https://www.reef2reef.com/threads/instant-tank-cycle.612166/#post-6155066
summary of that thread: Eli tells us we can't know if a reef tank is cycled without testing for it.
result: four years of back links for cycles verified without testing, free of charge, that's a recurring them...free vs for cost opining. it always amazed me the phD could not cycle tanks (or wouldn't) free of charge, we don't need any test kits for cycling tanks, therefore I'm not sure we need dna testing/kits for anything much right now/no response tools available
there's nothing we can add to drive the results in ways Eli says is best. he directly said something was not possible that we show possible, he defended it rather deeply, that makes me a skeptic from here on out.
to this date, someone can describe their cycle setup and we'll state if it's cycled or not, then we can be audited on a calibrated seneye to check for accuracy. it's possible to cycle reef tanks without testing, that's the only way I do it.