Are beginner corals really beginner-friendly?

[Gumbies R Us]

One of the main draws for anyone getting into the hobby is coral. The beauty of the colorful, flowing creatures in a tank is something that everyone can appreciate. However chosing which one to start with is the difficult part. A lot of people will suggest something that is deemed "beginner" when in reality it might not actually be beginner-friendly. One of the corals I was told would be easy to keep was Candy Canes. I for the life of me could do nothing to get this coral flourishing in my tank, and ultimately it didn't make it. With that being said, are we loose on the term "beginner-friendly"? Is saying a certain coral is perfect for beginner reefers setting them up for failure, or is there actually coral that any beginner can keep with no issue?

 

[TOM-779]

One of the main draws for anyone getting into the hobby is coral. The beauty of the colorful, flowing creatures in a tank is something that everyone can appreciate. However chosing which one to start with is the difficult part. A lot of people will suggest something that is deemed "beginner" when in reality it might not actually be beginner-friendly. One of the corals I was told would be easy to keep was Candy Canes. I for the life of me could do nothing to get this coral flourishing in my tank, and ultimately it didn't make it. With that being said, are we loose on the term "beginner-friendly"? Is saying a certain coral is perfect for beginner reefers setting them up for failure, or is there actually coral that any beginner can keep with no issue?

Hey I totally agree with you. I am obsessed with Toadstools. And regularly hear people recommend toadies even in small setups regardless of the sizes they can grow. And i think emphasis is often on phrase 'impossible to kill species' when in fact its the water/tank husbandry regime that drives the success of species survival.

 

[Jtuvey]

When I started I was told that Blastomussa was beginner-friendly, but could not keep it alive, and felt I had my parameters spot on. That being said. I have a green Birdsnest I have had in my tank 5 months after I cycled it. It's been through a lot, and still growing.

 

[BryanM]

One of the main draws for anyone getting into the hobby is coral. The beauty of the colorful, flowing creatures in a tank is something that everyone can appreciate. However chosing which one to start with is the difficult part. A lot of people will suggest something that is deemed "beginner" when in reality it might not actually be beginner-friendly. One of the corals I was told would be easy to keep was Candy Canes. I for the life of me could do nothing to get this coral flourishing in my tank, and ultimately it didn't make it. With that being said, are we loose on the term "beginner-friendly"? Is saying a certain coral is perfect for beginner reefers setting them up for failure, or is there actually coral that any beginner can keep with no issue?

In a word, no.

Now, if the majority of us actually had the patience to cycle a tank properly and wait before putting critters in it, I think I'd change my mind.

Maybe GSP, its like a cockroach.

 

[vlangel]

Maybe GSP, its like a cockroach.

I have even had trouble with GSP.

 

[Matt L]

Kenya Tree.

 

[tsharpe291]

+1 on kenya tree, those split like crazy for me

 

[Bear22]

My strangest "beginner" coral are Duncans. They seem to open and close willy-nilly.

 

[exnisstech]

I think it's like many things in this hobby every tank is different. I could keep LPS like acanthophyllia, lobos, cynarina, pectinia amd bubble coral. But I couldn't keep zoas, GSP, even xenia would melt. 10 years later I can keep GSP, zoas live but don't thrive. Xenia still dies but I have moderate success with acros.

 

[fandaga]

Zoas, first coral I killed

 

[JonoH]

Pulsing Xenia...

 

[141918]

One of the main draws for anyone getting into the hobby is coral. The beauty of the colorful, flowing creatures in a tank is something that everyone can appreciate. However chosing which one to start with is the difficult part. A lot of people will suggest something that is deemed "beginner" when in reality it might not actually be beginner-friendly. One of the corals I was told would be easy to keep was Candy Canes. I for the life of me could do nothing to get this coral flourishing in my tank, and ultimately it didn't make it. With that being said, are we loose on the term "beginner-friendly"? Is saying a certain coral is perfect for beginner reefers setting them up for failure, or is there actually coral that any beginner can keep with no issue?

This is ironically funny as my candy cane has went from 2 heads to almost 8. My monti cap has grown a good inch. But my clove polyps wither and wine daily. They just can't keep up lol.

 

[Gumbies R Us]

My strangest "beginner" coral are Duncans. They seem to open and close willy-nilly.

Our Duncan did great for the first month we had it, then it slowly died and there was nothing I could do to fix it

 

[Seansea]

I woukd say anything with a skeleton is not beginner friendly. Skeletons mean keeping certain parameters up that beginner may have no clue about. Even certain softies can be tempermental. But if someone asked me i just want an easy beginner friendly tank i would recommend kenya trees, leathers, mushrooms and certain zoas. I would even say these could go in most fish only tanks with a decent light.

 

[Bear22]

Our Duncan did great for the first month we had it, then it slowly died and there was nothing I could do to fix it

 

[reefpanda]

Zoas and mushroooms, if one can't keep those alive, go back to freshwater tanks