Why not keep a mandarinfish in a nano tank?

  • Thread starter Thread starter afboundguy
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users Tagged users None

afboundguy

acanaholic
View Badges
Joined
Jun 12, 2009
Messages
1,374
Reaction score
876
Location
MA
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
We have all heard the famous words that you shouldn’t keep a mandarinfish in a tank smaller than 75 gallons. Well that’s the advice I was given back in my early reefing years anyways! Modern research suggests you can keep one in a tank as small as 50 gallons. My recent Biota mandarinfish has a suggested minimum tank size of 30 gallons. With what seems like the declining gallonage required to keep a mandarinfish should you really keep one in a nano tank?

I would say yes with an asterisk. In my old 25 gallon cube tank I was successfully keeping a wild caught mandarinfish but it required a lot of work! Besides the 25 gallons I had a HOB refugium with chaetomorpha and some live rock rubble so that copepods could have a safe haven to multiply. I also started multiple white worm cultures, 2 strands of phytoplankton cultures, copepod cultures and started hatching fresh baby brine shrimp (BBS) and made a Paul B mandarinfish feeder.
1738692769972.png
1738692779708.png
1738692793869.png
1738692802500.png


I watched my little wild caught mandarinfish get fat and chubby. I watched her devour the fresh BBS I would pour in 1-2 times a day. She would gobble up the white worms I would feed 1-2 times a day sometimes to the point she would have some sticking out of her mouth as she couldn’t get enough of them! It was a ton of work but well worth it as everybody told me it wouldn’t work!

And then the inevitable happened. I had a tank crash and I lost just about everything in the tank. I went from this -
1738692828586.png


To this -

1738692840541.png

Believe it or not that picture wasn't nearly as bad as it looked post tank crash!

Needless to say I was heartbroken and I ignored the tank for months. Only a few softies and my 10+ year old mated clownfish and a huge bobbit worm (found when I upgraded my tank) remained! I was saddest because despite all my hard work cultivating live food and overfeeding the tank to have a happy and fat mandarinfish I lost her due to the crash. I ignored the cultures and they all died as well. I let the tank go by the wayside and cleaned the tank what felt like every 4-6 months after the wife would tell me how ugly it was. I still topped off the water to keep it “stable” and I had a nice little tank full of algae and other guck.

Fast forward a few years and I finally decided to upgrade my tank to a 35 cube with a sump this time! Wife didn’t want the tank on the main floor so I put it in the basement to go along with my ever growing HO scale model railroad layout! Talk about a man, I mean dork cave! I was in heaven! I remembered the glory days of having a mandarinfish in “too small” of a tank and I figured if I could do it in a 25 cube with a HOB refugium I should easily be able to do it with a 35 gallon tank with a 10 gallon sump and the same handy HOB refugium!

I decided to play it safe and purchase a captive bred mandarinfish from Biota this time. I read that they eat frozen and pellet food and are much hardier. I initially was cocky, I mean I did keep a wild caught one in my old set up so this much more “advanced” setup would be a piece of cake right? So I got a male and female pair. Unfortunately, the female disappeared after 3 days and no matter how much I ripped apart the sump I couldn’t find her. The male on the other hand has been flourishing! Besides the fact that he eats frozen food and pellet food like a pig, he still enjoys the occasional white worm culture that I have been struggling with getting back to the old culture’s status that multiplied like rabbits.

I have gone back to the getting heavy into the live foods as well. Currently I have 3 strands of copepods and looking to add a 4th. I have two one-gallon jars of each strands. I have 6 active phytoplankton strands (two half gallon cultures of each strand) and I have been trying to get a 7th strand of rhodomonas to add a red strand but I have not been able keep one alive! I am giving it one more try in the next couple of weeks! With doing more phytoplankton strands my copepod cultures are doing amazing allowing me to seed the sump at least once a week. I am back doing BBS and currently have 2 dish hatcheries offset so I have a constant stream of freshly hatched BBS that the mandarinfish loves to pick at! (don't mind the messy basement!!!)

1738693093895.png


If you pay attention to my build thread I am in the process of designing and 3D printing a custom DIY pellet feeding system with an automatic pellet feeder. I have 1/4" black PVC with 3D printed parts so that the pellet food falls to the sandbed and isn’t gobbled up by my old clownfish pair and new mated pair of Orchid and Indigo dottyback fish!

I am also planning to make my own dosing pump setups to build a frozen food feeder and even automate and dose my copepod cultures and then top them off with phytoplankton! Once I hash out the DIY pellet feeder setup, build the frozen fish feeder and dose the copepod cultures I plan to try and get my male mandarinfish a new girlfriend! Currently I have the 35-gallon cube with a sapphire 34 sump and a remote display refugium for a total of about 70-75 gallons with lots of safe haven for copepods to multiply even faster to keep them well fed!

So if you’ve ever wanted a mandarinfish for your nano tank realize it is possible, as I am proof that it can happen if you are willing to put in the hard work! I find all the extra work very rewarding and it gives me a great sense of pride knowing all my hard work not only keeps my little guy fat and happy but also has the great added benefit of extra biodiversity in my tank and the corals love it as well!
 

Attachments

  • 1738692769972.png
    1738692769972.png
    569.4 KB · Views: 486
  • 1738692779708.png
    1738692779708.png
    1.5 MB · Views: 485
  • 1738692793869.png
    1738692793869.png
    1.1 MB · Views: 407
  • 1738692802500.png
    1738692802500.png
    1.4 MB · Views: 393
  • 1738692828586.png
    1738692828586.png
    1.9 MB · Views: 383
  • 1738692840541.png
    1738692840541.png
    1.3 MB · Views: 405
  • 1738693093895.png
    1738693093895.png
    1.5 MB · Views: 345
I think the TLDR of this is that with 75G of water volume, success is achievable. With enough talent and work, it can be done in a smaller setup.

For those recommendations though, its usually a "little time spent maintaining the fish" recommendation, as life gets busy. This should really be taken into consideration, as most reefers dont have food growing stations in their basement :)
 
Agree with the above. Technically, most "Rules" in the hobby can be broken with the right amount of work. Your average hobbyist isn't going to be maintaining a separate pod fuge and the necessary cultures to maintain one in less than 75g.
 
I think the TLDR of this is that with 75G of water volume, success is achievable. With enough talent and work, it can be done in a smaller setup.

For those recommendations though, its usually a "little time spent maintaining the fish" recommendation, as life gets busy. This should really be taken into consideration, as most reefers dont have food growing stations in their basement :)
It was definitely more than a little time keeping everything going. It is much easier with the total water volume being much larger with the larger sump and remote display refugium. Much more safe spots for microfauna to multiply!
Agree with the above. Technically, most "Rules" in the hobby can be broken with the right amount of work. Your average hobbyist isn't going to be maintaining a separate pod fuge and the necessary cultures to maintain one in less than 75g.
Agree with this! It is doable but it is a ton of work! If someone wants to tackle such a daunting task they just need to do the proper research and be ready to commit to all the hard work!
 
I have a theory about the common recommendations for keeping mandarins, and I think it’s based on a few factors:

  1. Many reef tanks are just too clean, which makes it hard to provide enough pods and other critters for mandarins to feed on. This usually means you need a much larger aquarium to support their diet.
  2. Mandarins are often placed in tanks with a lot of competition, which further limits available food resources.
  3. Most mandarins (or at least they used to be) were wild-caught and not trained to eat prepared foods.
I only have a couple of personal experiences to go by, but here they are: I kept a mandarin in a 17-gallon tank for over a year. The tank was packed with macroalgae, and I kept it on the "dirtier" side (still presentable but not sterile), which encouraged a big population of pods and critters, perfect for the mandarin. The only other competition for food was a pair of blue-striped pipefish. I also made sure to get a mandarin that was already eating frozen food. He’d been at a local store for over three months in a bare-bottom tank, and since they only fed frozen food, we figured he must’ve been eating something. I fed him a mix of live foods (some I cultured, some I bought) and frozen food.

I ended up giving him to a friend when I moved countries. They have a similar setup to mine, full of macroalgae and not sterile but with almost double the tank volume. He’s been thriving in that tank for over a year now. Most people aren’t running setups like this, so those mandarins probably just starve in more typical conditions.

Here's a picture of him when I had him for a year and right now; he seems pretty healthy!
IMG_1171.jpeg
(In my tank)
ab98f58f-938e-441f-921f-4ca65602dfc0.jpeg

(In my friend's tank)
 
@courtneykeeps excellent points about keeping a "dirty" tank! I over feed the crap out of my tanks on purpose for the reasons you mentioned! I still have visible pods on my DT's glass and I attribute that to keeping my tank "dirty."

It helps that I am mainly keeping LPS, NPS, a clam and other softies with only 1 or 2 SPS. In the past and now not keeping an SPS dominated tank allows me to keep tank dirtier to further help keep a mandarinfish in a smaller nano tank!
 

TOP 10 Trending Threads

WHAT DO YOU ALWAYS RUN OUT OF AT THE WORST TIME?

  • Salt mix

    Votes: 17 18.9%
  • Fish or coral food

    Votes: 5 5.6%
  • Test kits or reagents

    Votes: 9 10.0%
  • Filter media or replacement fleece

    Votes: 5 5.6%
  • RO/DI filters or supplies

    Votes: 14 15.6%
  • Fragging and repair supplies, like glue or epoxy

    Votes: 10 11.1%
  • I keep a backup of everything

    Votes: 23 25.6%
  • Other (Post in the comments)

    Votes: 7 7.8%
Back
Top
Home
Post thread…
Market
What's new