Valenciennea and the Sandsifting gobies; an in depth look

i cant think

Wrasse Addict
View Badges
Joined
Sep 1, 2021
Messages
17,049
Reaction score
31,939
Location
England
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
So, it seems there’s been a recent spike in people wanting Sand Sifting Gobies from these genera;
- Koumansetta
- Signigobius
- Valenciennea
(This is the biggest Genus I’ve seen people getting specimens from)
- Amblygobius
I figured it was time to start an article on these guys as their care is often more complicated than people expect given that they’re ‘Gobies’.
I’ve already done an article on the differences between Sand Sifters and the Rock Dwellers however the shortened version is;
Sand Sifters will not pair with Pistol Shrimp and their diet is often more complex than the average goby.


So, now we’ve had a bit of an introduction to this ‘section’ of Gobies. Let’s go into more detail about each genus, starting with Signigobius.
This genus is the smallest of the Sandsifting genera commonly kept in captivity with only one species - Signigobius biocellatus. In the wild, these guys are found around Indonesia at depths between 1 metre and 30 Metres. Their natural habitat is wide open silty areas of sand with a nearby shelter weather that’s coral, rubble or even leaf litter.
In captivity, this species is possibly among the hardest of Sand sifters to settle as many in captivity aren't captive bred and don’t readily accept frozen. These guys like many other species of sandsifter often starve to death within 6 months of being in captivity, this is often due to being in a system that is newer than they need or the sandbed is too shallow (A lot of the time it’s a reason of both). Frozen is not a good diet to keep them on for all of their nutrients (We’ll come to why soon as the reason stands for any Sandaifting species). These guys also tend to need spot feeding if they’re in a more active tank with aggressive eating fish.
7BCC2352-AEDA-4E38-880D-63D1A33E21A3.jpeg

Signigobius biocellatus (Two Spot Goby). Photo from Tankstop.com.

Now for the next genus, Koumansetta. This genus is home to now 3 species (it used to only be home to 2 species until one in the redsea was discovered). The three species in this genus are (In order of when they were discovered); Koumansetta rainfordi, Koumansetta hectori and Koumansetta hoesei. Koumansetta hoesei is no longer available to the hobby from what I know however the other two Koumansetta species are also widely available! In the wild, the Rainford’s and Hector’s Gobies are both found in the Indonesian range hence why we get the hybrids between these two species which do come into the hobby every so often. Generally these guys are found just off of Coral Reefs, hovering over a similar sand to what Signigobius species are found around (Silty).
In captivity, these guys are among the easiest of species to own. Because of the two species found in captivity being captive bred quite often, they happily eat frozen. However, whilst frozen is a more readily available food for them, their diet remains similar to other Sand Sifting species. As seen in the photo below, mine had a tank full of cyano. This is what separated this genus from the other genera, their diet is more open and the majority will readily eat Cyanobacteria. The other thing that separated this genus is that they are more likely to feed from both the Sand and also the Rockwork. I’ll go further into this and why this helps separate these guys from the other three genera when I go more in depth in their dietary needs.
258528D4-31AC-48BC-89E1-66E9B2AA9F55.jpeg

Koumansetta hectori (Hector’s Goby). Photo by I Cant Think.

The next genus we’ll look into is the genus that slightly more people keep. You may have noticed I’ve been doing this in a specific order, and that order is going from less kept in captivity to most kept in captivity. Now, it’s just a coincidence this also goes in number of species in the genus however the next genus is the Amblygobius genus. This genus has 15 species in it and only a few are actually common in captivity. The species I see most often in captivity are;
- Amblygobius decussatus (Orange Barred Sleeper Goby)
- Amblygobius phalaena (Banded Sleeper Goby)
- Amblygobius semicinctus (Half-Barred Goby)
In the wild these guys are generally all found on Muddy Substrates around the Pacific and Indian Oceans. Which again, this will link to their dietary needs.
In captivity, these guys can be slightly harder to keep however they generally are on the easier side of sand sitting gobies as they will more readily accept frozen. The hardest part is actually finding one that accepts frozen foods (Again, I’ll go into this deeper when going in about diets).
235B3725-BB9A-4EF4-ABFB-77A95D149EE7.jpeg

Amblygobius semicinctus (Half Barred Goby). Photo by I Cant Think.

And the final genus is Valenciennea. This is the most popular genus of Sandsifting Goby in the hobby. Now, this genus holds 16 species. The majority are found in the hobby. Some of the most common you’ll find in fish stores are;
- Valenciennea puellaris (Orange Spotted ‘Watchman’ Goby)
- Valenciennea stigata (Blue Cheek Goby)
- Valenciennea wardii (Tiger ‘Watchman’ Goby)
- Valenciennea sexguttata (Chalk Goby)
- Valenciennea helsdigenii (Railway ‘Watchman’ Goby)
- Valenciennea bella (Bella Goby)
Now, as you’ll see, there are some species that are called ‘Watchman’ Gobies. These are not true watchmans - the true watchmans are in the genus Cryptocentrus. I go further in depth about the differences between these two in my article titles ‘True vs False’.
In the wild, Valenciennea species are again, found around the Pacific and the Indian Oceans. Yet again, their natural habitat is in a wide open area of sand with a nearby shelter (often Rubble or Coral). Now, captivity generally sees these guys die the most through starvation. These guys are rather needy in terms of their diet and die within 6 months just withering away. Again, I’ll go in depth of their needed diet later. Now these guys are slightly larger gobies that generally max out around 4-6 inches.
8771B4BE-EF3A-411F-B26E-DDAB0581675B.jpeg

The infamous Valenciennea puellaris (Orange Spot ‘Watchman’ Goby). Photo by I Cant Think.

Now that I’ve given an inteoduction to the 4 most common genera kept in captivity let’s go into their needed tank sizes.
Starting with Koumansetta. This genus is a smaller genus with its species ranging from 2 to 3 inches in captivity. So, in terms of Tank size for these guys I would aim for a 20G-30G (75-136L) tank. These guys are not only small in size but also activity and don’t move around as often.
Now, the next genus is Amblygobius. This genus ideally needs a 50-60G (230-270L) tank. This is again, a less active genus however their dietary needs are bigger than Koumansetta species’ are (A lot of the needed tank sizes to link to their dietary needs as well as activity).
Let’s go for Signigobius as the next genus. This genus is again, not as active however as they are more well known to die of starvation I would say this species needs Atleast a 70G (320L) tank, ideally an 80-90G (365-400L) tank. This doesn’t link to their activity as they are a species that doesn’t move much from their spot however they rarely eat frozen.
This leaves Valenciennea as our last genus for tank size. Now, this genus needs Atleast a 90G (400L) tank however a 125-180G (570-820L) tank would work best. This is linked to their size, activity as well as dietary needs. This genus gets larger than the other genera mentioned above and needs slightly more food. This genus is also more active than the others - those who have had species from this genus will know how much they like to move around the tank when settled.
5DF7BBAB-2876-4593-9305-EEA2CE4A40BF.jpeg

Valenciennea sexguttata (Chalk Goby). Photo by I Cant Think.


Finally, the dietary issue. This is the biggest issue with sand sifting species. The genus Koumansetta doesn’t have as much of an issue with this however they should still have a nice matured, deep sandbed just to snack on. The reason this isn’t as big of an issue is because these guys do feed off of algae from the rockwork.

Now, the other three genera are much more needy and this is why;
Due to their habitat in the wild, these guys don’t have much of an option to hunt for pods and microfauna from the rocks. So they need to get their nutrients from the sandbed which is flourishing with life in the wild. In our closed ecosystems, this isn’t quite the case. A matured tank will have the perfect micro fauna and if one half of the sand is deprived, the other half will likely be able to provide life back into that empty sand. Now, to get that life from the sand you either need a huge tank (6-8’+) or a deep sandbed. I recommend sandbeds of 3-4 inches at a minimum for these guys as they generally take the first 2 inches of sand off the surface to feed from, leaving the other 2 inches full of life. Even then, to build that life and get it to thrive you need Atleast a 3 year old tank. Remember, these guys get Atleast 90% of their nutrients from the sand bed in captivity, if the sand is white it’s lost almost all of its life. Ideally to have a thriving sandsifting goby, you’ll want a tank that has a sand bed similar to this:
99DBAF82-D60C-4659-B796-CCCB497BD1FF.jpeg

The 3” sand bed of my 3 year old 4’x2’x18’’ tank. Photo by I Cant Think.

Now, why do they not thrive off of frozen? If you were to feed these frozen only, you would have to use an incredibly nutrient rich food and also feed 5-6 times a day at the minimum (ideally you’re aiming for 8-10 feedings a day).
334F7B6E-7B8C-42E5-AD62-D1B50EAD4B0B.jpeg

Amblygobius bynoensis (Bynoe Goby). Photo by I Cant Think.

So, next time you want to get one of these guys to give you a totally white sandbed… think again if it’s worth it :)
So I shall leave you with a picture taken by a fellow friend of a thriving Puellaris.
F86E5EE0-2438-4A8C-86F3-44CC4830A11F.jpeg

Valenciennea puellaris (Orange Spot ‘Watchman’ Goby). Photo by Slocke
 

Weeb

Active Member
View Badges
Joined
Dec 14, 2022
Messages
379
Reaction score
251
Location
Las Vegas
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
So, it seems there’s been a recent spike in people wanting Sand Sifting Gobies from these genera;
Thank you very much for the article. I think the only thing missing is 'how' they sift the sand. That is, do they sift on the substrate while remaining on the substrate like Valenciennea puellaris (Orange Spot ‘Watchman’ Goby), or do they grab some substrate and sift it as they swim upwards/around the aquarium.

Great job! :)
 
OP
OP
i cant think

i cant think

Wrasse Addict
View Badges
Joined
Sep 1, 2021
Messages
17,049
Reaction score
31,939
Location
England
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Thank you very much for the article. I think the only thing missing is 'how' they sift the sand. That is, do they sift on the substrate while remaining on the substrate like Valenciennea puellaris (Orange Spot ‘Watchman’ Goby), or do they grab some substrate and sift it as they swim upwards/around the aquarium.

Great job! :)
Most Gobies will sift the sand whilst remaining closer to it and then swim up however every so often I have seen all of them swim up to the mid water column and sift it (This is more common in the Valenciennea genus than it is in the others).
 

Gino

Active Member
View Badges
Joined
Jan 31, 2016
Messages
381
Reaction score
335
Location
Tampa, Florida
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
As seen in the photo below, mine had a tank full of cyano. This is what separated this genus from the other genera, their diet is more open and the majority will readily eat Cyanobacteria. The other thing that separated this genus is that they are more likely to feed from both the Sand and also the Rockwork.
Thanks brother for the write up, very helpful and informative. As your quote mentions... "that the majority will eat Cyanobacteria". I been dealing with cyano for quite a while now, I try everything on the book and nothing seems to work it's manageable but annoying . Did you think or will you recommend one of them to help me out with the cyano battle? At this point I don't look to eradicate it but to keep the cyano at bay. Any suggestions will be greatly appreciated.

Gino
20230127_141225.jpg
 
OP
OP
i cant think

i cant think

Wrasse Addict
View Badges
Joined
Sep 1, 2021
Messages
17,049
Reaction score
31,939
Location
England
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Thanks brother for the write up, very helpful and informative. As your quote mentions... "that the majority will eat Cyanobacteria". I been dealing with cyano for quite a while now, I try everything on the book and nothing seems to work it's manageable but annoying . Did you think or will you recommend one of them to help me out with the cyano battle? At this point I don't look to eradicate it but to keep the cyano at bay. Any suggestions will be greatly appreciated.

Gino
20230127_141225.jpg
I would personally go for a Koumansetta hectori for both the looks but also they feed from both the rocks and sand and not just the sand bed. Whilst Rainfordi is less likely to feed from the rocks.
 

Gino

Active Member
View Badges
Joined
Jan 31, 2016
Messages
381
Reaction score
335
Location
Tampa, Florida
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
I would personally go for a Koumansetta hectori for both the looks but also they feed from both the rocks and sand and not just the sand bed. Whilst Rainfordi is less likely to feed from the rocks.
Thanks for the input, I think that I will give it a try to a Hectori. Another question, Does yours picks on the cyano?
 
OP
OP
i cant think

i cant think

Wrasse Addict
View Badges
Joined
Sep 1, 2021
Messages
17,049
Reaction score
31,939
Location
England
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Thanks for the input, I think that I will give it a try to a Hectori. Another question, Does yours pic on the cyano?
When I had mine he definitely picked at it but also he ate it whilst sifting the sand.
 

Mark Gray

2500 Club Member
View Badges
Joined
Jul 13, 2015
Messages
2,957
Reaction score
2,827
Location
Athens GA
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Quick question I have a 48 x 24 tank at the moment, I have some cayno would 1 Koumansetta hectori be enough or will they get along with 2 my the sand is fairly dirty. I don't see them often but 8 see a few places I can get them online.
 

FlyinAg

Active Member
View Badges
Joined
Sep 27, 2022
Messages
170
Reaction score
117
Location
Niceville
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Cool write up. Our orange spot went carpet surfing this week

He finally had moved to the front of the tank and looked like he was pairing with our candy cane pistol shrimp. Bummer.
 
OP
OP
i cant think

i cant think

Wrasse Addict
View Badges
Joined
Sep 1, 2021
Messages
17,049
Reaction score
31,939
Location
England
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Quick question I have a 48 x 24 tank at the moment, I have some cayno would 1 Koumansetta hectori be enough or will they get along with 2 my the sand is fairly dirty. I don't see them often but 8 see a few places I can get them online.
I would stick to 1 specimen of hectori in your tank first and see how he does. If your sand is daily deep I’d go for 2 as I know 1 can get rid of cyano relatively fast. They also help deal with other algae’s/bacteria like diatoms.
 

Mark Gray

2500 Club Member
View Badges
Joined
Jul 13, 2015
Messages
2,957
Reaction score
2,827
Location
Athens GA
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
I would stick to 1 specimen of hectori in your tank first and see how he does. If your sand is daily deep I’d go for 2 as I know 1 can get rid of cyano relatively fast. They also help deal with other algae’s/bacteria like diatoms.
Thank you I will try and find one as soon as I get back from Spain leaving next weekend
 

xiongsy

Active Member
View Badges
Joined
Jan 25, 2023
Messages
286
Reaction score
169
Location
Little Elm
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
I have an orange spotted Watchman Goby. It acceps masstick, salmon, and pellets. Pellets tend to fall out of its gills however. My sand is nice and clean but there is always a sand storm in the tank. I use AF Bio Sand.
 
OP
OP
i cant think

i cant think

Wrasse Addict
View Badges
Joined
Sep 1, 2021
Messages
17,049
Reaction score
31,939
Location
England
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
I have an orange spotted Watchman Goby. It acceps masstick, salmon, and pellets. Pellets tend to fall out of its gills however. My sand is nice and clean but there is always a sand storm in the tank. I use AF Bio Sand.
Generally, if they eat you need a varied diet like your feeding but to keep them on frozen only you’d have to give Atleast 7-8 feedings a day. The life sand is where it’ll get most of its nutrients and you’ll likely find your sand is dirtier than you can see on the glass.
My 4’ tank’s sandbed is much dirtier than it looks on the glass and I have 3 Sand Sleeping wrasses that stir it up twice every day.
 
OP
OP
i cant think

i cant think

Wrasse Addict
View Badges
Joined
Sep 1, 2021
Messages
17,049
Reaction score
31,939
Location
England
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
My tank has more of a gravel bed than a sand bed. Would this be a problem for a sand-sifting goby? I've heard that some fish can damage whiskers etc. on gravel.
I would aim for a more fine sandbed as I have had them get larger bits of sand stuck in their gills however I personally have a mix of sand with;
1/2part crushed coral
1part coarse sand
3-4 parts fine sand
I find this best mimics a natural environment and seems to reduce harm to any fish that uses the sand.
 
Back
Top