New Tank without Fish PO4 is rising

  • Thread starter Thread starter Gsponi
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users Tagged users None

Gsponi

Active Member
View Badges
Joined
Mar 14, 2025
Messages
141
Reaction score
99
Location
Switzerland
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Hello Guys.
Its been 15 Days since i started my Reef Tank. But since the first Day my PO4 is rising and i cant explain it.

Its a netto 180L Tank
Barebottom with new Carrib Sea Live Rock Branches with lots of Air and only a few Ground Contact points.

A Tunze 9004 Skimmer and a Jebao SLW20 .

The PO4 is going up from 0.01to 0.2 in little steps, day per day but i dont have Any Fish, i dont have any old Rocks, i dont have any Foods in the Tank, i dont have any Sand .
My Osmose is new with Mischbettharzfilter ( dont knoe the english word) and the Water is showing 0.01 ppm so totally fine.
I use Arka Special Blend and Nite Out2 and yes i tried to quit it and see if it makes any difference but no.
And i dose Ati Nutritions N
My no3 is 2
KH is 8.8
Calcium 430
Magnesium 1290
Temp. 25c
Salinity 1023

My Skimmer is working well my water is cristal clear and my Corals are looking great.

Do i miss something ? I mean Phospat can reproduce by its one😅
Hopefully someone can help
Tommorow i start with a 20% Water change
IMG_3553.jpeg
IMG_3551.jpeg
IMG_3552.jpeg
 
Hello Guys.
Its been 15 Days since i started my Reef Tank. But since the first Day my PO4 is rising and i cant explain it.

Its a netto 180L Tank
Barebottom with new Carrib Sea Live Rock Branches with lots of Air and only a few Ground Contact points.

A Tunze 9004 Skimmer and a Jebao SLW20 .

The PO4 is going up from 0.01to 0.2 in little steps, day per day but i dont have Any Fish, i dont have any old Rocks, i dont have any Foods in the Tank, i dont have any Sand .
My Osmose is new with Mischbettharzfilter ( dont knoe the english word) and the Water is showing 0.01 ppm so totally fine.
I use Arka Special Blend and Nite Out2 and yes i tried to quit it and see if it makes any difference but no.
And i dose Ati Nutritions N
My no3 is 2
KH is 8.8
Calcium 430
Magnesium 1290
Temp. 25c
Salinity 1023

My Skimmer is working well my water is cristal clear and my Corals are looking great.

Do i miss something ? I mean Phospat can reproduce by its one😅
Hopefully someone can help
Tommorow i start with a 20% Water change
IMG_3553.jpeg
IMG_3551.jpeg
IMG_3552.jpeg
A possible suspect is the bacteria additions., either the medium or dying bacteria. Adding heterotrophic bacteria to a new aquarium is starving them. They might be lysing and dumping phosphate.

Mix a sample of aquarium with these products one at a time and test the mixture for phosphate. Let mixture stand a day or two and retest.

Sorry, this is the only idea I have.
 
My nano did the same thing. High P at the very beginning, then one day the rocks and sand decided to start absorbing P and I couldn’t keep it above 0ppm for months. Finally, 6 months in, it’s starting to stabilize around 0.04 - 0.06ppm. I had to dose crazy amounts of trisodium phosphate daily to get it to finally register on the Hanna test and even more to have it reach an equilibrium to where it is now.
 
A possible suspect is the bacteria additions., either the medium or dying bacteria. Adding heterotrophic bacteria to a new aquarium is starving them. They might be lysing and dumping phosphate.

Mix a sample of aquarium with these products one at a time and test the mixture for phosphate. Let mixture stand a day or two and retest.

Sorry, this is the only idea I have.
Hi yeah i think its the only possible Way were Phospat comes into the Tank.
Arka Bacteria is specially made for new Reef Tank Start Ups.
But yes its going up in a constant curve and i dose a constant ammount.
In the morning i added 300ml Osmose water and a bit of Special Blend and Nite out and tested directly after that. Clearly it was to much for the amount of water but it showed a PO4 of 0.9! Hanna checker.

I think the Bacterias need to have some Phosphat ore someting in the bottle because they need do eat?

I will check in the evening and willmmake a 20% waterchange to bring it down to 0.15 and i will buy some Phospat absorbing Granulat.
 
My nano did the same thing. High P at the very beginning, then one day the rocks and sand decided to start absorbing P and I couldn’t keep it above 0ppm for months. Finally, 6 months in, it’s starting to stabilize around 0.04 - 0.06ppm. I had to dose crazy amounts of trisodium phosphate daily to get it to finally register on the Hanna test and even more to have it reach an equilibrium to where it is now.
Do you know why it starts rising? Did you use Nite Out
 
It was my understanding that it was the new dry rock and sand that I started with. Once it reaches equilibrium, the numbers settle down and stablize.
 
A possible suspect is the bacteria additions., either the medium or dying bacteria. Adding heterotrophic bacteria to a new aquarium is starving them. They might be lysing and dumping phosphate.

Mix a sample of aquarium with these products one at a time and test the mixture for phosphate. Let mixture stand a day or two and retest.

Sorry, this is the only idea I have.
I probably found the Reason. I tested the misxture and it went instantly blue. I didnt dose the Special Blend and Nite out for 3 days and had a Phosout Granulat in it. It went down to 0.05! Nice
 
I probably found the Reason. I tested the misxture and it went instantly blue. I didnt dose the Special Blend and Nite out for 3 days and had a Phosout Granulat in it. It went down to 0.05! Nice
I am happy you solved the mystery!
 
Tank is 15 days old and has coral...?

Am I reading something wrong or would it not be still cycling?
Lots of ways to do a reef. You can do corals day one with no precycle if you know what you are doing. Corals, macro, plants prefer ammonia to nitrate all three have to turn nitrate back into ammonia to use it. With proper dosing of ammonia and phosphate you can start a fishless reef full of corals as long as you understand the basics of dosing and testing for all the parameters.
 
Tank is 15 days old and has coral...?

Am I reading something wrong or would it not be still cycling?
Hi no . You seen right. There are lots of different oppinions about this. Some say just let it cycle some says load it with corals directly and 100 more. More modern is it to do a fast loading with corals, because the product and bacterias are more modern than a few years ago.
But everybody can do it like he wants to do it. I use Arka Special Blend and Nite out (Real life Bacterias) to Quick start my Tank and yes i have algee and my nitrate is 2 and nitrite is <0.1 and i already had my nitrite peak. Im from Europe i could show you a lot of videos were they says just set up a few corals after a few days.
Sorry for my english do you understand what i say?
May coral are getting bigger and open more than the first days and even my zoanthos are getting new polyps.
 
I understand this to a point, and if its set up with live rock then the tank is pretty much insta-cycled anyway.

I did this in my tank anyway :)
Still had trouble with SPS though until about a 6 months in.
 
I understand this to a point, and if its set up with live rock then the tank is pretty much insta-cycled anyway.

I did this in my tank anyway :)
Still had trouble with SPS though until about a 6 months in.
I did use Carrib sea life Rock but no Sand. With Sand i think it would be much quicker
 
Live cycled rock is the quickest easiest way to do something like this and has been done for years. Dry rock is a little harder and actually bacteria adds are not even needed but you have to understand things like dry rock and sand can pull phosphates, alk, calc and mag out of the water and test for this. You also need to worry about dosing ammonia and phosphates to feed the corals not too much but not to little. I have a 180g I am in process of setting up and have not decided if I want to try my hand at starting like this or do a traditional cycle like I did on the current tank. Time wise I will probably just do a traditional cycle. I dont have the time to test daily.
 
Live cycled rock is the quickest easiest way to do something like this and has been done for years. Dry rock is a little harder and actually bacteria adds are not even needed but you have to understand things like dry rock and sand can pull phosphates, alk, calc and mag out of the water and test for this. You also need to worry about dosing ammonia and phosphates to feed the corals not too much but not to little. I have a 180g I am in process of setting up and have not decided if I want to try my hand at starting like this or do a traditional cycle like I did on the current tank. Time wise I will probably just do a traditional cycle. I dont have the time to test daily.
yeah i have been testing a lot but i only had the unstable phospat because the Nite Out. Until now i think ive been lucky. I didnt use Sand because i dont want depots and i like to have nice flow. And a queue factor is, i build my setup out of life rock branches and its very slim
 
Live cycled rock is the quickest easiest way to do something like this and has been done for years. Dry rock is a little harder and actually bacteria adds are not even needed but you have to understand things like dry rock and sand can pull phosphates, alk, calc and mag out of the water and test for this. You also need to worry about dosing ammonia and phosphates to feed the corals not too much but not to little. I have a 180g I am in process of setting up and have not decided if I want to try my hand at starting like this or do a traditional cycle like I did on the current tank. Time wise I will probably just do a traditional cycle. I dont have the time to test daily.
IMG_3398.jpeg
 
Most likely leeching from the rock and sand, can take a few months and regular water changes for phosphates to settle. Shouldn’t go higher than .25 if you’re doing a 20% weekly. Can also add some phosphate absorbing media to your filter/sump if you don’t want to be doing frequent water changes. You might experience on and off string algae or cyano blooms until things settle, just blow off any cyano from all surfaces with a turkey baster and vacuum out as much as you can when you do your water change.
 
Most likely leeching from the rock and sand, can take a few months and regular water changes for phosphates to settle. Shouldn’t go higher than .25 if you’re doing a 20% weekly. Can also add some phosphate absorbing media to your filter/sump if you don’t want to be doing frequent water changes. You might experience on and off string algae or cyano blooms until things settle, just blow off any cyano from all surfaces with a turkey baster and vacuum out as much as you can when you do your water change.
Yeah it stoppet rising and lowered to 0.04
I used PO0.04 Absorber .
But do you think it can leech from newe unused Carrib Seablive Rock ? Its more likely to absorb at the beginning?
 
Yeah it stoppet rising and lowered to 0.04
I used PO0.04 Absorber .
But do you think it can leech from newe unused Carrib Seablive Rock ? It’s more likely to absorb at the beginning?
Sorry, leeching probably wasn’t the right word. Algae, bacteria, uneaten food, and other organic matter settles in the porous live rock and decomposes to release phosphate over time.

With 2ppm nitrate and 0.2ppm phosphate your N : P ratio is roughly 15:1 which is very close to the Redfield ratio (which is a good thing!). You want to maintain around 16:1 ratio of molecular N : P for a healthy holobiont.
 
Sorry, leeching probably wasn’t the right word. Algae, bacteria, uneaten food, and other organic matter settles in the porous live rock and decomposes to release phosphate over time.

With 2ppm nitrate and 0.2ppm phosphate your N : P ratio is roughly 15:1 which is very close to the Redfield ratio (which is a good thing!). You want to maintain around 16:1 ratio of molecular N : P for a healthy holobiont.
ah ok but until a few days ago i didnt have any algea. But now everything is fine so im happy;) My po4 is 0.04 but yes the target is to get higer no3 than po4
 

TOP 10 Trending Threads

WHAT DO YOU ALWAYS RUN OUT OF AT THE WORST TIME?

  • Salt mix

    Votes: 18 18.6%
  • Fish or coral food

    Votes: 5 5.2%
  • Test kits or reagents

    Votes: 10 10.3%
  • Filter media or replacement fleece

    Votes: 5 5.2%
  • RO/DI filters or supplies

    Votes: 15 15.5%
  • Fragging and repair supplies, like glue or epoxy

    Votes: 12 12.4%
  • I keep a backup of everything

    Votes: 25 25.8%
  • Other (Post in the comments)

    Votes: 7 7.2%
Back
Top
Home
Post thread…
Market
What's new