- Joined
- Feb 24, 2025
- Messages
- 6
- Reaction score
- 1
- Location
- OFallon
- What state or country do you live in
- Missouri
My First Saltwater Tank Journey: A Detailed Build Thread
I’m excited to share my journey as I dive into my first saltwater tank! I’ve had freshwater aquariums for most of my life and have always enjoyed the hobby. Now, I’ve finally made the leap into marine aquariums. My main goal for this build is to spend wisely while ensuring I can enjoy the hobby long-term.
Tank Selection
Initially, I was planning to reuse an old tank that had previously been used for freshwater, along with a canister filter and all the usual equipment. However, after testing for leaks, I discovered my old tank had a leak. Rather than risking a DIY repair, I decided to go for a new setup.
I chose the Tideline 47g Lagoon AIO ($850 with tank and stand), as it seemed to offer the best price for the size compared to other options. I also considered the Waterbox 50.3 ($1500), but didn’t find the 3 gallon difference to be worth the extra money. Another option was the RedSea Max Nano G2 XXL, but I was discouraged by multiple sources citing concerns about leaks. I also looked into the Fusion Pro 2 50 AIO, but my LFS isn’t a vendor of theirs, and I wanted to support them.
When I received the Tideline tank, I was impressed by its quality—clear glass, solid construction, and well-put-together. However, I did learn that the stands are made to order and can take up to 4 weeks for delivery. I chose the black stand, which turned out to be more of a dark charcoal color than true black. The white stand, as I understand, is also more of a cream shade, not pure white. While I preferred the black of the Waterbox, I didn’t think the price difference was worth it.
Lighting
For lighting, I opted for two SMATFARM Aquarium Light-140W ($209 each). I compared them to the NICrew HyperReef 100 Gen 2 ($250 each) and Maxspect Razor X R5 200W ($760), but I decided the SMATFarms offered a good balance of wattage and LED count at a more affordable price. I probably got a little fixated on the wattage and should have considered the NICrews for their better user interface and additional accessories. Overall, I’m still happy with the SMATFarms and would recommend them to anyone looking for a more budget option.
I also looked at the AI Hydra 32 ($425) and Kessil AP9X ($870) but found both to be too pricey for my needs. I almost bought some Hydra 32s on Facebook Marketplace, but the price seemed too good to be true, and I didn’t want to risk getting scammed. Both the AI and kessil have bells and whistles galore and a supreme app interface. However, I don’t plan on changing the lighting settings that frequently and it seemed like overkill of a hobbyist.
Flow & Pumps
After reading about the flow limitations of AIO tanks, I decided to add a powerhead to improve water circulation. I chose two pumps for testing with the plan on returning one: the Hygger DC Wavemaker 1500GPH ($59) and the AQQA Aquarium Wave Maker Pump 1059GPH ($59). After some testing, both boxes got soaked… so now I have both. I’ve settled on the Hygger in the tank for now, as it keeps debris suspended in the water column and flows through the rockwork without too much disruption.
I also considered the AI Nero series, but they seemed overpriced at $170. Maxspect options were not recommended by my LFS, so I didn’t feel they were a good fit. Overall, I’m happy with the Hygger pump, which I’ve set to 50% power to prevent blowing my sand around. It’s working well for maintaining water movement and debris suspended till it makes its way to the overflows.
Auto Top Off (ATO)
A friend recommended an ATO, so I purchased the Useek AT200 Auto Top Off Smart ATO Lite ($49). There are more expensive models out there, but this one seemed to offer good value. It comes with a check valve, which is essential for preventing backflow. Overall, I’m happy with it. I used it to initially fill the tank without having to carry buckets around. Additionally, I ran the pump in an empty bucket, by accident, for 10 minutes, but it didn’t seem to cause any damage. The sensor appears to work fine and during testing it turned on and off the pump as desired.
Heater & Thermometer
For a heater, I went with the Finnex Titanium as recommended by my LFS. While I trusted their suggestion, I probably should’ve done more research since a heater is a critical piece of equipment. One thing I still need is a good thermometer. I’m disappointed with the accuracy of most aquarium thermometers, as they often have a +/- 1.5°F margin of error. I would love a more accurate model with a tolerance of just +/- 0.5°F and will likely use some personal connections to make a custom thermocouple setup just because.
Additional Equipment
I also picked up Aquaneat Bio Ceramic Rings (6lbs) ($20) for filtration, along with 40lbs of live rock and Caribsea sand. My LFS helped me choose the right supplies, and I’m not sure of the exact pricing for these.
Tank Setup
I leveled the stand as best as I could, but since it’s on carpet, the stand shifted a bit when I started filling the tank. I’ll need to re-level it. I bought larger pieces of live rock and spent a lot of time breaking them apart to shape them the way I wanted. Initially I didn’t want to do a lot of breaking apart but decided to just go for it. The rocks aren’t that expensive and I could always get another one. I did use the box the tank came un as a place to mock my setup. This was very helpful and would recommend using a cardboard tank for setting up that landscape.
Inside the stand, I’ve made space for two water buckets—one for fresh water for the ATO and one for saltwater for water changes. I installed power strips inside the stand, one for equipment that needs to be on all the time, and another for items that should be turned off during water changes. I may add a shelf later, but for now, the setup is pretty tidy.
Filtration Setup
The back of the AIO tank has five chambers. Here’s my current setup:
Future plans
The current long term plan for the tanks livestock:
I’m excited to continue setting up this tank, and I hope this thread can help others who are setting up their first saltwater tank. Any feedback or advice is greatly appreciated!

I’m excited to share my journey as I dive into my first saltwater tank! I’ve had freshwater aquariums for most of my life and have always enjoyed the hobby. Now, I’ve finally made the leap into marine aquariums. My main goal for this build is to spend wisely while ensuring I can enjoy the hobby long-term.
Tank Selection
Initially, I was planning to reuse an old tank that had previously been used for freshwater, along with a canister filter and all the usual equipment. However, after testing for leaks, I discovered my old tank had a leak. Rather than risking a DIY repair, I decided to go for a new setup.
I chose the Tideline 47g Lagoon AIO ($850 with tank and stand), as it seemed to offer the best price for the size compared to other options. I also considered the Waterbox 50.3 ($1500), but didn’t find the 3 gallon difference to be worth the extra money. Another option was the RedSea Max Nano G2 XXL, but I was discouraged by multiple sources citing concerns about leaks. I also looked into the Fusion Pro 2 50 AIO, but my LFS isn’t a vendor of theirs, and I wanted to support them.
When I received the Tideline tank, I was impressed by its quality—clear glass, solid construction, and well-put-together. However, I did learn that the stands are made to order and can take up to 4 weeks for delivery. I chose the black stand, which turned out to be more of a dark charcoal color than true black. The white stand, as I understand, is also more of a cream shade, not pure white. While I preferred the black of the Waterbox, I didn’t think the price difference was worth it.
Lighting
For lighting, I opted for two SMATFARM Aquarium Light-140W ($209 each). I compared them to the NICrew HyperReef 100 Gen 2 ($250 each) and Maxspect Razor X R5 200W ($760), but I decided the SMATFarms offered a good balance of wattage and LED count at a more affordable price. I probably got a little fixated on the wattage and should have considered the NICrews for their better user interface and additional accessories. Overall, I’m still happy with the SMATFarms and would recommend them to anyone looking for a more budget option.
I also looked at the AI Hydra 32 ($425) and Kessil AP9X ($870) but found both to be too pricey for my needs. I almost bought some Hydra 32s on Facebook Marketplace, but the price seemed too good to be true, and I didn’t want to risk getting scammed. Both the AI and kessil have bells and whistles galore and a supreme app interface. However, I don’t plan on changing the lighting settings that frequently and it seemed like overkill of a hobbyist.
Flow & Pumps
After reading about the flow limitations of AIO tanks, I decided to add a powerhead to improve water circulation. I chose two pumps for testing with the plan on returning one: the Hygger DC Wavemaker 1500GPH ($59) and the AQQA Aquarium Wave Maker Pump 1059GPH ($59). After some testing, both boxes got soaked… so now I have both. I’ve settled on the Hygger in the tank for now, as it keeps debris suspended in the water column and flows through the rockwork without too much disruption.
I also considered the AI Nero series, but they seemed overpriced at $170. Maxspect options were not recommended by my LFS, so I didn’t feel they were a good fit. Overall, I’m happy with the Hygger pump, which I’ve set to 50% power to prevent blowing my sand around. It’s working well for maintaining water movement and debris suspended till it makes its way to the overflows.
Auto Top Off (ATO)
A friend recommended an ATO, so I purchased the Useek AT200 Auto Top Off Smart ATO Lite ($49). There are more expensive models out there, but this one seemed to offer good value. It comes with a check valve, which is essential for preventing backflow. Overall, I’m happy with it. I used it to initially fill the tank without having to carry buckets around. Additionally, I ran the pump in an empty bucket, by accident, for 10 minutes, but it didn’t seem to cause any damage. The sensor appears to work fine and during testing it turned on and off the pump as desired.
Heater & Thermometer
For a heater, I went with the Finnex Titanium as recommended by my LFS. While I trusted their suggestion, I probably should’ve done more research since a heater is a critical piece of equipment. One thing I still need is a good thermometer. I’m disappointed with the accuracy of most aquarium thermometers, as they often have a +/- 1.5°F margin of error. I would love a more accurate model with a tolerance of just +/- 0.5°F and will likely use some personal connections to make a custom thermocouple setup just because.
Additional Equipment
I also picked up Aquaneat Bio Ceramic Rings (6lbs) ($20) for filtration, along with 40lbs of live rock and Caribsea sand. My LFS helped me choose the right supplies, and I’m not sure of the exact pricing for these.
Tank Setup
I leveled the stand as best as I could, but since it’s on carpet, the stand shifted a bit when I started filling the tank. I’ll need to re-level it. I bought larger pieces of live rock and spent a lot of time breaking them apart to shape them the way I wanted. Initially I didn’t want to do a lot of breaking apart but decided to just go for it. The rocks aren’t that expensive and I could always get another one. I did use the box the tank came un as a place to mock my setup. This was very helpful and would recommend using a cardboard tank for setting up that landscape.
Inside the stand, I’ve made space for two water buckets—one for fresh water for the ATO and one for saltwater for water changes. I installed power strips inside the stand, one for equipment that needs to be on all the time, and another for items that should be turned off during water changes. I may add a shelf later, but for now, the setup is pretty tidy.
Filtration Setup
The back of the AIO tank has five chambers. Here’s my current setup:
- First Stage: Filter bags that come with the tank (though they don’t reach the bottom, so I added a bag of ceramic rings on both sides).
- Second Stage (Left side): Heater.
- Second Stage (Right side): Additional ceramic rings. I plan to mix in carbon filters or other media as needed. Eventually, I may add a protein skimmer here if it fits, otherwise, I’ll move the heater to the display tank and add the protein skimmer there
- Third Stage: Return pump.
Future plans
The current long term plan for the tanks livestock:
- A clean up crew. I will likely be a little heavy on the hermit crabs since my kids love them. Otherwise I will follow the Top Shelf Aquatics Clean Up Crew Pack (Medium) counts. I will just get them from my LFS.
- Fish:
- 2 clowns
- Orchid or a Neon dottyback
- 6 line wrasse
- Yellow watchman goby and possibly a pistol shrimp
- Possibly something else
- Corals and More
- Anemone for the clowns
- Torches and hammers
- Zoas
I’m excited to continue setting up this tank, and I hope this thread can help others who are setting up their first saltwater tank. Any feedback or advice is greatly appreciated!
