Bad skimmer choice?

[Cmp1985]

I have a 50 gallon DT and the trigger system platinum 34 sump. I bought this skimmer on black friday but after some more research it looks like my tank could be too "clean" which could cause some issues. Should I get a new smaller one. May keep this since I got a decent price for a possible future build

eSsence S-130 Internal Protein Skimmer

BRS Recommended for tanks up to: Heavy Bioload (Most Common) - 75 Gallons Medium Bioload - 120 Gallons Light Bioload - 160 gallons Footprint - 8.3" x 6.9" Height - 20.5″ Recommended Water Height: 7"-8" Reef Octopus eSsence S-130 Protein Skimmer has been designed from the ground up to create...

www.bulkreefsupply.com

 

[Pistondog]

If you are having trouble tuning, maybe put a needle valve in the air line and turn it down.
I had to do this with my vertex 150 on a 75 g.

 

[Cmp1985]

If you are having trouble tuning, maybe put a needle valve in the air line and turn it down.
I had to do this with my vertex 150 on a 75 g.

Ok thanks

 

[Cmp1985]

Ok thanks

Bump

 

[Cramsey]

As stated above, just tune it down. Are you having and issues with it? It can take up to 2 weeks for a new skimmer to process out all of the factory residue. Is this a new tank?

 

[Cmp1985]

As stated above, just tune it down. Are you having and issues with it? It can take up to 2 weeks for a new skimmer to process out all of the factory residue. Is this a new tank?

I haven't used it yet. I figured I'd try and get feed back and return it if it would be an issue

 

[Cramsey]

I haven't used it yet. I figured I'd try and get feed back and return it if it would be an issue

Is your tank new or established? If your tank is new then you should think about the future and where you’re going instead of where you are... because you can definitely grow into this skimmer.

 

[Cmp1985]

Is your tank new or established? If your tank is new then you should think about the future and where you’re going instead of where you are... because you can definitely grow into this skimmer.

Brand new. Still setting it up. Just got waternin it

 

[Cramsey]

Gotcha, if it were me... I’d either sell it or buy a bigger tank. I’d probably go to petco and buy a 75 on their $1 per gallon sale. You could always sell it on here or trade it. That skimmer is a bit big for your tank IMO

 

[stanlalee]

I think you are misunderstanding the concept of too large a skimmer. Your tank won't be cleaner because a grossly oversize skimmer won't skim well. A 5" skimmer MIGHT (might not) be a better match for a 50g display but you want a skimmer with the ability to skim as well as possible. I don' think yours is too big if you have a good bioload and feeding. The ratings are useless. I've had 4,5 & 6" skimmers on my 30g/10 sump. ALL of them functioned just fine. If you're getting good skimate production it's not too big. When you get little to nothing it's too big. What are your indicators that your running too clean? That's an easy problem to fix. Feed more add more [appropriate] livestock and feed that. Without carbon dosing or frequent large water changes I find it almost impossible for a skimmer alone to make a reef tank too clean.

 

[Cmp1985]

Gotcha, if it were me... I’d either sell it or buy a bigger tank. I’d probably go to petco and buy a 75 on their $1 per gallon sale. You could always sell it on here or trade it. That skimmer is a bit big for your tank IMO

I talked to brs and they would accept a return

 

[Cmp1985]

I think you are misunderstanding the concept of too large a skimmer. Your tank won't be cleaner because a grossly oversize skimmer won't skim well. A 5" skimmer MIGHT (might not) be a better match for a 50g display but you want a skimmer with the ability to skim as well as possible. I don' think yours is too big if you have a good bioload and feeding. The ratings are useless. I've had 4,5 & 6" skimmers on my 30g/10 sump. ALL of them functioned just fine. If you're getting good skimate production it's not too big. When you get little to nothing it's too big. What are your indicators that your running too clean? That's an easy problem to fix. Feed more add more [appropriate] livestock and feed that. Without carbon dosing or frequent large water changes I find it almost impossible for a skimmer alone to make a reef tank too clean.

I'm still in the middle of setting it up. I'm worried that with the automatic filter roller and a larger skimmer would be too "efficient

 

[Cramsey]

I'm still in the middle of setting it up. I'm worried that with the automatic filter roller and a larger skimmer would be too "efficient

I agree with you. The rollers do a pretty good job of cleaning a good portion of the waste before it breaks down.