Sinularia in mixed reef

[LunaSky]

I'm second guessing my purchase of a neon green Sinularia. I do run carbon in my tank, but I have a mixed reef with mostly LPS and few SPS. The Sinularia would be my first soft coral in this tank. But after doing some reading, some sites say yes, others day no. Should I put this Sinularia in my tank or should I find it a new home?

 

[Mr. Mojo Rising]

Why would it be a no? I don’t get what the concern is. I love sinularia, it’s my favourite leather coral.

 

[petcellar]

I dont have sps, but I really like sinulara and is hasnt caused any issues that I could tell in my mainly lps tank.

 

[LunaSky]

Why would it be a no? I don’t get what the concern is. I love sinularia, it’s my favourite leather coral.

Because I've read it can release toxins to neighboring corals.

 

[kevgib67]

I’ve had one in my mixed tank for 4 1/2 years without a single problem.

 

[Ocellaris123]

You will be fine, ive had this coral in every reef i have had, they just grow quick but can be controlled via fragging

 

[LunaSky]

Okay. Thank you everyone. He is getting settled into my tank. I still have him some room just in case.