Is it possible for a cycle to happen in a week?

Advil_LiquiGLs

Community Member
View Badges
Joined
May 12, 2026
Messages
71
Reaction score
78
Location
Las Vegas
What state or country do you live in
Nevada
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Hey yall. So heres the setup: I started this 10 gallon a week ago. At first my plan was to feed snails to cycle the tank but that failed and the snails died within 3 days in the tank. Thats my fault. I left them in there to build up ammonia. Then i threw a whole frozen shrimp in there.

At the time of adding water to tank, I seeded it with seachem stability and pristine. I used a lot of each.

The water was cloudy for a couple days but i let that cycle and now the water is crystal clear and i have brown algae growing. I only have expired api kits and looking to upgrade to hanna or salifert for my next buy.

Point is I dont have a clue what the parameters are other than salinity (which i used a refractometer) and temp (78F) but I plan to get it tested at my local lfs tomorrow. If i test negative across the board is this tank cycled? Also should note I am getting a 4 stage rodi but for now I used tap water to make the seawater. Maybe that's why I have so much brown algae so quick? I should also keep the lights off but i have gracilaris algae in there so i kept lights on for it. Prolly so many noobie mistakes here by bear with me ill get better lol.

I also wanna add cuc soon to eat all this brown algae. Water is looking clear and alluring me to add things in it. Is it a trap?

Sorry for all these questions. Id rather hear your opinions so i know what direction to go overall. Thanks

17790754353148695153012236018811.jpg
 
What I consider cycled is the ability for an ecosystem to process ammonia from 2ppm to zero in 24 hours for about 4 days in a row.
 
Yes with live rock for sure.
My current tank was a transfer from an existing set up with extra rock I cooked for about 6 months before. It insta-cycled with zero uglies.
 
Hey yall. So heres the setup: I started this 10 gallon a week ago. At first my plan was to feed snails to cycle the tank but that failed and the snails died within 3 days in the tank. Thats my fault. I left them in there to build up ammonia. Then i threw a whole frozen shrimp in there.

At the time of adding water to tank, I seeded it with seachem stability and pristine. I used a lot of each.

The water was cloudy for a couple days but i let that cycle and now the water is crystal clear and i have brown algae growing. I only have expired api kits and looking to upgrade to hanna or salifert for my next buy.

Point is I dont have a clue what the parameters are other than salinity (which i used a refractometer) and temp (78F) but I plan to get it tested at my local lfs tomorrow. If i test negative across the board is this tank cycled? Also should note I am getting a 4 stage rodi but for now I used tap water to make the seawater. Maybe that's why I have so much brown algae so quick? I should also keep the lights off but i have gracilaris algae in there so i kept lights on for it. Prolly so many noobie mistakes here by bear with me ill get better lol.

I also wanna add cuc soon to eat all this brown algae. Water is looking clear and alluring me to add things in it. Is it a trap?

Sorry for all these questions. Id rather hear your opinions so i know what direction to go overall. Thanks

17790754353148695153012236018811.jpg
That is likely diatoms, not algae, fed from silicates in the tap water,

What does the API ammonia test read currently?
 
I feel like your rushing here, why not just wait a day or two to get the test kits and get the rodi? I feel like your cutting corners and skipping steps to get livestock quicker.
 
It might be easier to plan on being patient. Years ago I started a 40 breeder. Fill with salt water, wait 2 weeks. Add sand and bacteria, wait 2 weeks. Add rock wait two weeks. Knowing that patience pays off you won’t feel rushed to get started. Good luck
 
I feel like your rushing here, why not just wait a day or two to get the test kits and get the rodi? I feel like your cutting corners and skipping steps to get livestock quicker.
yeah, I have a problem with being too eager. But I'm seriously new to this and was just looking for your advice because it confused me as to why I have clear water now like I thought the cloudiness was to remain for a couple weeks.
Also the test kits and RODI are next on my list, and as for adding livestock quicker I'm just unsure of where in the process I am at. I didnt mean to come off as "Hey, cycled, tank ready for fish?". I just seriously am trying to learn the ropes here. Like if the cycle is indeed "finished" isnt the next logical step CUC to eat the brown algae?
 
My advice as a fellow newbie. (Take what I say worth a grain of salt) look up “serious reef” on Patreon. It’s 6-10 bucks a month and he has a step by step guide on cycling and setting up a new tank called the 90/10 method. 90% of the results for 10% of the work. Along with hours of other good information. IMO. Again take it worth a grain of salt. But might be worth checking out for a month. Worst case you lost 10 bucks. Best case you move from newbie to successful beginner. :)
 
Depends on your definition of cycled. Is the tank ready for livestock, not even close. The fact that the water is clear means nothing in terms of cycled. Using tap water is the worse thing you can do for a reef tank. So many nasty elements that will just cause headaches in the future. Also no need to spend money on a Class to learn, wish people would stop advertising programs with info that is already free on line. All the info is free on youtube, just takes a few click to find it. BRS has done an amazing job providing all the info you need to start the right way. The brown algae is probably caused by the tap water used. Slow down and wait till you get the RO/DI unit. If you plan to be in this hobby for a while you will need to learn wait.
 
Depends on your definition of cycled. Is the tank ready for livestock, not even close. The fact that the water is clear means nothing in terms of cycled. Using tap water is the worse thing you can do for a reef tank. So many nasty elements that will just cause headaches in the future. Also no need to spend money on a Class to learn, wish people would stop advertising programs with info that is already free on line. All the info is free on youtube, just takes a few click to find it. BRS has done an amazing job providing all the info you need to start the right way. The brown algae is probably caused by the tap water used. Slow down and wait till you get the RO/DI unit. If you plan to be in this hobby for a while you will need to learn wait.
I wish people would stop hating on investing in quality info…yes it’s all out there, if you can find it and discern it from the bad info.

I guess we can’t all have our wishes…idk man I’m going to keep advertising it. And you can keep wishing I wouldn’t….
 
yeah, I have a problem with being too eager. But I'm seriously new to this and was just looking for your advice because it confused me as to why I have clear water now like I thought the cloudiness was to remain for a couple weeks.
Also the test kits and RODI are next on my list, and as for adding livestock quicker I'm just unsure of where in the process I am at. I didnt mean to come off as "Hey, cycled, tank ready for fish?". I just seriously am trying to learn the ropes here. Like if the cycle is indeed "finished" isnt the next logical step CUC to eat the brown algae?
Its very understandable to be impatient.

Personally I like to add fish and hermit crabs first, then I add snails as I start to see algae. The brown algae is likely diatoms at this stage, its a normal progression of the tank. The diatoms are feeding off the silicates in the new sand, as well as the silicates in tap water, and it will die away on its own in a few weeks once it has consumed all the silicates. Copepods consume diatoms as well as some kinds of snails.

With that said, not sure if you are aware, but a 10 gallon is considered extremely small in this hobby, and very few fish can fit in that tank. For example the suggested tank size for a pair of clownfish is 20 gallons. A 10 gallon can fit 1 or 2 small gobies. My own 10 gallon has a single damsel, which I admit should be in a larger tank. If you have the means, I would suggest that a 20 gallon is a great beginner size tank.

Good luck
 
My 3 steps process to this saltwater hobby.
1 Money
2 Patience
3 Execute

You've made it thru the first step 😅


Good luck and happy reefing !
 
I agree with all the others in that it's generally not a good idea to use tap water I most municipalities. I'd suggest using gallons of distilled water or your local fish shop likely sells RODI water.

However, in the pics posted above, I see some kind of macro algae growing, and quite a bot of coralline. Did you use real, wet live rock that came from a local fish shop or another hobbyist? If so, this tank would be ready for some livestock. The rock you bought (if real live rock) would have already been "cycled", so to speak.

I would say start using distilled water to make saltwater for your water changes, and add some hermits and other critters, or possibly one small, hardy fish, like a small Goby. As mentioned above, 10 gallons isn't a whole lot of real estate for saltwater fish, but you can do two or maybe three small, peaceful fish.

I hope this helps!
 
Thanks for all the info and replies guys. I plan to get my RODI today and the test kits tomorrow. I was getting away with using tap for my freshwater tank but looks like I can't with saltwater. I actually plan to have just coral and a couple of inverts in this tank and no fish, I understand this is considered a 'nano tank' but im ready for the challenge. In my dry climate is already needing a cup or two if i forget of top off daily
 
If you want to do just corals and some motile inverts, then you're fine to start adding them. No cycle is really needed for corals, and, again, it looks to me like you have mature, fully cycled live rock 🙂
 
I at first thought not to post my results, but after second thought as arbitrary as it is, id just like to post my thoughts.

But after one week I am definitely NOT cycled. I bought salifert test kits and they should be coming in the mail soon. So I had my local lfs check my water. I forget what tests they were, but they were some brand i wasnt familiar with. Nor was it hanna nor salifert. But they tested .25ppm ammonia (some ammonia) and 0 nitrites and 0 nitrates. I was able to buy brand new tetra min 6 in one and ammonia test. I understand these arent recommended but i was super curious what they would read.

My reading was

6ppm Ammonia
0 Nitrites
0 Nitrates

Ill confirm with salifert but this might be a lesson to me: even though it got cloudy and clear its not gonna be cycled in a week. I suspect im not seeing nitrites because its just too early in the process?

Anyways thanks to yall that chimed in. But i am no where near live stock. Should I break up the algae for now? Leave it in there until it eats all the silica or whatnot in the water? My 4 stage rodi is coming soon, so if possible ill be able to "redo" the saltwater if i need to, but my gut is telling me to leave the current water to cycle, and then when i water change it for the first time use the rodi water
 
I was able to buy brand new tetra min 6 in one and ammonia test. I understand these arent recommended but i was super curious what they would read.
Friend, I don't know what these tests are, but they sound like test 'strips', and if so, definitely not recommended 🙃

I asked above, but I'll ask again - did you start your tank with rock that came 'wet' out of a tank? It looks like it to me, and if so, you're cycled 🙂

Did you add anything that might have raised the ammonia concentration? I don't believe you got 6.0 ppm ammonia without either adding ammonia such as Dr. Tim's Ammonium Chloride, or if you had a fish or two and they both died at once. This is almost certainly testing error 🙂

I would suggest that you get your RODI filter up and running, get yourself a food-grade 5 gallon pail from your local Mega-Lo-Mart for all of about $6. Add an inexpensive heater and circ pump, and use this to pre-mix and heat your saltwater for water changes.

Then, just start doing regular, partial (10%-20%) water changes each week, and soon enough you'll swap out the tap water.

Or, given that you don't yet have any delicate livestock, and this is a 10 gallon system, I'd change 50% to 100% of the water a couple of times, Im sure you'll be fine 🙂
 

TOP 10 Trending Threads

WHAT DO YOU ALWAYS RUN OUT OF AT THE WORST TIME?

  • Salt mix

    Votes: 18 18.6%
  • Fish or coral food

    Votes: 5 5.2%
  • Test kits or reagents

    Votes: 10 10.3%
  • Filter media or replacement fleece

    Votes: 5 5.2%
  • RO/DI filters or supplies

    Votes: 15 15.5%
  • Fragging and repair supplies, like glue or epoxy

    Votes: 12 12.4%
  • I keep a backup of everything

    Votes: 25 25.8%
  • Other (Post in the comments)

    Votes: 7 7.2%
Back
Top
Home
Post thread…
Market
What's new