You Can Keep Only ONE Reef Automation... Which One Makes the Cut?

If you had to operate everything else manually, which automated system would you keep?

  • Auto top-off

    Votes: 63 57.8%
  • Automated dosing

    Votes: 7 6.4%
  • Mechanical filtration / roller filter

    Votes: 4 3.7%
  • Automated water testing

    Votes: 3 2.8%
  • Automatic feeding

    Votes: 1 0.9%
  • Lighting schedule

    Votes: 21 19.3%
  • Controller and remote monitoring

    Votes: 4 3.7%
  • Leak detection and emergency shutoff

    Votes: 2 1.8%
  • Automatic water changes

    Votes: 3 2.8%
  • None. I prefer to operate everything manually

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Something else (explain in the comments)

    Votes: 1 0.9%

  • Total voters
    109

Daniel@R2R

Living the Reef Life
View Badges
Joined
Nov 18, 2012
Messages
40,771
Reaction score
68,104
Location
Fontana, California
Rating - 100%
1   0   0
5b043212-ae91-4e77-afb1-98a09cdf12d2-jpeg.2734429

Modern reef tanks can automate almost everything. We can top off evaporated water, control temperature, dose supplements, test parameters, feed fish, change water, detect leaks, and monitor the whole system from another room...or another state.

But what if you could keep only ONE of those conveniences?

Everything else would still be available, but you would have to handle it manually. Which automation would you refuse to give up?

BONUS POINTS: What made your choice indispensable? Has it prevented a disaster, improved your reef, or simply saved you from a chore you never want to perform manually again?


POST EDIT: I agree heater control is probably the single most essential automation we have. So let's say heaters are automated + you can only choose 1 other.
 
Last edited:
Temperature control. I won't be getting up at night to switch on heaters and turn them off in time again without accidentally frying my fish and corals 😅

As this wasn't on the list, I chose remote monitoring and controller. This makes it easy to know when I need to do something to keep my tank running, including letting me know when to refill water.

As my tank is medium/large without too much evaporation I can dump in 5L - 10L (1.3gal - 2.6gal) RO/DI each day once and would be fine so ATO isn't too important to me. In my old tank ATO failed frequently without causing issues because my return pump started spitting air bubbles before salinity increased significantly and I knew I had to check the ATO.
 
Last edited:
ATO is the only answer. Everything else is a luxury in my opinion. Nice to have but not necessary. Stability is the most important factor. If you don’t have that none of that other stuff is gonna help.
 
Heating for sure but I have never used a heater that was not automated to turn off at a certain temperature. So next in line would be lighting schedule.
 
ATO. I could not imagine running my tank without a way to auto top off the water
 
Roller mat 10000000%. That thing made my life a million times easier. No more wife nagging at me watching filter socks in our washing machine lol
 
Temperature control. I won't be getting up at night to switch on heaters and turn them off in time again without accidentally frying my fish and corals 😅

As this wasn't on the list, I chose remote monitoring and controller. This makes it easy to know when I need to do something to keep my tank running, including letting me know when to refill water.

As my tank is medium/large without too much evaporation I can dump in 5L - 10L (1.3gal - 2.6gal) RO/DI each day once and would be fine so ATO isn't too important to me. In my old tank ATO failed frequently without causing issues because my return pump started spitting air bubbles before salinity increased significantly and I knew I had to check the ATO.
I went into this immediately thinking ATO. But this comment immediately changed my mind. Having a heater that automatically turns on and off is utterly essential. Everything else would be a nuisance and cumbersome to manage, but not critical lke a self running heater. This needs to be added to the poll.

Its one of the few peices of technology that existed from when I first started keeping aquariums in the mid 80's. Mind you, back then, they werent fully submersible.



s-l1600.webp
 
ATO for sure. Then lighting, followed by dosing (for my reef, not my FOWLR). Filter roller is awesome but not nearly as critical as salinity and light.
 
I voted controller/remove monitoring, but the reality is if you're really going to make me choose 1, probably heaters.

I won't ever do just one though. ATO, heaters, 7 in-use dosing pumps, auto fish feeder.. All make my life easier.
 
Temperature control. I won't be getting up at night to switch on heaters and turn them off in time again without accidentally frying my fish and corals 😅

As this wasn't on the list, I chose remote monitoring and controller. This makes it easy to know when I need to do something to keep my tank running, including letting me know when to refill water.

As my tank is medium/large without too much evaporation I can dump in 5L - 10L (1.3gal - 2.6gal) RO/DI each day once and would be fine so ATO isn't too important to me. In my old tank ATO failed frequently without causing issues because my return pump started spitting air bubbles before salinity increased significantly and I knew I had to check the ATO.

Heating for sure but I have never used a heater that was not automated to turn off at a certain temperature. So next in line would be lighting schedule.
Haha! Yeah, I thought about temp control when setting up the poll, but I figured that's so essential, we'd expect that it would remain thermostat controlled. I can't imagine anyone choosing any other option if that one was on the list, so we'll say you get heat control + any single one of the ones in the poll. 😎 👍
 
Roller mat 10000000%. That thing made my life a million times easier. No more wife nagging at me watching filter socks in our washing machine lol
I still need to get one of those for my tank! I hate dealing with the socks.
 
Dosing. I’m not with the tanks for at least 18 hours of the day (including sleep), so need something to keep parameters stable. Water can be topped off with an elevated bucket and float valve.
 
Lighting is the only thing on this list that I have never had manual in my 28 years of reefkeeping. Even my VHO fluorescents were on a timer.

ATO and feeders are important for vacation. Other automations are nice, but can lead to complacency or over-reliance.
 
Yeah, as much as some of the other stuff is probably borderline mandatory for me as well, I don't think there's an answer here other than ATO.
 
ATO is the only answer. Everything else is a luxury in my opinion. Nice to have but not necessary. Stability is the most important factor. If you don’t have that none of that other stuff is gonna help.
ATO. I could not imagine running my tank without a way to auto top off the water
ATO for me.
ATO here!
I voted controller/remove monitoring, but the reality is if you're really going to make me choose 1, probably heaters.

I won't ever do just one though. ATO, heaters, 7 in-use dosing pumps, auto fish feeder.. All make my life easier.
ATO for sure. Then lighting, followed by dosing (for my reef, not my FOWLR). Filter roller is awesome but not nearly as critical as salinity and light.
I went into this immediately thinking ATO. But this comment immediately changed my mind. Having a heater that automatically turns on and off is utterly essential. Everything else would be a nuisance and cumbersome to manage, but not critical lke a self running heater. This needs to be added to the poll.

Its one of the few peices of technology that existed from when I first started keeping aquariums in the mid 80's. Mind you, back then, they werent fully submersible.



s-l1600.webp
Yeah, as much as some of the other stuff is probably borderline mandatory for me as well, I don't think there's an answer here other than ATO.
I realize how old I am when I use glass tops for evaporation control instead of ATO, LOL. That was the old school way of handling it and they never fail or 🐌 don't cause them to dump a load of freshwater into the tank.
 
I use glass tops for evaporation control instead of ATO, LOL.
This, as most of these polls are, is situational. I have a solid lid too, plus a canister filter (no sump) and do daily, fractional AWC. Very little water evaporates. My ATO has the easiest job in the world! Hence, I picked lighting. It too is a powerful factor in pursuing that elusive mythical creature "stability."
That said, if you want to go away for any length of time, "all of the above" or "dedicated, knowledgeable, reliable neighbor who owes you big" would be the right answer, but those weren't offered as choices. So, lighting.
 
keep only one? hmm I dunno, I like most of them except auto feeding, that one is fun the rest are chores

if I had to pick probably auto testing since the options are not known to be super reliable currently anyway
 

TOP 10 Trending Threads

HOW WOULD YOU FEEL ABOUT RECEIVING A FISH OR CORAL AS A HOLIDAY GIFT?

  • I’d love one, as long as it’s a species I chose

    Votes: 26 22.8%
  • I’d trust someone who knows my tank to choose

    Votes: 10 8.8%
  • I’d rather get a gift card and pick it myself

    Votes: 45 39.5%
  • I’d prefer gear or supplies instead

    Votes: 3 2.6%
  • Please don’t surprise me with livestock

    Votes: 30 26.3%
  • Other (Post in the comments)

    Votes: 0 0.0%
Back
Top
Home
Post thread…
Market
What's new