Return pump recommendation

[Debacle]

Display is on the first level and sump in basement. Display is a 150g tall. Approximate head height is 16'. Got it narrowed down to two pumps. The Sicce SDC 9.0 or the panworld 200 ps. Both pumps will be ran externally. According to documentation both pumps will push what I need, but the Sicce will do it at approximately 200 watts less. Any reason I should go with 1 over the other?

 

[Crabs McJones]

Display is on the first level and sump in basement. Display is a 150g tall. Approximate head height is 16'. Got it narrowed down to two pumps. The Sicce SDC 9.0 or the panworld 200 ps. Both pumps will be ran externally. According to documentation both pumps will push what I need, but the Sicce will do it at approximately 200 watts less. Any reason I should go with 1 over the other?

I use a sicce on my tank now and love it. Dead silent, no issues. Never heard of the Panworld.

 

[tdileo]

I also have a Sicce pump and I love mine. Have used them on both of my tanks since I got into the hobby and never had any problems.

 

[Debacle]

Do you guys run your Sicce external?

 

[gcarroll]

Panworld! Head pressure it what they are designed to handle.