Extreme phosphate consumption.

xLUGUBRIOUSx

Active Member
View Badges
Joined
Jan 23, 2021
Messages
126
Reaction score
41
Location
Colorado
What state or country do you live in
Colorado
Rating - 100%
1   0   0
Hey, im a bit perplexed and need some help. In my last 3 systems I set up, i have been dealing with massive phosphate uptake. Last tank ran for well over a year and I fought dinos constantly from phosphate consumption, I shut it down because I just couldn't deal with that anymore.

I mention that it was over a year to get into the rock binding thing. I dosed multiple times a day for over a year and still never "hit equilibrium" so I'm not buying the rock binding thing in that situation. I had thought it may have been from the bacteria that was prominent in that tank, it was prodbio sunstrate sauce.

So this time around I went with fritz, tried and true. Im well over a month into this tank and the same thing is happening. Im dosing significantly more in this 75g currently then I did in my previous 200g and I'm still struggling to keep it above 0. Im currently dosing reef moonshiners phosphorus at 12+ml a day. Equating to somewhere around .06-.08 ppm.

I even dosed 24ml one day to try and buy some time, or to do some sort of "loading" dose. Under 24 hours later I still tested at .01ppm

There's no coral, no media, no significant algae in this tank.

What am I missing? Im so tired of living on the razors edge of a potential dino bloom, along with hesitation to introduce coral because my phosphate is swinging so significantly on a daily basis.

Im entertaining the phosphate binding thing in this tank but im just not convinced. Admittedly I used rock from my old tank, dry, that still had bio material on it it was dirty. My nutrients were sky high after the cycle because of the decomposing organics, but within 2 days the consumption was on full force. I went from 60 no3 .4 po4 after cycle to 5 no3 and 0 po4 within days after that.

The only similarity I have is the aquaforest rock. But I cant accept that either because I had a 45g for years not using aquaforest rock but using substrate sauce bacteria initially, that tank did the same thing for well over a year until it didn't anymore.

Its like theres something I'm doing that creates this. Part of me wants to stop dosing po4 and let the rocks have a chance to equalize and release po4 rather then constantly absorbing it, but id rather suffer through dosing then deal with dinos ever again. Dinos man.

my tanks prior to these never did this. Not anything close to this. It took a month of occasional dosing to maintain po4 then po4 wanted to climb and I went to the opposite spectrum of removal. What I would give to need to remove phosphate vs dosing it. 😩

HELP
 
Why do you not believe rock binding is the cause? How much total have you added???

A reef2reef member showed that some rock in a 5 gallon bucket took up something like 50 ppm of phosphate before showing around 0.1 ppm if phosphate remaining in the water.
 
It's not clear in the post but are fish in the system? I feel like if you want to get nutrients in the system then you need poop!
 
I can only second Randy's assessment. My current system was started with dry rock and sand. I poured in insane amounts of phosphate every day in the beginning until phosphate stayed detectable for longer than a day.

The graph below shows quite well what happens once you understand it:
1794835226852.png

(Source: Millero et al. 2001)
​
X-axis: PO₄ left in the water after 1 day (white dots) or after 7 days (black dots)
Y-axis: PO₄ adsorbed per gram of carbonate after 1 day or 7 days

How much phosphate the carbonate holds depends on how much you add to the water. Before your rock and substrate are in balance, they have to be saturated, and with small daily doses that can take very long.

This will be a very rough approximation, but we can work out how much phosphate your tank might eat up before you get to 0.08ppm consistently (Trigger-Warning: Mathematics, skip the colored part if you just want the answer):

The paper offers an equation for the adsorption:
[PO₄]ad = Km · Cm · [PO₄] / (1 + Km · [PO₄])
(for aragonite at 25°C after 1 day Cm, and Km are defined as: Cm = 15.5µmol/g, Km = 0.037L/µmol)
​
For simplicity we aim for 0.08ppm PO₄ that we want to keep in your tank's water:
0.08ppm PO₄ ≈ 0.84µM​

Put into the mentioned equation, this yields 0.47µmol/g adsorbed, or

45mg PO₄ per kg aragonite
​
Your daily dose contains 23mg PO₄:
0.08mg/L · 284L ≈ 23mg PO₄​

And now we can finally approximate the number of daily doses a single kilogram of carbonate can adsorb:

45mg PO₄ / 23mg PO₄ ≈ 2
​
Every kg of carbonate in your tank can take up about 2 daily doses before it is in balance with 0.08ppm.

Of course your rocks and substrate have less surface area than the powder they used in the article, so this is an upper limit, but you get the idea. It will take quite a long time if you just keep adding small amounts to a tank with many kilos of rock and substrate.
 
Thanks to everyone for their input. I'll try and respond to everyone in this post.

It's hard to estimate how much ive added total, closer to or above 1.0 ppm cumulatively. Im not ruling out rock binding, thats the obvious answer I'm just afraid of running into this happening for over a year again and want to try and sort this out much earlier on.

Fish are in the system! Its not heavily stocked but I have 2 clowns, a tomini, 6 line, watchman, pistol shrimp, coral banded. Planning on adding a few more just still deciding what other additions will mesh well.


Entername ~ how much were you adding daily? What would you suggest i dose to get ahead of the curve. I dont have coral yet so its probably fine to do pretty heavy dosing. I have at least 60+lbs of rock. Plus 30-40lbs of sand.
 
Thanks to everyone for their input. I'll try and respond to everyone in this post.

It's hard to estimate how much ive added total, closer to or above 1.0 ppm cumulatively. Im not ruling out rock binding, thats the obvious answer I'm just afraid of running into this happening for over a year again and want to try and sort this out much earlier on.

Fish are in the system! Its not heavily stocked but I have 2 clowns, a tomini, 6 line, watchman, pistol shrimp, coral banded. Planning on adding a few more just still deciding what other additions will mesh well.


Entername ~ how much were you adding daily? What would you suggest i dose to get ahead of the curve. I dont have coral yet so its probably fine to do pretty heavy dosing. I have at least 60+lbs of rock. Plus 30-40lbs of sand.
It's been a few years so I don't remember, but I could imagine I added +10ppm daily for like 2 weeks into 165gal.

I would suggest "only" adding 1ppm. Even if you suddenly don't see a drop anymore and end up overdosing. It's easy to get rid of 1 - 2ppm vs. 10ppm 😁

This recipe makes it really easy and cheap to add 1ppm. If you tell me what reagent you can get your hands on I will give you a recipe that adds 1ppm per 10mL for your specific tank or so ☺️
https://www.reef2reef.com/threads/diy-phosphate-dosing-recipe.1109919/
 
Based on those calculations, factoring in my rock and sand. Theoretically to reach equilibrium at .08 were talking about 2245mg/ml of phosphate total?
 
Can you also feed more heavily? Give those fish the goodies!
I've been dumping a lot of food in given the amount of fish I have. At least 2x what I would consider feeding normally.
 
It's been a few years so I don't remember, but I could imagine I added +10ppm daily for like 2 weeks into 165gal.

I would suggest "only" adding 1ppm. Even if you suddenly don't see a drop anymore and end up overdosing. It's easy to get rid of 1 - 2ppm vs. 10ppm 😁

This recipe makes it really easy and cheap to add 1ppm. If you tell me what reagent you can get your hands on I will give you a recipe that adds 1ppm per 10mL for your specific tank or so ☺️
https://www.reef2reef.com/threads/diy-phosphate-dosing-recipe.1109919/
I'll definitely get my hands on some this week. Buying bottled phosphorus is going to get out of hand lol.
 

TOP 10 Trending Threads

WHAT DO YOU ALWAYS RUN OUT OF AT THE WORST TIME?

  • Salt mix

    Votes: 17 17.7%
  • Fish or coral food

    Votes: 5 5.2%
  • Test kits or reagents

    Votes: 10 10.4%
  • Filter media or replacement fleece

    Votes: 5 5.2%
  • RO/DI filters or supplies

    Votes: 15 15.6%
  • Fragging and repair supplies, like glue or epoxy

    Votes: 12 12.5%
  • I keep a backup of everything

    Votes: 25 26.0%
  • Other (Post in the comments)

    Votes: 7 7.3%
Back
Top
Home
Post thread…
Market
What's new