OP needs to take a SG reading - I'm betting that's low also
I did, nothing changed there.
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
OP needs to take a SG reading - I'm betting that's low also
That is only true if nitrate is accumulating. Nitrification consumes alkalinity
If nitrate is steady, there is zero effect on alkalinity because the consumption of nitrate by organisms returns exactly the alkalintiy lost in nitrification.
If nitrate is declining, then alkalinity will actually rise by that process.
I see a pH drop when I pull cheato, but I normally remove a lot more than half. I suspect it could be the issue. Might be a perfect storm with pulling the chaeto and the skimmer going off line. Less chaeto to turn CO2 into O2 and less air exchange with the skimmer not running. Seems plausible.Holy cow, YES! I took out half of Cheto this morning! Is that it? I have done that many times before!!
You guys know much more about this than I do, but I was under the impression this was a process that took days, not hours. Can you help clarify that? I'm always up for expanding my knowledge.I think I see what you mean, but bear in mind that denitrification could also be responsible for stability in nitrate. Many of us have active denitrification in our systems due to anoxic zones and bioavailable carbon/sulfur. Zooxanthellae also consume some. My tank never deviates from 0-5 ppm nitrate, even with water changes every 2 months. Back when I worked at a large fish farm, we ran denitrifiers 24/7 to keep it below 200 ppm.
And to mass-balance, denitrification restores 50% of the carbonate lost through nitrification. So you would still have a net loss over time. I once argued for a point on a fish pathology class test in grad school because I claimed that denitrification is a source of alkalinity. They gave me the point, but made sure to mention the mass balance. An alkalinity test report might put this issue to bed though!
You guys know much more about this than I do, but I was under the impression this was a process that took days, not hours. Can you help clarify that? I'm always up for expanding my knowledge.
I should have been more clear. The pH was going down 0.05 per day, and I didn't think biomass could have that much of an impact. But, I say that will little confidence. I thought with biomass uptake you wouldn't see a measurable difference for a week or more.Your are 100% correct I think. Check that graph again. I think it's a week span unless I misread or something. Those daily swings were the indicator for me. Just a misunderstanding!
I should have been more clear. The pH was going down 0.05 per day, and I didn't think biomass could have that much of an impact. But, I say that will little confidence. I thought with biomass uptake you wouldn't see a measurable difference for a week or more.
I don't have a source, which is why I lack confidence in that statement. It is only a perception that I have, but can't claim it is an accurate perception. I am honestly just trying to learn more, not trying to challenge.A fair point. That may be but I'm not familiar with those limitations. Do you have a source? I dealt with massive biomass so 0.05 in a day was nothing. As a reef hobbyist, I lose 0.5 dkH per day in 90 gallons. However, in my aquaculture experience it was freshwater and nitrifying bacteria were basically r-selected.
I don't have a source, which is why I lack confidence in that statement. It is only a perception that I have, but can't claim it is an accurate perception. I am honestly just trying to learn more, not trying to challenge.
I drop over 4dkh per day in my 187g system but I have no way to quantify how much is coral and biomass. I find this very interesting, but challenging to expand my knowledge.
Where can I get a ph monitor like yours? Unless it’s like 300 or somethingDid you have a lot of family over close windows, due to cooler temperatures. The CO2 could have spiked in your house. BTW it can take days to go back to normal CO2. This is what I did, for the high CO2, the Air goes into my Skimmer. This is very crude, and I plan on using a bigger air pump. Also put a bleed off valve, to keep from Spiking the pH at first