Stalled cycle

ReefGaz

New Member
View Badges
Joined
Oct 18, 2026
Messages
11
Reaction score
15
What state or country do you live in
United Kingdom
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
My tank has been set up just over a month now. I started with dry rock and Caribsea Arag alive sand. I ran the Red Sea reef mature starter kit. All the parameters were going well until a couple of weeks in when my nitrites went sky high and stalled there for over a week. Ammonia was showing 0ppm. I done a 50% water change which dropped the nitrites, but a week later and they have crept back up to over 5ppm again. I’ve not dosed any Ammonia in the meantime so am wondering how the nitrites have risen so high again? Should I do another water change or just leave it alone for now and see if they drop on their own. I was under the impression that nitrites over 5ppm would stall the cycle. Any help much appreciated
 
I wouldn't do any more water changes until you get a nitrate reading. I would a bit more ammonia then see if you get a zero reading on ammonia. Nitrite doesn't harm saltwater tanks but your looking for a good nitrate reading then I would say it has cycled . Nitrite has to rise and fall to cycle. One month might not be long enough for your tank to cycle. Some cycle very quickly and some are slower. Every time you do a water change you are just diluting the problem don't do any water changes until you get a good nitrate reading. You could put some live rock in will help speed things up .
 
Don't worry about it. The nitrite oxidizing bacteria (NOB) take far longer than the ammonia oxidizing bacteria (AOB) to properly establish. This has been observed many times and you will find a large number of threads with people reporting the same issue.

It took my dry rock-started tank months to get fully rid of nitrites, but in contrast to freshwater tanks nitrite doesn't really matter in reef tanks. Just ignore it 😊

As long as ammonia is oxidized fast the tank is doing fine and you can consider it "cycled", even though not the full nitrogen cycle has been completed. Don't trust your nitrate tests in the mean time, they will show elevated levels while nitrite is present.

There is no evidence in the literature that AOB or NOB are negatively impacted by low levels of nitrite. I just recently double checked and according to Anthonisen et al. 1976 & Vadivelu et al. 2006 you would probably need multiple hundreds of ppm to actually inhibit those bacteria. Arguably people with high nitrite keep measuring it and notice it doesn't go down as expected, so they report that their cycle stalls at x ppm nitrite. People repeat it, and suddenly high nitrite stalls the cycle even though there is no real evidence for it.

The only limiting options I see would be carbon, phosphate, and maybe trace elements like iron, copper, and I believe molybdenum that are being used for enzymes to work with nitrite and ammonia.
 
Nitrite and Nitrate levels don't matter. The only thing that does is ammonia processing. Don't waste any more money doing water changes to chase nitrite or nitrate numbers.

If you dose 1 to 2 ppm of ammonia and it heads toward zero in 24 hours, your ready for a fish.
 
I wouldn't do any more water changes until you get a nitrate reading. I would a bit more ammonia then see if you get a zero reading on ammonia. Nitrite doesn't harm saltwater tanks but your looking for a good nitrate reading then I would say it has cycled . Nitrite has to rise and fall to cycle. One month might not be long enough for your tank to cycle. Some cycle very quickly and some are slower. Every time you do a water change you are just diluting the problem don't do any water changes until you get a good nitrate reading. You could put some live rock in will help speed things up .
Thanks. Nitrate has been rising slowly but I was just unsure as to why the nitrate hasn’t been dropping. I’ve found a lfs that sells live rock so I’m going to try some of that and see if it speeds things along
 
Thanks. Nitrate has been rising slowly but I was just unsure as to why the nitrate hasn’t been dropping. I’ve found a lfs that sells live rock so I’m going to try some of that and see if it speeds things along
There nothing to speed along. The nitrogen cycle will just chug along, adapting as it goes.

The hunk of live rock won't hurt and may offer benefits, but the tank is ready for a fish as long as it is processing ammonia reliably. You don't need to keep testing nitrate and there is never a reason to test nitrite.
 
Thanks. Nitrate has been rising slowly but I was just unsure as to why the nitrate hasn’t been dropping. I’ve found a lfs that sells live rock so I’m going to try some of that and see if it speeds things along
There's nothing to speed along, you're cycled 🙂
 
Nitrite and Nitrate levels don't matter. The only thing that does is ammonia processing. Don't waste any more money doing water changes to chase nitrite or nitrate numbers.

If you dose 1 to 2 ppm of ammonia and it heads toward zero in 24 hours, your ready for a fish.
Ok thanks. I was under the impression that high levels of nitrite were toxic to fish also or is this not the case?
 
Don't worry about it. The nitrite oxidizing bacteria (NOB) take far longer than the ammonia oxidizing bacteria (AOB) to properly establish. This has been observed many times and you will find a large number of threads with people reporting the same issue.

It took my dry rock-started tank months to get fully rid of nitrites, but in contrast to freshwater tanks nitrite doesn't really matter in reef tanks. Just ignore it 😊

As long as ammonia is oxidized fast the tank is doing fine and you can consider it "cycled", even though not the full nitrogen cycle has been completed. Don't trust your nitrate tests in the mean time, they will show elevated levels while nitrite is present.

There is no evidence in the literature that AOB or NOB are negatively impacted by low levels of nitrite. I just recently double checked and according to Anthonisen et al. 1976 & Vadivelu et al. 2006 you would probably need multiple hundreds of ppm to actually inhibit those bacteria. Arguably people with high nitrite keep measuring it and notice it doesn't go down as expected, so they report that their cycle stalls at x ppm nitrite. People repeat it, and suddenly high nitrite stalls the cycle even though there is no real evidence for it.

The only limiting options I see would be carbon, phosphate, and maybe trace elements like iron, copper, and I believe molybdenum that are being used for enzymes to work with nitrite and ammonia.
 
I quit testing ammonia and nitrite years ago when cycling. When I see the presence of nitrate I slowly move forward. I've never had a stalled cycle and don't really believe cycles stall. I've never lost a fish when added to a newly cycled tank.
Maybe I'm way off base but my thinking is if I'm seeing nitrate then ammonia is being processed so I proceeded slowly. I realize nitrite can skew nitrate test results but I think having 0 ammonia and a nitrate reading is good enough to proceed but like I said I could be way off base and it's not a recommendation but is something that works for me. It sure makes cycling much less complicated 🙃
 
I quit testing ammonia and nitrite years ago when cycling. When I see the presence of nitrate I slowly move forward. I've never had a stalled cycle and don't really believe cycles stall. I've never lost a fish when added to a newly cycled tank.
Maybe I'm way off base but my thinking is if I'm seeing nitrate then ammonia is being processed so I proceeded slowly. I realize nitrite can skew nitrate test results but I think having 0 ammonia and a nitrate reading is good enough to proceed but like I said I could be way off base and it's not a recommendation but is something that works for me. It sure makes cycling much less complicated 🙃
That sure makes sense. I’ve got 0 ammonia and the nitrate is rising so the cycle is definitely working as it should. It’s just thrown me of with the nitrite being so high for so long but it’s probably just me overthinking it
 
That sure makes sense. I’ve got 0 ammonia and the nitrate is rising so the cycle is definitely working as it should. It’s just thrown me of with the nitrite being so high for so long but it’s probably just me overthinking it
I think most do at first. Better safe than sorry.
 
That sure makes sense. I’ve got 0 ammonia and the nitrate is rising so the cycle is definitely working as it should. It’s just thrown me of with the nitrite being so high for so long but it’s probably just me overthinking it
The nitrogen cycle is complex, but in basic terms "cycle" in this context refers to a specific set of bacteria, where one's output is the input for another.

Ammonia --> Bacteria --> Nitrite --> Bacteria --> Nitrate --> Bacteria --> Nitrogen gas

That last step is a bit different in our captive systems, but the basic idea is the same.

Each group of bacteria is different and needs food to become established and grow. So over the first days and weeks, the different groups of bacteria grow at different rates as their food becomes available and/or with competition from other bacteria that aren't directly part of this chain (or cycle).

What we are worried about is the ammonia, because it is the form that is toxic in a marine tank. Testing for nitrite or nitrate can help to tell us that things are happening, but the only one that really matters during cycling is ammonia and nitrite testing is prone to errors if nitrate exists. So the safe bet is to just test ammonia, its behavior tells you what you need to know. It is either being processed in reasonable time, or it isn't. If it isn't then we may go start looking at other things.
 

TOP 10 Trending Threads

HOW DO YOU HANDLE HOLIDAY DECORATING AROUND YOUR REEF?

  • I decorate the tank or stand

    Votes: 1 14.3%
  • I decorate AROUND the tank or stand

    Votes: 1 14.3%
  • I add one small seasonal touch but keep it very basic

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • I take a holiday photo, but don’t decorate the space

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • I leave the reef area as it is

    Votes: 5 71.4%
  • We don’t decorate for the holidays

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Other (Post in the comments)

    Votes: 0 0.0%
Back
Top
Home
Post thread…
Market
What's new