Adding sodium hydroxide to balance pH swings

  • Thread starter Thread starter SatBchReef
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users Tagged users None

SatBchReef

New Member
View Badges
Joined
Apr 7, 2024
Messages
4
Reaction score
4
Location
Satellite Beach
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Hoping someone can give me some guidance on the right approach to adding sodium hydroxide to my dosing.

Sorry for the long explanation but I think background info is needed...I have a high macro and micro consumption tank in a ~120g sps dominant mixed reef that has been running for about 4 years. I drip kalk for ~21hrs per day to match my tank evaporation. I haven't had my ATO RODI pump on for probably 2 years. Kalk drip stops at my peak photo period to try and reduce pH swings. I run fans to increase evaporation so I can dose more kalk and to keep my temp under 78.5 degrees May-October and about 77.5 when its not as hot outside and I can open the windows some. I end up dosing about 1 gallon of kalk per day. I also dose BRS soda ash, calcium chloride and magnesium based on weekly testing needs which averages somewhere between 60 and 120 ml per day for alk and calcium. I keep alkalinity between 7.5 and 8, calcium about 450 and magnesium 1450ish. I run a CO2 recirculating scrubber with my skimmer. I run reef moonshine method for traces and dose about 12 elements daily based of ICP every 6-8 weeks plus correction doses of some elements that have inconsistent consumption. I've switch over to making many of my own trace elements base on Randy's posts. I haven't done a water change in about 2.5 years.

My pH fluctuated daily between 8.3 and 7.9 and I haven't figured out an effective way to narrow this daily swing. I live in Florida and if I open my windows in the winter my pH will swing between 8.4 and 8.0. I'm considering adding on some sodium hydroxide dosing when my lights are off and my pH drops with the goal of reducing my pH swings. I am looking for guidance for the best way to do this.

My thoughts are to just add on sodium hydroxide dosing for about 12 hrs on top of what I am currently. NaOH dosing would start about 2 hrs after my lights go off until about an hour after they turn on. I would keep kalk and 2 part dosing still going but drop my soda ash dosing amount based of my alkalinity needs.

Thank you so much for any comments and a picture of my WD colony for attention.

fc4d7409-2875-4773-8e9a-2cc0ad8f4f6f.png
 
I'm using Notafeesh 2 part, which is sodium hydroxide based. I have high CO2 in my house with the kids and dogs. I run a CO2 scrubber, but I was still dropping below 7.8 at night. I dose the 2 part every 30 minutes, so 48 times a day. With the CO2 scrubber still attached, I get to 8.1 at night and between 8.5 and 8.6 during the day. I'm happy with it so far.
 
Honestly that swing is normal and works well. I dose kalk 24/7 alongside my carx.
Ph before kalk was 7.6 at night.
Now 7.9-8 at night and 8.3 during the day.
No need to fine tune yours.
My 2 year 150 for reference.
20260421_161454.jpg
 
Hoping someone can give me some guidance on the right approach to adding sodium hydroxide to my dosing.

Sorry for the long explanation but I think background info is needed...I have a high macro and micro consumption tank in a ~120g sps dominant mixed reef that has been running for about 4 years. I drip kalk for ~21hrs per day to match my tank evaporation. I haven't had my ATO RODI pump on for probably 2 years. Kalk drip stops at my peak photo period to try and reduce pH swings. I run fans to increase evaporation so I can dose more kalk and to keep my temp under 78.5 degrees May-October and about 77.5 when its not as hot outside and I can open the windows some. I end up dosing about 1 gallon of kalk per day. I also dose BRS soda ash, calcium chloride and magnesium based on weekly testing needs which averages somewhere between 60 and 120 ml per day for alk and calcium. I keep alkalinity between 7.5 and 8, calcium about 450 and magnesium 1450ish. I run a CO2 recirculating scrubber with my skimmer. I run reef moonshine method for traces and dose about 12 elements daily based of ICP every 6-8 weeks plus correction doses of some elements that have inconsistent consumption. I've switch over to making many of my own trace elements base on Randy's posts. I haven't done a water change in about 2.5 years.

My pH fluctuated daily between 8.3 and 7.9 and I haven't figured out an effective way to narrow this daily swing. I live in Florida and if I open my windows in the winter my pH will swing between 8.4 and 8.0. I'm considering adding on some sodium hydroxide dosing when my lights are off and my pH drops with the goal of reducing my pH swings. I am looking for guidance for the best way to do this.

My thoughts are to just add on sodium hydroxide dosing for about 12 hrs on top of what I am currently. NaOH dosing would start about 2 hrs after my lights go off until about an hour after they turn on. I would keep kalk and 2 part dosing still going but drop my soda ash dosing amount based of my alkalinity needs.

Thank you so much for any comments and a picture of my WD colony for attention.

fc4d7409-2875-4773-8e9a-2cc0ad8f4f6f.png
With that growth, and knowning that PH swings are natural and your range is fine, I wonder why bother worrying about it?

2nd, have you calibrated your ph probe recently? They do tend to drift over time.
 
Switching from soda ash to sodium hydroxide is the most you can do dosing wise with that all your alk demand will be replaced with an hydroxide
 
With that growth, and knowning that PH swings are natural and your range is fine, I wonder why bother worrying about it?

2nd, have you calibrated your ph probe recently? They do tend to drift over time.
Yeah, its been a couple months but I notice my pH probe drifts on the higher side and I recalibrate via apex every 6-9 months
 
I'm using Notafeesh 2 part, which is sodium hydroxide based. I have high CO2 in my house with the kids and dogs. I run a CO2 scrubber, but I was still dropping below 7.8 at night. I dose the 2 part every 30 minutes, so 48 times a day. With the CO2 scrubber still attached, I get to 8.1 at night and between 8.5 and 8.6 during the day. I'm happy with it so far.
Nice, not familiar with notafeesh but will look into it. I like to make my own stuff and am kind of a chemistry nerd.
 
I'm using Notafeesh 2 part, which is sodium hydroxide based. I have high CO2 in my house with the kids and dogs. I run a CO2 scrubber, but I was still dropping below 7.8 at night. I dose the 2 part every 30 minutes, so 48 times a day. With the CO2 scrubber still attached, I get to 8.1 at night and between 8.5 and 8.6 during the day. I'm happy with it so far.
I just started to dose this about a week ago. How are you liking it and are you dosing this mostly at night?
 
I just started to dose this about a week ago. How are you liking it and are you dosing this mostly at night?
I am setup to dose every 30 minutes, so 48 times a day 24 hours. It’s funny because I dose into the return chamber and my pH probe is 2 chambers before it in the skimmer. My pH probe spikes for just a second every time part 1 solution dispenses. It goes right back down to normal, but I can see it on my controller.
 
I am setup to dose every 30 minutes, so 48 times a day 24 hours. It’s funny because I dose into the return chamber and my pH probe is 2 chambers before it in the skimmer. My pH probe spikes for just a second every time part 1 solution dispenses. It goes right back down to normal, but I can see it on my controller.

That sounds like electrical interference. :)
 
That sounds like electrical interference. :)
🤔 There is a titanium grounding probe in the skimmer chamber by the pH probe. It happens right after (a second or so) after the doser doses??? It happens so fast that my Hydros graph doesn’t graph it when I go and look.
 
I just started to dose this about a week ago. How are you liking it and are you dosing this mostly at night?
I am setup to dose every 30 minutes, so 48 times a day 24 hours. It’s funny because I dose into the return chamber and my pH probe is 2 chambers before it in the skimmer. My pH probe spikes for just a second every time part 1 solution dispenses. It goes right back down to normal, but I can see it on my controller.
Nice. Yeah so far I haven’t had to dose a lot to get the elevated PH I wanted.
 
🤔 There is a titanium grounding probe in the skimmer chamber by the pH probe. It happens right after (a second or so) after the doser doses??? It happens so fast that my Hydros graph doesn’t graph it when I go and look.

Electrical interference through wires and air, not in the water. Such interference is a known problem of some pH devices.
 
Has anyone got a chart for dosing sodium hydroxide. I know how many grams into a gallon but I cant find any info on actual dosing chart
 

TOP 10 Trending Threads

Back
Top
Home
Post thread…
Market
What's new