Anemone Recommendation

Dos Ocho

Community Member
View Badges
Joined
Nov 25, 2017
Messages
90
Reaction score
185
Location
Nebraska
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Hello all. I have a Biocube 29 that is crashing and i am planning a full reboot (dang Dinoflagellets). I have 2 Black and White clownfish that I've had for about a year and a half that will be going back into the tank and I would like to get them an anemone that they can hopefully host in and be happy!

So, my plan for the cube is a minimalist setup as far as live rock goes. This biocube was my first reef tank and i made essentially a giant rock structure in the display. It worked very well for me for a while, but I've learned a lot since then and think i can make a healthy system with other media and not have to have the tank packed to the brim with rock. I like open areas of sand and especially like rooted macroalgae (mermaid fans, pencil caps, etc...) and want to have a more open look to the new tank.

But I digress, my question is for all you anemone keepers. My anemone experience is only with Rock Flowers and a Maxi Mini. All are doing well, although I've found a couple RFAs move around a bit more than i was led to believe. I have 3 that have pretty much stayed put since arrival though. All 6 of my nems are alive and well, but I want a larger nem for the new cube.

I have been doing a lot of research on nems and think i have it narrowed down to 3 candidates:

Bubble Tip: Based on my research, obviously the most common and seemingly the hardiest of all larger nems. My concern about a BTA is they seem likely to move around a lot, especially when first added and I've seen a lot of people start with 1 and have it split and spread across the tank over time. As you all are aware, a 29 gallon can fill up quick. I will be reusing my MP-10 and I don't want a wandering nem to get chewed up and nuke the tank. I realize this can happen with any nem, but it seems like BTA's are more likely to wander into a powerhead.

Long Tentacle: Not as flashy as other nems, but i really like the look of them. Seems like they don't reproduce as much as BTA's and prefer to stay in the sand, so maybe a better chance of it staying put and away from the MP-10. Problem is I don't see a lot of folks with these nems so the info i am finding is limited.

Sebae: Seems to be a sand dweller like the LTA which i like. Nice color (I would aim to get a blue-tip), but not common and listed as a difficult nem.

So just looking for thoughts from experienced keepers, especially if you have a LTA or Sebae because they are my first choices. I will have other corals, but not many and I plan of the nem being the star of the show, so to speak. Thanks in advance for any advice.
 

hdsoftail1065

5000 Club Member
View Badges
Joined
Mar 19, 2018
Messages
7,446
Reaction score
45,775
Location
Derby, Kansas
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
We are happy with our BTA's. We picked both up from the lfs' for a song and dance (sump rescues). They were about this size of a quarter and attached where we placed them and has never moved. But, has you mentioned they have split, we have 4 now, plus a Green BTA. We had a lta years ago but it wasn't, as you said as flashy. I have never owned a Sebae.

Screenshot_20180628-221712.jpg
 

OrionN

Anemones
View Badges
Joined
Jul 28, 2013
Messages
9,128
Reaction score
21,149
Location
Corpus Christi, TX
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Hello all. I have a Biocube 29 that is crashing and i am planning a full reboot (dang Dinoflagellets). I have 2 Black and White clownfish that I've had for about a year and a half that will be going back into the tank and I would like to get them an anemone that they can hopefully host in and be happy!

So, my plan for the cube is a minimalist setup as far as live rock goes. This biocube was my first reef tank and i made essentially a giant rock structure in the display. It worked very well for me for a while, but I've learned a lot since then and think i can make a healthy system with other media and not have to have the tank packed to the brim with rock. I like open areas of sand and especially like rooted macroalgae (mermaid fans, pencil caps, etc...) and want to have a more open look to the new tank.

But I digress, my question is for all you anemone keepers. My anemone experience is only with Rock Flowers and a Maxi Mini. All are doing well, although I've found a couple RFAs move around a bit more than i was led to believe. I have 3 that have pretty much stayed put since arrival though. All 6 of my nems are alive and well, but I want a larger nem for the new cube.

I have been doing a lot of research on nems and think i have it narrowed down to 3 candidates:

Bubble Tip: Based on my research, obviously the most common and seemingly the hardiest of all larger nems. My concern about a BTA is they seem likely to move around a lot, especially when first added and I've seen a lot of people start with 1 and have it split and spread across the tank over time. As you all are aware, a 29 gallon can fill up quick. I will be reusing my MP-10 and I don't want a wandering nem to get chewed up and nuke the tank. I realize this can happen with any nem, but it seems like BTA's are more likely to wander into a powerhead.

Long Tentacle: Not as flashy as other nems, but i really like the look of them. Seems like they don't reproduce as much as BTA's and prefer to stay in the sand, so maybe a better chance of it staying put and away from the MP-10. Problem is I don't see a lot of folks with these nems so the info i am finding is limited.

Sebae: Seems to be a sand dweller like the LTA which i like. Nice color (I would aim to get a blue-tip), but not common and listed as a difficult nem.

So just looking for thoughts from experienced keepers, especially if you have a LTA or Sebae because they are my first choices. I will have other corals, but not many and I plan of the nem being the star of the show, so to speak. Thanks in advance for any advice.
In a 29 gal cube, I would recommended a H. malu. Two anemones have common name of Sebae: H. crispa and H. malu.
Crispa is a large anemone which live on the rock, no sand. Most anemone sold as Sebae are Crispa. Occasionally, there is a Malu available. Malu is a sand bed anemone that get to about 7-8 inced only. They dwell in the sand and does not need really high light or high current. Percula and Ocellaris readily go into Malu anemones. This is the anemone I recommended for a 29 gal cube tank.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top