Phoenix Rising 40g/120g build thread (finally)!

IPT

Well-Known Member
View Badges
Joined
Jan 30, 2023
Messages
650
Reaction score
467
Location
Alaska
What state or country do you live in
Alaska
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Okay, the title is a little dramatic 😊. This will be a dual thread in actuality documenting the current build of my 40 breeder and (in retro fashion) documenting the ongoing drama and evolution of my heavily SPS dominant mixed 120gal.

A few pics to set the hook for those of you peeking to see if there will be anything worthwhile here. There will be :).

I’ve been in the hobby literally for decades. Some of you old timer might remember me from Reef Central back in the day (probably mostly in the photography sub forum). I still have a coral (Palythoa grandis) that I first acquired back in the 90's when I had my first reef tank. Some of you might remember the "Bible of salt water" back in the day by, who was it? Oh yeah, Martin Moe! It came out in 1989! Lord, I can’t believe my parents allowed me to do what I did. I moved furniture out of my bedroom to fit fishtanks. I built a trickle filter with a plastic laundry basket, some florescent light grids and a zillion bio-balls! I built a 3 foot tall skimmer with 3ā€ PVC pipe, siliconing some Tupperware containers on top, used a rubber slip fitting and wooden airstones – and it worked like a champ (for the day).

Fast forward to today. I’ve never really been out of the hobby, sans for a few short periods, but I for certain have been more or less involved over the journey. I’ve been ā€œmore involvedā€ over the last 3 years since I got more serious about SPS and had some success. I also have big eyes, apparently bigger than my tank based on the number of frags I have acquired (way too many for my tank!). I also have had some battles over the years some new, some old with the usual nemeses such as Velonia, and more recently (first time in my reefkeeping carrier) APTASIA ☹ and one I never really even heard of (again until recently) White bugs.

So, this ride will be interesting for sure and I will mingle a retro look at the evolution/build of my 120 (which came essentially from a 75 I had) that will take us way back and (maybe?) be mostly chronological in getting us to ā€œtodayā€. Simultaneously I’ll white board and hopefully take ya’ll through the build of the 40 breeder.

My intention for the 40 Breeder and in part the reason for the thread build name is I want to rise from the accumulation of errors I made with the 120. Errors you ask? Well, maybe not errors, but things I would like to resolve and do better. The bigger ones being: allowing Aptasia and velonia into the system, over stocking on coral and destroying my original Aquascape design cramming too much in. The plan for the 40 will be laying out and keeping a more open scape with lots of negative space, and God willing, transferring only my favorite (say top 20) SPS and maybe a Torch or two without the Velonia or Aptasia getting in. Fingers crossed.

Oh yeah, I forgot to mention, there will probably be gaps between my posts. I have two little humans to raise, a wife, a career, a house, a tank, a tank build and an exercise routine I need to juggle. Be patient, check back when you can, and enjoy the ride.

Some eye candy to start. Bare with me because I am also building a photo editing Desktop and I just realized most of my more recent photos are on that one! I do have a few on hand here...plus a few older ones. Oh, and I am really into photography (at least I used to be when i had time so I will probably sprinkle in some Alaskan photos along the way).

_25A5012.jpg _25A5497.jpg _25A5560.jpg
 
A beginning render of the simple stand I'll be building for the 40 breeder.... Since we do have Earthquakes here it might be considered by some to be "overbuilt". I won't use 2x6's like I did on the 120 stand, but after out last "big one" I am glad I used 2x6's on that stand!


40 Breeder stand CAD.jpg
 
Can't wait to see more of this!
 
Okay, the title is a little dramatic 😊. This will be a dual thread in actuality documenting the current build of my 40 breeder and (in retro fashion) documenting the ongoing drama and evolution of my heavily SPS dominant mixed 120gal.

A few pics to set the hook for those of you peeking to see if there will be anything worthwhile here. There will be :).

I’ve been in the hobby literally for decades. Some of you old timer might remember me from Reef Central back in the day (probably mostly in the photography sub forum). I still have a coral (Palythoa grandis) that I first acquired back in the 90's when I had my first reef tank. Some of you might remember the "Bible of salt water" back in the day by, who was it? Oh yeah, Martin Moe! It came out in 1989! Lord, I can’t believe my parents allowed me to do what I did. I moved furniture out of my bedroom to fit fishtanks. I built a trickle filter with a plastic laundry basket, some florescent light grids and a zillion bio-balls! I built a 3 foot tall skimmer with 3ā€ PVC pipe, siliconing some Tupperware containers on top, used a rubber slip fitting and wooden airstones – and it worked like a champ (for the day).

Fast forward to today. I’ve never really been out of the hobby, sans for a few short periods, but I for certain have been more or less involved over the journey. I’ve been ā€œmore involvedā€ over the last 3 years since I got more serious about SPS and had some success. I also have big eyes, apparently bigger than my tank based on the number of frags I have acquired (way too many for my tank!). I also have had some battles over the years some new, some old with the usual nemeses such as Velonia, and more recently (first time in my reefkeeping carrier) APTASIA ☹ and one I never really even heard of (again until recently) White bugs.

So, this ride will be interesting for sure and I will mingle a retro look at the evolution/build of my 120 (which came essentially from a 75 I had) that will take us way back and (maybe?) be mostly chronological in getting us to ā€œtodayā€. Simultaneously I’ll white board and hopefully take ya’ll through the build of the 40 breeder.

My intention for the 40 Breeder and in part the reason for the thread build name is I want to rise from the accumulation of errors I made with the 120. Errors you ask? Well, maybe not errors, but things I would like to resolve and do better. The bigger ones being: allowing Aptasia and velonia into the system, over stocking on coral and destroying my original Aquascape design cramming too much in. The plan for the 40 will be laying out and keeping a more open scape with lots of negative space, and God willing, transferring only my favorite (say top 20) SPS and maybe a Torch or two without the Velonia or Aptasia getting in. Fingers crossed.

Oh yeah, I forgot to mention, there will probably be gaps between my posts. I have two little humans to raise, a wife, a career, a house, a tank, a tank build and an exercise routine I need to juggle. Be patient, check back when you can, and enjoy the ride.

Some eye candy to start. Bare with me because I am also building a photo editing Desktop and I just realized most of my more recent photos are on that one! I do have a few on hand here...plus a few older ones. Oh, and I am really into photography (at least I used to be when i had time so I will probably sprinkle in some Alaskan photos along the way).

_25A5012.jpg _25A5497.jpg _25A5560.jpg
Gorgeous pictures, thanks for sharing!
 
Modeling of the 40 breeder (done in Fusion 360). The plan is one of simplicity. I know it'll take a good while to get stable for SPS. This is not a show piece tank. Well, I hope the tank will be once it's aquascaped and grown in, but the build is about utility. Simple 2x4 construction. Nop doors, no fancy finishes. Notice the top spans are fully resting on top of the vertical 2x4. No screws, nails or dowels taking the sheer force, just lumbar. I'll add a few metal braces and a backer board (probably about 8"s tall) to help resist any racking forces that may occur (ie, during an Earthquake). I may throw a few triangles glued and screwed in the corners too...depending on how paranoid I feel :).

There will be room for (3) 15 high tanks underneath. The plan is to start (and maybe stay?) sumpless. I've never done a tank without a sump so this will be uncharted territory. One tank will be for freshwater top-off, one for Kalk, and the other if I decide too could be a sump. I'll also build in a little open "box" one one side or the other for the electrical. I like to keep it boxed in just in case a hose or plumbing fitting breaks free in an effort to prevent water and electricity mixing. Still tweaking the model, but here is where it is at the moment. No skimmer to start. I purposely choose a low volume system in hopes I can keep up with it via a low fish load and just regular water changes. Time will tell how that will pan out.

Tank model.jpg
 
Maybe the color on this one is better? The other one looked a little too blue and flat.

IMG_6472.jpg
 
Lets take it back to the 90's :). A few from "back in the day". What young guy wouldn't want a small school of Red Belly Piranha :)? I wonder if you can even get these dudes anymore? I knew of people who would essentially starve them and then throw in a rat or something. That wasn't my style. These guys got regular feedings of raw chicken breast.

IMG_7241.jpg


Here was my Reeftank, yup, back in 1997! From the looks of it I had some fair success. That clam got pretty dang large! It was a Derasa, so hardy, but still. Coming from these days I am blown away by and still struggle with the expense of stuff today! I built a wooden hood, went to Home Depot and bought 4 fluorescent light fixtures for about $10 a piece. I stripped the ballasts, wiring and none waterproof end caps and mounted them and they were good to go for many years. I had an 8 bulb (or maybe it was 6) T5 fixture over my tank for about $50 and a few hours of labor!

IMG_7243.jpg IMG_7247.jpg IMG_7248.jpg

You can see some Palythoas on the right of the second image. I still have these in my tank today! That blows my mind. So sentimental. I remember "dry shipping" them from NY to AK in a small cooler with some wet paper towels and some wet bubble and that was it!

Here is a small colony of them. I've traded many of these over the years. These have survived multiple tank crashes. I can real them being closed for weeks, maybe even months, and then suddenly they were back. Crazy.

_25A7755.jpg


It almost looks like a Venus Fly Trap! In essence I guess they do have some similarities.

_S3A0991.jpg


These is something very rewarding about this hobby when you get things dialed in. maybe it's similar to what a gardener or Bonsai tree feels. To keep living creatures, and bring out the best of them in a aesthetic was is just so cool. I love just looking at the tank today and watching things grow and color up :).

A fairly recent image of a blue table coral I have for you stickheads.

_S3A0619.jpg
 
Last edited:
Speaking of Deresa clams...This image, one of my Favs, won me an Avast Porthole in a Reef2Reef photo contest! I was pretty stoked about that (but I actually forgot I even submitted it and didn't remember until a few months later - Thanks to Maroon C for still getting me the prize).

This image was taken in my old 50 Gallon before I moved up to a 75. The clam got so big (I think about 9 inches or more at the shell) I couldn't keep up with the Alk demands. It had to go partially up on edge in a 5 gal bucket when i traded it in because it wouldn't fit in the bottom. The guy was shocked, and thought I was egagerating about how big it was :). I don't recall if I was using A and B at the time or just Kalk. In hindsight, I was precipitating a ton of what I was dosing. I now have a much slower flow rate dosing pump and make sure it drains right into the highest flow area of the tank (the sump when my main overflow drains). I don't have any precipitation or build up at all anywhere. It used to coat my heaters and sump floor and walls. Live and learn, live and learn, but in part this is the idea of this thread to share (and maybe gain) knowledge with you all.

neon gobbie2.jpg
 
Last edited:
Man, life....been crazy busy and headed out of town for 5 days of camping and photography! Been wayching some You Tbe stuff and might re-design the Stand. Just to make it more editable as well as to better learn the program for future projects. Fusion 360 is sick, but there is a learning curve for sure.

Regarding my tanks....in the 120 the Alk consumption is going up :). i had to raise my part A and B 10 ml daily. My Berghia are getting big! hey are at least 3/4 of an inch now. Lots of egg spirals, but I have not seen any babies and a lot fo the eggs are gone. Strange. I have one spiral laiud on a heater suction cup no isolated so we'll see how that goes. i am really getting sick of the Aptasia in my tank. i wanted to add some Wrasse, but now I am second thinking it. They might stop the Berghia reproduction in it's tracks. If I can get the 40 to remains Aptasi free (as I plan too) then a Wrasse or two for sure.

A few more coral shots to hold the two people following the thread over :).

_25A1382.jpg _25A0093.jpg _25A7740-2.jpg _S3A1079.jpg _S3A6094.jpg _S3A6484.jpg
 
A super old image I took snorkeling in Fiji (modified so only the Chromis have color). Really dig this. Taken with a Canon S-90 with an underwater case and some off camera strobes.

One of the other reasons there hasn't been much progress is because I am working on a mounting system for better Tank photography. I already use a top-down tube, but need more stability. Trip doesn't really work, so in comes some metal bending, drilling a tapping, and some T Track. Time will tell how it works :). See you'll on the lip side. If all goes well I should have some cool Eagle Images to share.

Fiji B&W.jpg
 
Phew, getting lonely in here. Though it's not like I've been here a lot. man, life, always something to do!

Anyway, I made some progress on the build. Got a preliminary cut list made up.

IMG_7498.jpg


The cool think about fusion is it will modify it all even if I change one thing by 1/4 of an inch. Since I used it to rough it out I entered generic 2x dimensions. However, I know that will be modified. I am not a pro at building, far from it. However, I have fought through enough out of square builds in my day to have learned a few things. Still, I am all ears to anyone else's suggestions.

First off, 2x4's are NOT square, nor straight. I spent quite a while the other day getting the wood ready. By ready I man planed down and squared off. The stock stuff has not flat (despite my picking the best of what was there).

Look at the humps in this...
IMG_7522.jpg

Ah, much better...

IMG_7515.jpg



On the right, some cleaned up pieces. On the left, a stock piece on top of a cleaned up piece.

IMG_7537.jpg


Look at the gaps and rounded edges on the left pieces. The actual contact points seem to be just about 50% of the surface.

This lends itself to weak joints. It also (especially with the waves from the picture above that) makes building anything square a nightmare! I've built stuff before and been blown away at how off it ended up being as this stuff compounds itself. I'm sure I'll still be a little off, because I am not a pro by any imagination, but hopefully I won't be toooo far off :). Time will tell.

More posts tomorrow (I hope) on how I improved the quality of what I had plus more on the actual construction plan. I think I am going to use dowels on this one vs the pocket screws I used on previous builds. Either works, but I am trying to have some fun and like to learn new techniques so what the heck :). Plus I impulse bought a Dowel jig for something else I built and I don't even recall if I used it :0.

Also, I do live in Earthquake zones and there is this....

Dowel vs screws.jpeg


Since this is only a 40 I'll be using 2x4's. I used a lot of 2x6's on my 120 and don't regret it a minute. Especially after that 8.2 earthquake we had 2021. All sorts of stuff was rocking and rolling! Water sprayed a good 3 feet from my tank and the tank slid 1/2 inch on the stand. Luckily, it all held together, phew.

Well, Buenos Noches my elusive audience :). Can't say I blame you, I have been lack luster on frequency of my posting. I was hoping the eye candy might attract a few stragglers who were just passing by.
 
Last edited:
Sweet, at the computer at a reasonable hour! Okay, so how did I fix this crappy wood. Well I have a planer first off. That helps take any bowing or cupping out of the flat faces of the wood. So if I have a 2x4 on edge and want to butt another 2x4 vertically against it, I know it will be flush and there won't be any gaps. That still leaves to rounded edges on the short side (the 1.5" wide part), and the bowing or unevenness you may see on the length of the board. If you lay the board down on a flat surface there may be an arc, rise, or gap (like a really flat rainbow). Not good when your trying to make a square box!

The bowing on the narrow 1.5" edge seen in the pic with the comparison of the two joints is simply resolved by using a saw to cut the 1/8th of an inch (or more if needed) edge off each side of the board. This takes it back to the meat of the board and cuts off any roundness.

For the gaps seen on the length, that was another issue. I think there is an (expensive) tool called a jointer that does this. I don't have one of these. What it does though is creates a known straight and flat edge along the length of one side of the board. Then, if you put it through a table saw, that known flat edge runs along the flat fence and you get a flat edge on the other side. the key is you need a known flat edge.

If you just try and run it through the table saw using the flat fence, if the bow is bad enough, and the length long enough, then the bow sort of just "curves" or "wraps" around the saws flat fence in essence causing the same (or maybe slightly less so) curve to be mirrored on the outer edge you just cut. So in essence, you don't get a "true" edge. If the length is short, it probably doesn't matter that much because it can't "wrap" around the fence. The soultion is easy enough to do no matter what the length though so I just do it (like Nike says :).

A trick I saw and used for this was to put the wood against a true straight edge, then run that along your fence with the wood next too it simultaneously (see image). I used a 4 foot level. That way no matter the length, the flat edge of the level slides along the fence and the outer edge of the wood being cut will be true and flat. You might still have a bow on the inner edge though. However, with the true edge now on the outside, when you flip it around and slide the "true" flat edge along the saw fence it will create another "true" edge, thus removing any bowing along the length the board.

It's important to note that the level and the wood must move together. If you just slide the wood along the level, its the same as using the fence. By moving the wood and level at the same time you are in essence starting with a known "true" flat edge to create one on the opposite side. Then you can use the newly created "true" edge on the inside to create the other "true" edge and have a straight board in that plane.

IMG_7516.jpg
 
Last edited:
Speaking of "true" edges. Always check your tools! I cut a board and it just looked beveled to me even though the miter of the table saw was set to 0 degrees. Turns out something got bumped. I used a square and raised the blade as high as it could go and re-set it to a true 90 degrees.

IMG_7520.jpg


Seems rather insignificant until you do the math. Check this out....

A 1-degree miter error will make you exactly 0.84 inches (about 13/16 of an inch) off at a distance of 4 feet.

Quick Reference Metrics
  • At 1 foot away: You will be off by 0.21 inches (just over 3/16").
  • At 4 feet away: You will be off by 0.84 inches (about 13/16").
  • At 8 feet away: You will be off by 1.68 inches (about 1 11/16"). [1]

Why This Happens
This gap expands linearly because of trigonometry. For every single foot your board extends from a 1-degree inaccurate cut, the end of the board drifts sideways by roughly 0.21 inches. If you are joining two pieces together to form a corner, this error doubles if both boards are cut incorrectly.

I wish I understood this stuff years ago. i could have saved myself a lot of frustration and headaches!
 
Aquascape. I want way more negative space this time. I started out the 120 with that concept in mind.

IMG_8912.jpg IMG_9021.jpg

Then what happened was the SPS bit hard! I kept seeing corals I liked and just "need to have". So, I bought them, and of course I added rock to fit them in. I kept doing this and doing this until the open feeling was long gone. It' so out of control now I have frag racks in the front of the tank with about 10+ frags with no home :(.

I can find places for most of them once I removed a huge Staghorn I have that is taking up a lot of space and shading a lot of stuff. I also have two colonies of Bubble Gum Digi so one of them is going for sure The plan for the 40 Gallon is to keep it open. I'll have an arch of sorts on the left 2/3 of the tank with projections here and there for SPS. The right 1/3 of the tank will probably be for some Torches.

I think I mentioned it early on but one of the main goals here is to start this tank, and keep it free of Velonia and Aptasia. The Velonia is pretty well maintained now inn the 120 but it's still a pain and requires some work on my part to keep it in check. The aptasia is getting out of control. I do have 4 Berghia right now I am trying to breed some hopefully in the next month or so I can release a little army of them and get them in check. I dream of a tank without either pest because it annoys me to use time managing them. For decades I never had it until I let my guard down a few times. This time NOTHING will go into the 40 without being inspected and freshly fragged with live tissue only. Still no guarantees I won't pass some on, but I think the probability is in my favor.

Some Torches...

IMG_4006-2.jpg


Bubble gum...

_S3A0174.jpg


Random tricolor image because I think it's cool....

_S3A6264.jpg
 
Last edited:

TOP 10 Trending Threads

HOW WOULD YOU FEEL ABOUT RECEIVING A FISH OR CORAL AS A HOLIDAY GIFT?

  • I’d love one, as long as it’s a species I chose

    Votes: 19 29.2%
  • I’d trust someone who knows my tank to choose

    Votes: 2 3.1%
  • I’d rather get a gift card and pick it myself

    Votes: 24 36.9%
  • I’d prefer gear or supplies instead

    Votes: 1 1.5%
  • Please don’t surprise me with livestock

    Votes: 19 29.2%
  • Other (Post in the comments)

    Votes: 0 0.0%
Back
Top
Home
Post thread…
Market
What's new