Hey, NO FAIR!!!! That is MUCH SHARPER, but that is what your lens is designed for! So.... That makes the comparison even more valid, tubes+diopter DO NOT equal a Macro lens, PERIOD.
I thought it would make a good comparison of the difference. I'm not even going think about getting into a photo battle with you. That would just be a straight up whoopin!
I have a Canon 1D with the macro tubes, the 500D and a good tripod, the only question I have is... that tripod head... what kind, how much and where from!
Your best choice is a ball head with a quick-release camera mount. In addition to the ball, I like models that have a second lever so you can rotate the head. The head also needs to be able to handle the heaviest camera/lens combination. I use Manfrotto heads, but there are several other options. In looking for the link to the heads I use, I learned they've been discontinued.
There must be a good professional photographer store (Calumet?) in the Cleveland area. Go there and test the heads they have on display to get one with controls you like. Don't spend less than $100.
Gary
I'm not sure if anyone else has mentioned this yet, but have you guys tried using a reverse lense mount? I purchased one for a couple bucks off ebay and it allows you to put your lens on backwards. You can then capture really great macro shots but the depth of field is affected and a zoom lens will end up working as a prime lens does where you have to move the whole camera back and forward in order to make sure you get the right zoom and focus on your subject.
I have a Nikon D80 and looking to get extension tubes and new lenses. My tank is 1000 gallons and 4 feet deep. What would be the best lens to capture shots through the glass at that distance?
I hear you, I always wanted to take awesome pictures like these guys. I think it is fantastic, and I will try it someday. These threads are a great way to stay close to the action.
Nitro