Goniopora Recession in reef, please help fix!

Cornball67

New Member
View Badges
Joined
Sep 2, 2026
Messages
2
Reaction score
1
What state or country do you live in
New York
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Hi everyone,

First post here, recently got a Maxspect LS-060 lagoon that's been setup with water and liverock since January, began to gradually stock in in May with various fish, inverts, and coral.

Fish consists of two juvenille clownfish, a midas blenny (adore the little guy), a royal gramma, a mckoskers flasher wrasse, and a watchman goby.

Inverts consist of a fighting conch, red leg and blue leg hermit crabs, a rock anemone, a skunk cleaner shrimp, and 3 berghia nudibranchs I got once the aptasia that came with the live rock began to multiply.

Corals consist of zoas, candy cane corals, rainbow montipora, orange montipora digitata, kermit the frog acropora, green bubble coral, lepto coral, red eye favia, duncan coral, aussie wall hammer, frogspawn, a gold and green branching hammer, alveopora coral, micromussa, a small lobo frag, and

The hobby has been incredible and everyone seems happy- no coral deaths other than an acropora frag that was ordered online and had RTN hours after being drip acclimated to my tank. I've had a recent bacterial infection in an acropora frag that survided after a coralRx dip and flatworms on my hammer coral that was treated with flatworm Rx. However, I couldn't say the same for my goniopora frags. I got them early July from an LFS that had them in good condition. They seemed to be ok for a week or two, I was still moving around a lot of the frags to see what they would like more and making room for new coral, I noticed the green one already starting to have shorter tentacles. I moved the red one higher near the center bridge of my rockwork, where it actually seemed to grow longer tentacles and seem happier in general. I decided to move the green one there as well, but found that after around two weeks both corals had begun to heavily recede. I conducted additional water tests, and found Mag was at ~1000, so I slowly upped the magnesium to ~1200 over the course of a few days, but this didn't seem to do much for them but made my acro very happy. I decided to move them down last week, where they have been closed up since. These are some of my favorite corals and I would hate to see them die. Would greatly appreciate any help on how to bring them back. Parameters are below, I test every few days, these have been consitent since last week and everything except Mag has been the same for ~1-2 months now- being auto-dosed with aquarforest 1,2,3 15ml daily to maintain. I use reagents for testing except hanna checker for alkalinity.

Alk: 9.7-10dkh
Calcium: 400ppm
Magnesium: 1290ppm
Salinity: 35-36ppm
pH: 8.1
Nitrate: 0-10ppm (depends how long since the last feeding)
Phosphate: 0.1ppm
Ammonia: 0ppm

I have attached pictures of how they looked like in July vs. now, any help would be greatly appreciated! Happy to answer any questions.



IMG_6380.jpeg
 

Attachments

  • IMG_6967.mov
    4.2 MB
  • IMG_6973.mov
    4.1 MB
  • IMG_6974.mov
    2.7 MB
Welcome to Reef2Reef!

In my experience Gonis will visibly adjust their tentacle length depending on even slight flow differences, which makes sense considering their long polyps. In calm water they extend much more than in heavy flow, so I'm not surprised you see differences depending on where you place them.

Changing positions ultimately changes flow and light, so the coral has to adjust, which is kind of stressful and takes time. Relocating corals frequently without giving them time to adjust is certainly not beneficial to their health, so I'd recommend letting them sit in one spot for multiple weeks if not months before moving them again, as long as there's no reason to believe the light/flow is harming them in a meaningful way.

I would definitely check for parasites, since some of them don't let go of the coral easily even when treated with coral dips. Take a magnifying glass and look for small dots that don't belong where they are. The community will be able to help if you manage to get good photos.

Are you supplementing any trace elements? This one is more based on anecdotal evidence from various people here on R2R, but apparently Gonioporas really like manganese (it's an essential trace element, so supplementing it makes sense). Dosing blindly is obviously not a good idea, but there are some decent products like ATI Daily Traces or Tropic Marin's Elements A- & K+ that you can add daily without having to worry too much about overdosing. An ICP test (preferably MS over OES) would also help verify your test results, as magnesium tests especially are very inaccurate, and it will help to get parameters in order you can't test at home.

It can also help to ask the vendor you got the frags from how much PAR they keep their Gonioporas under. That way you might be able to tell if light differences are causing issues.

I hope one of the listed suggestions turns out helpful 😊
 
IMO there is not a lot of flow in your tank, IMO flow is the most important for goni's, if they are placed in a too low flow spot they close up. I would also say they like more light than zoa's and acan's, and seeing the goni's at the same level as zoa's as acan's, I think not enough light and not enough flow. There is also a chance that the red one killed the green one, goni's have strong stings, some goni's can touch other goni's but some will kill other goni's, so I would not place them too close together
 
Welcome to Reef2Reef!

In my experience Gonis will visibly adjust their tentacle length depending on even slight flow differences, which makes sense considering their long polyps. In calm water they extend much more than in heavy flow, so I'm not surprised you see differences depending on where you place them.

Changing positions ultimately changes flow and light, so the coral has to adjust, which is kind of stressful and takes time. Relocating corals frequently without giving them time to adjust is certainly not beneficial to their health, so I'd recommend letting them sit in one spot for multiple weeks if not months before moving them again, as long as there's no reason to believe the light/flow is harming them in a meaningful way.

I would definitely check for parasites, since some of them don't let go of the coral easily even when treated with coral dips. Take a magnifying glass and look for small dots that don't belong where they are. The community will be able to help if you manage to get good photos.

Are you supplementing any trace elements? This one is more based on anecdotal evidence from various people here on R2R, but apparently Gonioporas really like manganese (it's an essential trace element, so supplementing it makes sense). Dosing blindly is obviously not a good idea, but there are some decent products like ATI Daily Traces or Tropic Marin's Elements A- & K+ that you can add daily without having to worry too much about overdosing. An ICP test (preferably MS over OES) would also help verify your test results, as magnesium tests especially are very inaccurate, and it will help to get parameters in order you can't test at home.

It can also help to ask the vendor you got the frags from how much PAR they keep their Gonioporas under. That way you might be able to tell if light differences are causing issues.

I hope one of the listed suggestions turns out helpful 😊
Hi,

Thanks so much for the response! I actually noticed a had low magnesium around 3 weeks ago, around 1000ppm, and started to dose with 10ml of Seachem Magnesion every day until magnesium was around 1290ppm, I now auto-dose aquaforest 1, 2, 3, which is supposed to provide every trace element necessary. The gonis were also in the tank when I treated it using flatworm exit for my hammer corals, I have not seen any flatworms of any kind on any coral since then. I will continue monitoring for another week or two to see if the gonis adjust and then get an ICP test to confirm. Thank you for the feedback!
 

TOP 10 Trending Threads

HOW DO YOU HANDLE HOLIDAY DECORATING AROUND YOUR REEF?

  • I decorate the tank or stand

    Votes: 1 20.0%
  • I decorate AROUND the tank or stand

    Votes: 1 20.0%
  • I add one small seasonal touch but keep it very basic

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • I take a holiday photo, but don’t decorate the space

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • I leave the reef area as it is

    Votes: 3 60.0%
  • We don’t decorate for the holidays

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Other (Post in the comments)

    Votes: 0 0.0%
Back
Top
Home
Post thread…
Market
What's new