All fish dead after water change - what went wrong?

Hello everyone.
My system is 2 months old. I started to gradually add fish after a month. I had a blonde naso. Regal tang, a well set powder blue, 2 golden head gobies and a Randall goby. They were all fine and eating well, there wasn’t any bullying. On Monday I did a 15% water change using Fauna Marin salt and Rodi water tds was 1. The rodi unit is my own setup. After the wc the fish started to die next morning and they all died by Wednesday. I had a lot of diatoms even those died I suppose because my macro rocks look as white as ever. My no3 is 5, po4 25ppb and my salinity 35ppt checked with tropic marine stick and refracto. Sorry for the image.
Any suggestion would help.

579e63a1-f3f8-4cc0-a237-c6d7b580a9c7.jpeg
 
Last edited:
Hello everyone.
My system is 2 months old. I started to gradually add fish after a month. I had a blonde naso. Regal tang, a well set powder blue, 2 golden head gobies and a Randall goby. They were all fine and eating well, there wasn’t any bullying. On Monday I did a 15% water change using Fauna Marin salt and Rodi water tds was 1. The rodi unit is my own setup. After the wc the fish started to die next morning and they all died by Wednesday. I had a lot of diatoms even those died I suppose because my macro rocks look as white as ever. My no3 is 5, po4 25ppb and my salinity 35ppt checked with tropic marine stick and refracto. Sorry for the image.
Any suggestion would help.

579e63a1-f3f8-4cc0-a237-c6d7b580a9c7.jpeg

Wow, sad and unexpected.

Have you previously been using that same water and batch of salt?
 
Hello everyone.
My system is 2 months old. I started to gradually add fish after a month. I had a blonde naso. Regal tang, a well set powder blue, 2 golden head gobies and a Randall goby. They were all fine and eating well, there wasn’t any bullying. On Monday I did a 15% water change using Fauna Marin salt and Rodi water tds was 1. The rodi unit is my own setup. After the wc the fish started to die next morning and they all died by Wednesday. I had a lot of diatoms even those died I suppose because my macro rocks look as white as ever. My no3 is 5, po4 25ppb and my salinity 35ppt checked with tropic marine stick and refracto. Sorry for the image.
Any suggestion would help.
Was this a new bucket or existing bucket? Definitely sounds like something was in the salt or maybe not even salt. Do you have any photos of any salt left over or the bucket?
 
Yes, I might have half a tub of salt remaining. I use a drum container which I have always used for water changes. Will post a picture.
Was this a new bucket or existing bucket? Definitely sounds like something was in the salt or maybe not even salt. Do you have any photos of any salt left over or the bucket?
 
Did you stir up the sand a bunch? Maybe the bioload wasn't quite ready yet. That's really weird to have such sudden deaths and not really know what from.
Not really. The fish were all very healthy and eating fine before the water change.
 

TOP 10 Trending Threads

HOW WOULD YOU FEEL ABOUT RECEIVING A FISH OR CORAL AS A HOLIDAY GIFT?

  • I’d love one, as long as it’s a species I chose

    Votes: 26 24.5%
  • I’d trust someone who knows my tank to choose

    Votes: 9 8.5%
  • I’d rather get a gift card and pick it myself

    Votes: 43 40.6%
  • I’d prefer gear or supplies instead

    Votes: 2 1.9%
  • Please don’t surprise me with livestock

    Votes: 26 24.5%
  • Other (Post in the comments)

    Votes: 0 0.0%
Back
Top
Home
Post thread…
Market
What's new