I'm done with T5 fixture, making the switch to LED

dieselkeeper

Valuable Member
View Badges
Joined
Dec 4, 2012
Messages
1,093
Reaction score
2,291
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Both my Sunpower T5 fixtures got new tombstone/bulb ends a year ago due to they was cracked and not holding the bulbs in any longer. A year later, the bulbs won't turn to get them out. I already broke one bulb using pliers. The other fixture bulbs came out fine. I'm gonna start with my 90 gal carpet anemone tank switch to LED. I hope this is not gonna be like a which salt is better thread. I dont have any idea on which one. I needed help with light spread, depth, spectrum, and intensity. Am I gonna need a par meter to setup LED?
 
I really like my Kessil A360X/XEs. They ain't cheap though, and I did get a par meter to help dial them in. I was advised to get two of them over my 4' tank but it did not give quite enough spread to the sides of the tank, even with the 55 degree reflectors. I bought a third one and now it is perfect. They were the A360X back then, and have since been upgraded to XE. The XEs are a little brighter but I think the spread is the same as the X.
 
Wow thats crazy they barely lasted! Iv ran my Tek 8 bulb fixture for YEARS without any issues! I would recommend a par meter, but of course for an anemone only tank they can move if they do not like the intensity. Unless you plan to have corals as well? Im not sure of your price range, but here are some options below that arent crazy expensive.

I recently added a reef breeders edge 45 to my 90 gallon long and I am sure 2 of these would be more than enough for anemones! The 1 I added has great spread, and the reef 14k they offer would give you everything needed.

Nicrew 200w would also be a good place to start for a cheaper lighting option. I bet 2 would work perfect

Orrr a black box would work perfectly fine as well. Viparspectra would be the go to for a cheap black box
 
For a 90g you could use a reefbreeders Meridian 35 or two reefbreeder edge 45 bars. Both would give full coverage, plenty of power, and spectrum control.

You could also get two Meridian 11 and the link rail kit to connect them, each Meridian 11 can cover 24x24 and you can daisy chain them for power so there’s only a single cord.
 
I was able to get the bulbs to turn. I took the fixture down and sprayed a little lubricant in the bulb end. Worked them back and forth until they turned. I kicked that can down the road another year. One day I'll be forced to switch to LED when the ban on florescent bulbs goes into full effect.
 
I was able to get the bulbs to turn. I took the fixture down and sprayed a little lubricant in the bulb end. Worked them back and forth until they turned. I kicked that can down the road another year. One day I'll be forced to switch to LED when the ban on florescent bulbs goes into full effect.
If you go to the ATI North America web site they sell the sockets and I believe they were updated with different ones. Not a difficult task to do as well

https://store.atinorthamerica.com/products/socket?variant=33285698369
 
I replaced all the sockets last year when I replaced the bulbs. I got them from Amazon. I already kicked myself for not spending the extra money for ATI sockets.
 
I replaced all the sockets last year when I replaced the bulbs. I got them from Amazon. I already kicked myself for not spending the extra money for ATI sockets.

Well that’s the problem. The ATI ones really are superior. I’ve got 2 sun powers. Never had to replace the sockets. Just keep them dry and clean.

Also there is no fluorescent bulb ban. It doesn’t apply to aquarium lights or grow lights etc. But it isn’t a bad idea to stock up on bulbs. I just changed mine for the year and have 2 more years in boxes. About to order another 2 years worth.
 
I replaced all the sockets last year when I replaced the bulbs. I got them from Amazon. I already kicked myself for not spending the extra money for ATI sockets.
You need to get the sockets from ATI. They are way superior than any other brand. The secret to move the lamps to unlock the socket is to grab the metal part of the lamp and play left/right gently. Again, ATI sockets is what you need!!! I used mine for 15+ years before replacing them. Take your time when working on the fixture and pay attention. You will enjoy doing it and the results will make a HUGE difference due to the quality of their sockets! T5s are amazing! Way better than any LEDs over 24" high or less systems, in terms of qualities of light IMO. Specially the amazing distribution and superior spectrum. Have fun!
 
Last edited:
Well that’s the problem. The ATI ones really are superior. I’ve got 2 sun powers. Never had to replace the sockets. Just keep them dry and clean.

Also there is no fluorescent bulb ban. It doesn’t apply to aquarium lights or grow lights etc. But it isn’t a bad idea to stock up on bulbs. I just changed mine for the year and have 2 more years in boxes. About to order another 2 years worth.
Here is the list of states have or gonna have ban on fluorescent bulb ban.

https://www.pecnw.com/blog/active-list-of-us-states-banning-fluorescent-lights/
 
Both my Sunpower T5 fixtures got new tombstone/bulb ends a year ago due to they was cracked and not holding the bulbs in any longer. A year later, the bulbs won't turn to get them out. I already broke one bulb using pliers. The other fixture bulbs came out fine. I'm gonna start with my 90 gal carpet anemone tank switch to LED. I hope this is not gonna be like a which salt is better thread. I dont have any idea on which one. I needed help with light spread, depth, spectrum, and intensity. Am I gonna need a par meter to setup LED?
I would stick with T5.

You'll struggle to be happy with LED and the change may well affect your coral.

Starting a new tank with LED is one thing, changing an existing tank is a different beast altogether.

It may be a change you regret.
 
if you want fast coral growth, sun powers are it. if you want that coral pop, led is superior. Do both
+1.

I've been meaning to add some T5 to my LED only tank for a while now (it was started with LED).

LED is just too directional for even SPS growth - unless you have a billion of them.
 
Here is the list of states have or gonna have ban on fluorescent bulb ban.

https://www.pecnw.com/blog/active-list-of-us-states-banning-fluorescent-lights/

Not a single actual law applies to grow lights or aquarium lights. This has come up 100x on here.

Here is just California’s version.
IMG_2011.jpeg
 
IF you decide to go LED, just pay attention to the spectrum. Sure, you need power, but it's pretty hard to under do it with LEDs. I'll be going with the Photon Pro. And running it at about 35% give or take. But it really does matter with spectrum. I've seen some pretty sketchy patterns out there with cheaper units.
 
Both my Sunpower T5 fixtures got new tombstone/bulb ends a year ago due to they was cracked and not holding the bulbs in any longer. A year later, the bulbs won't turn to get them out. I already broke one bulb using pliers. The other fixture bulbs came out fine. I'm gonna start with my 90 gal carpet anemone tank switch to LED. I hope this is not gonna be like a which salt is better thread. I dont have any idea on which one. I needed help with light spread, depth, spectrum, and intensity. Am I gonna need a par meter to setup LED?

Have you seen led setups in person?
I've tried most of the led fixtures and I just can't get used to them long term. Running a ATI Powermodule right now, and for my upgrade I will be going back to halides.
 
Have you seen led setups in person?
I've tried most of the led fixtures and I just can't get used to them long term. Running a ATI Powermodule right now, and for my upgrade I will be going back to halides.
i’m slightly disappointed with the lack of glow that the t5’s do not provide coming off of running kessils. However, the par and coverage more than make it worth it. I’m putting a quanta bar in front of my ati sunpower
 
Both my Sunpower T5 fixtures got new tombstone/bulb ends a year ago due to they was cracked and not holding the bulbs in any longer. A year later, the bulbs won't turn to get them out. I already broke one bulb using pliers. The other fixture bulbs came out fine. I'm gonna start with my 90 gal carpet anemone tank switch to LED. I hope this is not gonna be like a which salt is better thread. I dont have any idea on which one. I needed help with light spread, depth, spectrum, and intensity. Am I gonna need a par meter to setup LED?
Reefi Uno 2.1s. 2 of them mounted high. Watt for dollar best LEDs out IMO but not what I would call a “value” brand. Much, much better than Radions at half the price.
 

TOP 10 Trending Threads

WHAT DO YOU ALWAYS RUN OUT OF AT THE WORST TIME?

  • Salt mix

    Votes: 17 18.9%
  • Fish or coral food

    Votes: 5 5.6%
  • Test kits or reagents

    Votes: 9 10.0%
  • Filter media or replacement fleece

    Votes: 5 5.6%
  • RO/DI filters or supplies

    Votes: 14 15.6%
  • Fragging and repair supplies, like glue or epoxy

    Votes: 10 11.1%
  • I keep a backup of everything

    Votes: 23 25.6%
  • Other (Post in the comments)

    Votes: 7 7.8%
Back
Top
Home
Post thread…
Market
What's new