Help! All my corals dying after bacterial bloom.

  • Thread starter Thread starter iLikeAlgae
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users Tagged users None

iLikeAlgae

Community Member
View Badges
Joined
Oct 15, 2024
Messages
38
Reaction score
5
Location
Coquitlam
What state or country do you live in
Canada
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Hi all, all the corals in my tank are dying, this is how it happened:

I have 12 gallon UNS 90B shallow tank where I keep:
- 2 small Clownfish
- 1 hermit crab
- 2 Turbo snails
- 3 Nessarius snails
- Several Zoas
- 2 hammers
- few small chalices
- 1 favia
- blade macroalgae

Tank is about 3 ~ 4 months old and Everyone is happy at this point. The tank recently had a terrible diatom bloom, much better now.

My sister recently started setting up her own tank, and she asked me if I could store her small bicolour dottyback while her tank is ready(it was a black Friday deal).
So I did just that and added the new fish, and since the LFS told us it only eats Mysis shrimp I bought a frozen cube of mysis shrimp as well.
1 day after I added new fish and fed mysis shrimp everything went downhill, I came from work and water was extremely milky.
One of clown fish was gasping for air, so I maxed the powerhead strength and added an air pump, did a 50% water change.
At that point PH was 6, but surprisingly Phosphate and nitrate was near 0. All the zoas are closed and hammer was clearly not doing well.
This was one week ago, since then I've been doing daily water change of 1 gallon, and had powerhead turned on at max.

PH is now around 6.8. But nitrate and phophate are still near 0. Salinity is 1.026 and temperature swings between 73F to 75F throughout the day.
- All the Zoas are still closed and I can visibly see them getting smaller and melting away.
- Favia looks dead.
- Hammers are showing white bones.
- Chalices however looks perfectly fine.
- Clownfish, hermit, turbos are happy.
- Dottyback is missing I can not find him anywhere.
- All the nessarius snails are not coming out, they used to react instantly to food but not anymore.
- All blade algae looks terrible and browned.

I thought I was getting hang of it, but I guess I was wrong :crying-face:
Any help is appreciated.

KakaoTalk_20241202_225230706_01.jpg KakaoTalk_20241202_225230706_02.jpg KakaoTalk_20241202_225230706_03.jpg KakaoTalk_20241202_225230706_04.jpg KakaoTalk_20241202_225230706_05.jpg
 
Not gonna lie, in a 12 gallon system if this happened I would have changed as close to 100% as possible right away without beaching the fish. But this is a very strange thing that happened and doesn't really make sense. I don't see how you can have saltwater with gas exchange and have the pH go to 6 like that, unless something were added to the water that would cause that directly. I suspect maybe your test is wrong for that, but I'm not a chemist.

The fact that a single cube of mysis could crash a tank, If that's what actually happened, is a serious argument for nobody to ever start a tank using just dry rock again. I recommend you try to get some pieces of live rock to seed the dry stuff you have. Doesn't matter where it comes from as long as it's wet and covered in life. I literally have never removed any dead fish over the years from my nano and this has still never happened to me. So it's not a skill or experience problem on your end. There was nothing you could have done and no way for you to know this would happen.
 
ph 6.8 is not good, that needs to be sorted.

Not sure if you started with a sterile tank with dry rock or not, but if yes with any addition you can introduce something which was not in the tank before and that might start to spread as its natural enemies are not present/widespread.

On my new tank I do the cycle with dry rock and in the dark, building up very strong biological filter this way, but once that's done I add pieces of live rock rubble - QT-ing them while cycle goes on and inspecting them closely for pests before adding them.
 
I recommend you try to get some pieces of live rock to seed the dry stuff you have.
I actually did just that, I got a few live rock pieces from my friend's established tank a month ago. Tank has been very stable for a while until I introduced new fish and a mysis shrimp.

I brought my water sample to LFS for testing where they kindly checked its nitrate and phosphate level, and was told my water is "too clean" for zoas. Whereas my friend(who's been reefing for a while) told me I should just increase aeration and feed less.

Not sure what to do at this point.
 
Just to confirm. Tank is several months old, but you added some live rock a month ago. How did you cycle the tank before this addition and what are you using to test parameters? Are you using Rodi?
 
One of clown fish was gasping for air, so I maxed the powerhead strength and added an air pump, did a 50% water change.

I thought I was getting hang of it, but I guess I was wrong :crying-face:

To be honest you likely saved that clownfish, so its good job.

Corals in an appereangly new and still unstable tank going through foodchain cycles will or will not survive, thats part of the hobby, even experienced reefers with mature tanks has many times problems with new additions which are thriving at others.

Main thing is you saved fish, tiny frags can be replaced any time.
 
I actually did just that, I got a few live rock pieces from my friend's established tank a month ago. Tank has been very stable for a while until I introduced new fish and a mysis shrimp.

I brought my water sample to LFS for testing where they kindly checked its nitrate and phosphate level, and was told my water is "too clean" for zoas. Whereas my friend(who's been reefing for a while) told me I should just increase aeration and feed less.

Not sure what to do at this point.
Keep tinkering with the tank many times causes more damage than good.

BUT if things go south I do this without thinking:
- carbon
- prime
- aeration
- water change
- (if ammonia/nitrite present add bacteria as well after)
 
Just to confirm. Tank is several months old, but you added some live rock a month ago. How did you cycle the tank before this addition and what are you using to test parameters? Are you using Rodi?
rough estimates timeline:
for 1st one month - I added water, sand and some fish food and just put the powerhead on
- I introduced snails and hermit crab and waited about a month
- I added clownfish and died the day after, I did 50% water change, took some rock from my friend's old tank
- few days later parameter seemed ok, and friend confirmed I should be able to get fish now with the cured live rocks so I got a clown pair
- everything has been fine for about 1 month until the incident last week
 
rough estimates timeline:
for 1st one month - I added water, sand and some fish food and just put the powerhead on
- I introduced snails and hermit crab and waited about a month
- I added clownfish and died the day after, I did 50% water change, took some rock from my friend's old tank
- few days later parameter seemed ok, and friend confirmed I should be able to get fish now with the cured live rocks so I got a clown pair
- everything has been fine for about 1 month until the incident last week
Lol thats an interesting sequence, the start is not exactly as per the book :D
 
Lol thats an interesting sequence, the start is not exactly as per the book :D
I did my research but I got little cocky in first 2 months and thought I could add fish early and just do daily water change. But the first fish died on first night even before I could perform any water change.

After getting some mature live rocks and having somewhat stable parameters I got cocky again and bought some expensive Zoas, which now all seems to be dying. :downcast-face-with-sweat:

At least clownfishes don't seem to mind the aesthetics of dying corals, and I really hope the dottyback is somewhere hiding being shy.

Thanks for the tips, I will keep the extra aeration going. I do not have carbon so I will try to get some from petsmart tomorrow after work...
 
IMO Sounds like you didn't grow any beneficial bacteria from the start.... Not enough bio-mass in sand to start a cycle(IMO I could be wrong)...I'd be curious if the fish food was enough decay to start it.... and the mysis you just added might have kickstarted it as well...
Once you got the rock from your buddies tank your cycle may have started... so you probably had an ammonia spike which is potentially the cause of some of the loss.
I'm not seeing an ammonia level stated? Are you checking that as well?

That's just my two cents, at this point continue water changes and let things ride, I wouldn't add anything more until you have a stable tank for at least a month or so.
 
Yes I am using Rodi and I use HANNA egg shaped tester things for alkalinity, phosphate. And Salifert tester for nitrates.
What are you using to test salinity? With your alk below 7 it could be your salinity is low.

Try target feeding the corals if you haven't. 0 nutrients in the water is bad if they are not catching some food.
 
iLikeAlgae not trying but I have a similar situation either I have a copepod or bacterial bloom going on right now. I too currently have a 12 gallon running( 3 month) at the moment with 2 clowns, 3 Nessarius snails, a stomitella snail somewhere, 5 hermits or maybe 6 since one is either dead or molting. Frags: 2 hammers, 1 richordea shroom, 1 Aussie Lord, 1 echinata, 1,Goni, Kenya tree and 2 GSPs. Recently my turbo snail got mangled by one of my hermits and was taken out immediately earlier this week. I recently added a skimmer (bubble magus miniQ) in the middle last week and ran it by the end of the week to see if it would assist with lowering my Phosphate. I noticed my salinity changed a little so I stopped it. Did my weekly water changed and left the skimmer off. I got the bloom on either Monday or Tuesday. Noticed my water was a little cloudy but had a bunch of little critters on all side of the tanks. Mostly everything looks happy but today I noticed one of my hammers tissue retracted a bit and my goni is not fully extended at the moment. Ill be monitoring my issue till my next WC in the next couple of days. Currently I’m not dosing extra stuff besides Microbater7 and Restore (Aminos).
 

TOP 10 Trending Threads

WHAT DO YOU ALWAYS RUN OUT OF AT THE WORST TIME?

  • Salt mix

    Votes: 17 18.9%
  • Fish or coral food

    Votes: 5 5.6%
  • Test kits or reagents

    Votes: 9 10.0%
  • Filter media or replacement fleece

    Votes: 5 5.6%
  • RO/DI filters or supplies

    Votes: 14 15.6%
  • Fragging and repair supplies, like glue or epoxy

    Votes: 10 11.1%
  • I keep a backup of everything

    Votes: 23 25.6%
  • Other (Post in the comments)

    Votes: 7 7.8%
Back
Top
Home
Post thread…
Market
What's new