Go ahead….CONFESS!

Are you ready to confess to craziest, dumbest, funniest thing you’ve ever done in reefing?

  • Yeah, I'll confess! (Share your story in the comments!)

    Votes: 81 56.6%
  • Nah, I'll keep mine a secret...(Don't be like that, share with the class!)

    Votes: 62 43.4%

  • Total voters
    143
Killed my 6 year old blue tang and 5 year old wild caught yellow tang when using Flatworm Exit.
The treatment killed the flatworms but those two fish thought it was feeding time and ate them.
Killed both in under a minute. 6 fish took a bite or two and disappeared for a week, but did recover.
4 were not fooled and suffered no ill effects.
 
This past month, I have accidentally flooded my laundry room. I keep turning off the pump connected to the RODI unit, but forget to turn the hose off. I keep forgetting that shutting off the pump does not stop the water 😭. I've gotten 2 angry texts from my brother who keeps catching it. I need to install an alert system or something. This happens way too often!
 
Dumb……First tank… had corals…dosed kalk right into tank…..did not turn out well. 25 years later stupid chit still happens….but mostly water on the floor….
 
Please forgive me for I have sinned. I had assumed the effectiveness of seachem prime in saltwater environment, but what really happened is I reduced the water level in my AIO tank so that all sections were cascading wich increased aeration. I did them both simultaneously in hopes to save my fish. I was new to all in ones and instructions were not thorough, but it did not seem right. I don't believe my fish were "yawning" because of ammonia, I believe they were yawning because of low oxygen. Fortunately, it was very short time, and all inhabitants were happy within an hour. Much like when I used prime in freshwater for ammonia long ago for very similar symptoms.
 
I bought expensive live rock from Florida to set up my brand new tank. I was so excited, told them to leave allllll the good hitchhikers. I’d been planning and researching this for months, getting back into saltwater after a 15+ year hiatus.

Well I’d never used a refractometer before, back in the day I always used a hydrometer to measure salinity (this will be important later). I followed directions that came with it to calibrate and merrily (yes, merrily) went about my business mixing up my water. After a month I received the rock shipment, and was so careful about inspecting for anything I didn’t want added to my pristine new tank. I was really exciting about all the little beneficial crabs, starfish, clams/scallops I found. I put all the rock in my new tank and rearranged the scape just how I wanted.

Almost immediately the starfish started acting strange and dying! I tried to pull them out as fast as I could to put them back in the shipping water that came with the rock but it was too late. Managed to save a few crabs, that’s it. I immediately started testing for everything not knowing what had happened. Salinity perfect, no ammonia, nitrite etc, temperature good. I was completely freaking out. Ran to the store to get more freshwater to mix a new batch and pretty much completely refilled it just to be safe. Animals continued to suffer over the next day or two (the saved crabs went in another tank and thankfully one is still with us).

Finally went to the fish store to have my water tested. The salinity was almost 3x what it’s supposed to be. “But how?!?!” I belted out as everyone in the shop turned to look at me. I tested carefully using my brand new refractometer. Fish store owner informs me I needed to calibrate using a liquid that is set to 1.026 instead of what the directions said which was to use distilled water and set to zero. Went home (this time with premixed saltwater and the testing liquid in tow), and yes it was completely off. I still don’t understand quite how it could have been messed up that badly just from using distilled water but the stupid thing cracked a week later so I now have a much better model that I calibrate before each test just to be safe.

Killed 80% of what was on my beautiful live rock and am now in the process of curing it all in a bucket while my tank is re-cycling.

It was an expensive and heartbreaking lesson, I felt awful for killing so much wildlife.

Not a great pic, but here is my little survivor crab in his temporary home filtering the water. No matter how many expensive and colorful things I eventually add to my tank, he will always be my favorite 🥰


20260714_142622_871E4DB1-7F35-4EB9-9D9D-2856B2ED3BE3.png
I'm here to tell you i went through an alkalinity swing with a new tank with awesome live rock think about 4 dkh and low ph..... really unfortunate for some invertebrates. I thought I had killed everything. But I am here to tell you that 4 months later II noticed corals and tunicates even a couple baby brittle stars. a variety of feather dusters and sponges trickled in. A massive fleshy limpet snail from out of nowhere. some other cool snails trickled in. 8 months later I discovered a new species of starfish. And some kind of sea cucumber that i can only flashlight at night. The will to live is a strong one and I believe you will still have some critters waiting for their new home. I'm sure we both lost more than we can imagine, all you can do is learn and give the best care you can. My next tank will be setup, stable, and have a section dedicated of section for raw live rock as I find it the most intriguing.

There has also been the occasional "snapping" sound coming from my tank...
 
Last edited:
That I started this addiction at all.
 
My first time having a torch coral I saw stringy purple/brown coming out of it about a week in and immediately thought BJD. So I cancelled my dinner reservation with my wife and proceeded to spend the next 2 hours dipping it, treating it for BJD and observing it. Only to realize after I completely stressed it out, it was only pooping, I learned this because I posted about it and some kind folks informed me without being too harsh on my feelings. Fortunately it recovered just fine and it is back to happy again.
 
A month ago, my Red Sea return kept stalling, So many things were happening and I did all sorts of strange things to get it started and have it cycling. Put in my brand new back up return, same issue. Support got back to me quickly. Told me what to do to troubleshoot. Was told the skimmer power supply and return on controller run off identical power supplies bricks. Made sure to be home as the stalls would happen every hour. In the time I was waiting for the new power supply to arrive (via FedEx ground) and much energy going into getting a restart all the time, flooding the floor twice, being awake through the nights to restart it, I didn’t realize all I had to do was take the skimmer power supply, swap it over to the return connection of the controller. I was not using the skimmer anyways since the return stalls kept my sump level too full and instantly filling the skimmer collection cup. After days of babysitting this constant issue and waiting for FedEx to come, the lightbulb finally went off in my head. Um, “swap the brick dummy.”
 
Touched my scorpionfish “to see how bad the sting really is”
Well, you lived anyway. Couldn't be all that bad, right?! Glad you lived to tell the tale. Hope it didn't cause too much disruption in your body.
 
My first time having a torch coral I saw stringy purple/brown coming out of it about a week in and immediately thought BJD. So I cancelled my dinner reservation with my wife and proceeded to spend the next 2 hours dipping it, treating it for BJD and observing it. Only to realize after I completely stressed it out, it was only pooping, I learned this because I posted about it and some kind folks informed me without being too harsh on my feelings. Fortunately it recovered just fine and it is back to happy again.
Like going to the ICU post-BM! No harm done.
 

TOP 10 Trending Threads

HOW WOULD YOU FEEL ABOUT RECEIVING A FISH OR CORAL AS A HOLIDAY GIFT?

  • I’d love one, as long as it’s a species I chose

    Votes: 26 23.2%
  • I’d trust someone who knows my tank to choose

    Votes: 10 8.9%
  • I’d rather get a gift card and pick it myself

    Votes: 45 40.2%
  • I’d prefer gear or supplies instead

    Votes: 3 2.7%
  • Please don’t surprise me with livestock

    Votes: 28 25.0%
  • Other (Post in the comments)

    Votes: 0 0.0%
Back
Top
Home
Post thread…
Market
What's new