https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5441187/
This link cites over 50 different articles and its all summerized in the first few paragraphs.
Im not saying youre wrong in your reasoning but this theory has been proved already.
Plus I'm only speaking from my experience.
So please let me edit my first post.
"In my experience" should have been interjected into the beginning of my sentence you quoted in bold.
But isnt that why we are here on a forum?
To share our experiences and observations in reefing?
#science
Salty, lets look at what you cited, & what it says, keeping in mind this P-N ratio of no more than 5 to 10:1 that you recommend.
The paper refers to "skewed nitrogen (N) to phosphorus (P) ratios negatively affecting coral. But it clearly makes several points that you & another seem to over look, that are important.
1. " We exposed corals to imbalanced N-P ratios in long-term experiments and found that the
undersupply of phosphate severely disturbed the symbiosis, indicated by the loss of coral biomass, malfunctioning of algal photosynthesis and bleaching of the corals."
2. "In our experiments, a phosphate concentration of ~ 0.3 μM
(0.0285ppm) at a N/P ratio of >>>>
22:1 <<<<< yielded an
overall healthy phenotype."
3. *** "Accordingly, it is likely that the absolute N/P ratio becomes also
less critical for the proper functioning of the symbionts when phosphate concentrations
exceed a
vital supply threshold > 0.3 μM
(0.0285ppm), even when the symbionts are rapidly proliferating."
-----------------------------------------------------
So the paper suggests that if PO4 is maintained at 0.03 ppm or above,
which is typically advised in the hobby, a N to P ratio of 22:1 & higher is fine. To me, suggesting a N to P ratio of 5 to 10:1 as necessary for coral health is baseless.
No where is a 5 to 10:1 P-N ratio mentioned in that paper that i could see, let alone a recommendation for an aquarium.
I agree with Randy.