Why my duncans acting this way?

[Notsolostfish]

My tank is 5 months old. And those 2 duncans i have. One is 1 head its over 2 months old. And one is 1.5 months old. They stretch but their actual tentacles dont come out and stay short. Im just beyond frustrated with their behavior do i move them? They are in 120 par area.


Alk:7.4 (tropic marin salt)
Mag:1315
Calcium:415
Temp:77F
Salinity:1.026
Phosphate:0.04
Nitrate:10

For the people that says give them time. I mean yes all i do is giving them time the one behind i gave it over a month time still puffed up and closed.

 

[Saltyreef]

There could be multiple factors involved.

This looks like they are getting ample light which is why they may be staying short.

You could try to shade them and see if the tenticles get longer.

Your tank is only 5 months old so i would expect some biodiversity instability might be contributing as well.

 

[Notsolostfish]

There could be multiple factors involved.

This looks like they are getting ample light which is why they may be staying short.

You could try to shade them and see if the tenticles get longer.

Your tank is only 5 months old so i would expect some biodiversity instability might be contributing as well.

Do u think i should move them?

 

[TokenReefer]

Thread 'Duncan coral acting up.' https://www.reef2reef.com/threads/duncan-coral-acting-up.958385/

Why'd your give up on this thread? A bit of advice, take it or leave it... Keep one thread going when you're addressing the same issue. I think you're getting all sorts of advice with no clear history of what's been tried/states etc... You might find it more focused to your needs

 

[FIN&BONEZ]

Maybe hungry?

 

[Notsolostfish]

Thread 'Duncan coral acting up.' https://www.reef2reef.com/threads/duncan-coral-acting-up.958385/

Why'd your give up on this thread? A bit of advice, take it or leave it... Keep one thread going when you're addressing the same issue. I think you're getting all sorts of advice with no clear history of what's been tried/states etc... You might find it more focused to your needs

Because advising to fix a duncan that you usually dont have to feed to keep happy. Is not really the issue here. Trying different foods on the market wont help

 

[TokenReefer]

Because advising to fix a duncan that you usually dont have to feed to keep happy. Is not really the issue here. Trying different foods on the market wont help

Right but you can choose to take that advice or skip over it, however the history for others to get up to speed and on the same page is there which might help them address the issue from other angles as they've seen what's already been suggested, what you've already tried, etc... Just a thought

 

[TokenReefer]

Honestly if you care for my opinion, I think if you just sit back and feed the fish you're tank will stabilize (however you quantify that) and you'll start getting "happy corals". You've been altering things on a frequent basis and each time it moves the goalposts the corals are trying to get to. Your tank the way it is right now without changing anything will grow corals once they finally can relaxe from not having to readjust constantly. You may not even think the things you're doing are significant in any (even adding uv is a change for example) way but the corals may disagree. Just my opinion tho. I wish you luck truthfully

 

[ScottJ]

Honestly if you care for my opinion, I think if you just sit back and feed the fish you're tank will stabilize (however you quantify that) and you'll start getting "happy corals". You've been altering things on a frequent basis and each time it moves the goalposts the corals are trying to get to. Your tank the way it is right now without changing anything will grow corals once they finally can relaxe from not having to readjust constantly. You may not even think the things you're doing are significant in any (even adding uv is a change for example) way but the corals may disagree. Just my opinion tho. I wish you luck truthfully

Couldn't agree more! I learned the hard way just to keep up with good husbandry, regular maintenance, the right critters for the situation, and a tank will usually sort itself out. out.

 

[TokenReefer]

Sorry, I'm no arbiter, but @charbel101 I only say this because I read your posts and often don't chime in because there are usually a number of suggestions and I don't want to add to that.

Let me ask you this. Before you mounted them where they are now, did you have them in the sand or on a rack and did they open then?

 

[Mr. Mojo Rising]

from the video, it kind of seems like there is no flow at all in your tank, nothing is moving, and I see other unhappy corals. Corals need flow, its very important to them. I would suggest to increase the flow, it will help your tank overall.

 

[TokenReefer]

A few more ?'s... sorry...while I'm here lol

Do you have other stony corals in the tank?

You said you use TM salt -

• Classic: Ca: 370-390 ppm, Mg: 1250-1300 ppm, Alk: 9-10 dKH
• Pro-REEF: Ca: 430-450 ppm, Mg: 1300-1350 ppm, Alk: 7-8 dKH

Which one?

Are you dosing just enough to maintain the alk at 7.4?

When was that last time you calibrated your refractometer/probe that checks salinity?

 

[Notsolostfish]

A few more ?'s... sorry...while I'm here lol

Do you have other stony corals in the tank?

You said you use TM salt -

• Classic: Ca: 370-390 ppm, Mg: 1250-1300 ppm, Alk: 9-10 dKH
• Pro-REEF: Ca: 430-450 ppm, Mg: 1300-1350 ppm, Alk: 7-8 dKH

Which one?

Are you dosing just enough to maintain the alk at 7.4?

When was that last time you calibrated your refractometer/probe that checks salinity?

Tropic marin pro reef.

And my duncan looks better today.

 

[TokenReefer]

Tropic marin pro reef.

And my duncan looks better today.

Yes it does my friend