%
  • Soft pellets

    Votes: 11 16.7%
  • Masstick (or comparable)

    Votes: 7 10.6%
  • Other

    Votes: 4 6.1%
Back
Top