Fish Face-Off - Week 3

[sassAwrasse]

Welcome to Week 3 of our Fish Face-Off.

This week we have the Copperband Butterfly



VS

the Longnose Hawkfish



Let's see your picks and why you chose this fish!

 

[sassAwrasse]

I'm choosing the longnose hawkfish. I like the way hawkfish perch on everything, but what made me choose this fish was seeing the one in the big cube tank at The Coral Reef. He was really neat and alot of personality.

 

[Bryan47]

Longnose Hawkfish

My brother passed away and a psychic told us when we see Hawks it's my brother. That week I stumbled upon this guy and I love how he always perches in my tank. I always think of him as my brother watching over my tank.

 

[SaltAddict89]

Gonna go with the copperband just do to its shape and its color

 

[JerSaint]

Hawks are so cool and have a great personality!

 

[chevy4w]

Not familiar with either fish but if I was at a LFS and looking at each side by side I think I would buy the Longnose Hawkfish. Don't know why.

 

[ctopal]

Love my long-nose hawkfish!

 

[RossTheReefer1]

I had a long nose hawkfish for many years and loved him. Very peaceful fish.

 

[phillrodrigo]

I can't believe that the long nose hawk is smoking the copperband butterfly. This really shocks me. The copperband is probably in my top 3 favs. I don't think any hawk is in my top 10

 

[captc07]

My vote is for the copperband butterfly. It is a gorgeous fish....and it'll take care of aiptasia! If I wasn't afraid it would starve in my tank I would have one. But I do agree that hawks have great personality.

 

[Triggreef]

My vote is for the copperband butterfly. It is a gorgeous fish....and it'll take care of aiptasia! If I wasn't afraid it would starve in my tank I would have one. But I do agree that hawks have great personality.

I chose copper band too. I was always too scared it would go after my corals, now that I've seen enough to be over the fear, I certainly have no room for one. I'm still thinking about it though.

Blake's has been getting a lot, & he says they are eating mysis. Very tempted.

 

[CT Reefer]

I'm going with the CBB. He is an easy reef inhabitant (gets along with everyone) and annihilates any apistasia!:angel:

 

[Randy Holmes-Farley Verified Community Expert]

Longnose hawks are certainly cool, but the copperband earns its keep by eating aiptasia and that easily puts it over the top!

 

[Bryan47]

Hey randy I tried sending you a message and it wouldn't let me? :(

 

[Randy Holmes-Farley Verified Community Expert]

Hey randy I tried sending you a message and it wouldn't let me? :(

Sorry, I had too many private messages of things which could just be threads that others could benefit from. :)

 

[Bryan47]

Oh I just wanted to say thanks for all you've done for the reefer and I am going to start using your home recipes for calc alk and mag. So thanks for saving me a ton of money!

 

[Randy Holmes-Farley Verified Community Expert]

You're very welcome.

FWIW, I'll soon be publishing a DIY alk test method. Accurate and cheaper. :)

 

[sassAwrasse]

You're very welcome.

FWIW, I'll soon be publishing a DIY alk test method. Accurate and cheaper. :)

very interested in this. SWEET!

 

[JerSaint]

very interested in this. SWEET!

+1 to this^

 

[Bryan47]

Awesome!