Help Me Pick New Fish!

  • Thread starter Thread starter CastAway
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users Tagged users None

CastAway

Prone to wander, never lost.
View Badges
Joined
Jun 9, 2013
Messages
4,457
Reaction score
3,108
Location
Knoxville TN
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
I have amassed some store credit at one of my LFS's and would like to buy some new fish. I'm looking for some compatibility help, suggestions and insight.

I have a four year old 150g, 5ft long mixed reef, including a refugium.

Current fish list
1 - Lubbock's wrasse
2 - Ocellaris clowns, laying pair
4 - Lyretail anthias (3 female + 1 sub-male)
2 - Sapphire damsel, laying pair
1 - Tomini tang
1 - Scopas tang
1 - Potters wrasse
1 - Starry blenny
1 - Tailspot blenny
1 - Royal gramma

The Lubbock's displays a little aggression sometimes.
I've had success with red head and neon gobies. They were just very short lived it seems.
I recently lost an orchid dotty back. It was rarely out and visible except when I fed the tank. I think it was a natural death as I never saw it fighting with any other fish. It just disappeared.
I've kept a hippo tang successfully for years, then sold it.
I've lost a Midas blenny and two flame wrasse in the past, to jumping. I do not use a tank cover.

So far, my interests/candidates are:
  • Leopard wrasse, or pair
  • Terminal male lyre tail
  • Sunrise dotty back
  • Lemon Peel Angel
Be gentle...
 
Leopard wrasses may not be as jumpy as fairies or flashers, but with most wrasses, I think it's more a matter of "when" than of "if".

Not sure your sub-male lyretail will welcome a terminal male into that sweet harem he's got going on - and unlike some fish, I'm not sure anthias can reverse course.

Sunrise dottyback are beautiful, but IIRC, crankier than orchids. I suspect that you'd find his "stealth mode" similar, as he darts among the rockwork.

Lemon peels don't have the _most_ reef-safe reputation, but I know a fellow who has one, and his tank is gorgeous.

Either the sunrise or the lemon peel would give you bright colors, and it doesn't look like you've got a _ton_ of yellow in your fishy family so far.

Thoughts off the top of my head.

~Bruce
 
Thanks Bruce!!

I was looking at Artfully Acrylic just this morning, and think maybe it's time for a cover. Hate it, but....

Maybe another female or two would push my Lyretail to terminal?

I don't mind stealth; in fact find that trait nice. It adds a little variety.

Thanks again @Maritimer!
 
My thoughts mirror Bruce's.
 
I like the original thoughts and wouldn't add a terminal male lyretail. Maybe a couple more females and a nice school of green chromis would look great with them
 
Ive heard chromis pare actually pretty difficult; that there's an initial increased mortality rate.

Is this so?
 
I've had the same 3 chronic in my 150gal for Bout 15 months now no problem at all. I feed heavy though a d I think that's a key factor
 
Ive heard chromis pare actually pretty difficult; that there's an initial increased mortality rate.

Is this so?

Chromis are _very_ susceptible to Uronema marinum - you _don't_ want that in your display, as no "fallow period" can rid you of it. They also have a reputation for acting like "The Highlander" in many cases - picking one another off until only one (or perhaps a pair) remains.
 
Chromis are _very_ susceptible to Uronema marinum - you _don't_ want that in your display, as no "fallow period" can rid you of it. They also have a reputation for acting like "The Highlander" in many cases - picking one another off until only one (or perhaps a pair) remains.
Thank you!
 

TOP 10 Trending Threads

HOW MUCH DOES A FISH’S FEEDING REQUIREMENTS AFFECT YOUR STOCKING DECISIONS?

  • A lot! - I avoid fish that require frequent or specialized feeding

    Votes: 21 32.8%
  • Quite a bit, but an automatic feeder can change my answer

    Votes: 9 14.1%
  • It depends on whether my nutrient export can handle it

    Votes: 9 14.1%
  • It depends on how badly I want the fish

    Votes: 13 20.3%
  • Not much. I’m willing to adjust my routine

    Votes: 10 15.6%
  • Not at all. Feeding demands don’t limit my stocking choices

    Votes: 12 18.8%
  • I usually learn about the demanding feeding schedule after buying the fish!

    Votes: 2 3.1%
  • I haven’t really considered this before

    Votes: 4 6.3%
  • Something else (see my comments in the thread)

    Votes: 2 3.1%
Back
Top
Home
Post thread…
Market
What's new