Are we doing our bit to save coral reefs?

  • Thread starter Thread starter JoshO
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users Tagged users None

JoshO

Valuable Member
View Badges
Joined
Feb 7, 2020
Messages
1,751
Reaction score
8,649
Location
North East England
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
I've be acutely aware of the bleaching events for a number of years now. It's been something I've followed with fear and unease, and now after another mass event it's becoming increasingly clear that this is only going to get exponentially worse as our ocean temperatures rise.
What does that mean for us, reef hobbyists?
I've spent such a long period of time researching this hobby, and how to make it a success, and have now taken the leap into the saltwater world. But I can't help but think that in 10 years or so, much of that could be in vain. While there are people and companies out there that are doing their bit to try and culture corals in a way that isn't detrimental to reefs, it's obvious to see, with the hobby ever expanding, that this effort is likely not enough.
The global pandemic we are currently facing has further highlighted just how much we rely on the ocean to supply us with new frags and fish, just today I've seen a post on this forum about the potential for rising costs of corals due to the lack of shipping into the UK, I can't help but think this will be the case in all but those countries with reefs on their doorsteps.
I'm someone who also is an avid fly fisherman, and for years I've been paying my licence fees and encouraging catch and release to any other anglers who will listen. I spend a small period of each trip clearing rubbish left behind by the public and unfortunately other anglers, I still feel that this isn't enough. It does give me some hope, however, that anglers are becoming ever more vocal and passionate about the state of our rivers, and that this will ultimately lead to a positive outcome. I don't know that the same can be said for our hobby unfortunately.
While many of us are aware of what is happening in our oceans, I don't believe even we know the full extent.
Seeing companies like ORA doing their bit to increase the numbers of captive bred fish in the hobby is promising, but as for corals, the effort seems to be less intense.
It pains me to see so many hobbyists allowing their reefs to fall into a state of death and decay, and have nobody criticize them for doing so. Corals, fish and inverts are living beings, would we all be so forgiving if we saw people neglecting dogs or cats in this way? I'm not sure we would.
It's obvious that the problem is far greater than the hobby farming our oceans for new corals and fish, but even the smallest negative impact is a negative nonetheless. Do we all consciously try to reduce our carbon footprint to help slow global warming? Whilst many of us do small amounts when we can, I doubt (myself included) we are doing anywhere near enough.
I'd love to know some of your opinions on whether you think we are doing enough, and if not, what we can do to further benefit our coral reefs before they are totally wiped out?
 
Hopefully everyone does their part. I don't buy fish often, but when I do I try to buy captive bred. I only add aquacultured corals to my tank, nothing wild. I could be wrong, but I don't think coral collection for the aquarium industry is wiping out the worlds coral reefs. I think global warming, toxic runoff, overfishing, acid rain, and others are the main contributors to coral loss.
 
I think the best thing we can do in our tanks is try to only shop aquacultured frags or get frags from other hobbyists. Same goes for fish. It is difficult to do that and you’d have to make some compromises.
As far as the coral reefs devastation, there are so many factors at play. Particularly a practice called “trawling” which ruins the ocean floor - a practice the fish industry uses. Rising temperatures of course are a large factor and the industry responsible the most is animal agriculture.
Going vegan is the best way to reduce your carbon footprint. Trying to get aquacultured coral and fish is the best way to reduce the impact your reef has.
 
To be honest, I’m not sure there’s much we can do. If you compare the damage we do to reefs to say, commercial fishing, we don’t even come close to that. Not to mention global warming raising the temperature and lowering the salinity of the ocean. If the hobby just disappeared over night I’m sure there would be some benefit to natural reefs, but it would only stall what’s still inevitable.

I think at this point the only good we can do is save the coral that we have. Almost like a zoo that keeps an animal that’s become extinct in the wild. Maybe there will come a day when we can try to regrow reefs, but I don’t think we alone can do anything to fix what’s happening right now. Unfortunately those of us that care are stuck watching everything fall apart.
 
I believe if we fix the carbon situation(and some local problems like overfishing etc) the reef would probably do well even if some corals were harvested to the aquarium trade(at a sustainable rate of course).

Im trying to reduce my carbon footprint as much as I can at the moment. Not travel by airplanes, have no car, eating less meat etc.
 
We in western society can reduce our carbon footprints as much as possible and not even put a noticeable dent in the problem so long as countries like India and China aren’t being asked to abide by at least 1970’s era emissions standards.
 
In my opinion this hobby is not helping the reefs at all and is actually contributing to the coral die offs. Lots of energy is used to run aquariums. But then again, everything we humans do is contributing sadly.
 
Another hopeful sign (and things that can be supported) are things like the 1 billion oyster program in NY harbor. The goal is to bring back the natural filter feeders (and thereby take out pollution from the ocean). also, many places are re-building reefs from frags taken from hobby tanks.
 
To be honest, I’m not sure there’s much we can do. If you compare the damage we do to reefs to say, commercial fishing, we don’t even come close to that. Not to mention global warming raising the temperature and lowering the salinity of the ocean. If the hobby just disappeared over night I’m sure there would be some benefit to natural reefs, but it would only stall what’s still inevitable.

I think at this point the only good we can do is save the coral that we have. Almost like a zoo that keeps an animal that’s become extinct in the wild. Maybe there will come a day when we can try to regrow reefs, but I don’t think we alone can do anything to fix what’s happening right now. Unfortunately those of us that care are stuck watching everything fall apart.
I disagree with you that there isn't a lot we can do. By doing our bit, buying aquacultured corals and captive bred fish we will reduce our impact.
Also how much effort are we making to reduce our individual carbon footprints? We knowingly use more energy than the average household to power our reefs, and everyone will agree that energy consumption is what's fueling global warming and consequently the warming of our oceans.
In terms of trawling, there are plenty of charities and organisations that actively fight this, how many of us support them?
 
Growing up in California being blocks from La Jolla beach, I have always had a thing for the beach, im almost drawn to it, Being that i live is Texas now a couple hundred miles from any beach, if i dont go see the ocean every couple months i just dont feel right almost off centered. So its always been important to me. Being a UC Berkeley grad some sort of activism is almost bread into you from your freshman year. There are several activists that have done a ton and continue to do there part, being that i cant myself drop everything and be as vigilant as them about it, i do what i can, My wife and i donate to several foundations like Surfriders, Mission Blue, Sea Shepard, Coral reef Alliance and Coral Restoration foundation.

I also left Tech a couple years ago and took a job with one of the only carbon capture plants in the world that uses it technology to create products used everyday like Sodium Bicarbonate, sodium hydroxide ( Caustic Soda ), sodium hypochlorite ( Bleach ) and hydrochloric acid, used in almost every outlet in the world from water treatment to manufacturing. Unlike most plants that create these products we are 100% carbon free.
 
Growing up in California being blocks from La Jolla beach, I have always had a thing for the beach, im almost drawn to it, Being that i live is Texas now a couple hundred miles from any beach, if i dont go see the ocean every couple months i just dont feel right almost off centered. So its always been important to me. Being a UC Berkeley grad some sort of activism is almost bread into you from your freshman year. There are several activists that have done a ton and continue to do there part, being that i cant myself drop everything and be as vigilant as them about it, i do what i can, My wife and i donate to several foundations like Surfriders, Mission Blue, Sea Shepard, Coral reef Alliance and Coral Restoration foundation.

I also left Tech a couple years ago and took a job with one of the only carbon capture plants in the world that uses it technology to create products used everyday like Sodium Bicarbonate, sodium hydroxide ( Caustic Soda ), sodium hypochlorite ( Bleach ) and hydrochloric acid, used in almost every outlet in the world from water treatment to manufacturing. Unlike most plants that create these products we are 100% carbon free.
This is awesome to hear. Efforts like this give me hope!
 
I think we do a bit of both. It takes a lot of energy to run our tanks, but not all of us use bad energy. Some use sunlight in greenhouses, some use solar panels to help, etc, etc. I also think we help whenever someone new comes to the home and sees our tanks. Just awareness is the first step.

I personally am a crazy recycling and reusing freak. I try to not use plastic as much as possible, reuse then recycle, compost, blah, blah. I am not perfect as I get lazy too.

However, I did start an awareness program in my area to teach kids about coral reefs. It is fun and eye opening for many. Every bit helps. I also buy captive bred and aquacultured. Maricultured is good too as it supports those in other countries "farming" for their livelihood.
 
I think we do a bit of both. It takes a lot of energy to run our tanks, but not all of us use bad energy. Some use sunlight in greenhouses, some use solar panels to help, etc, etc. I also think we help whenever someone new comes to the home and sees our tanks. Just awareness is the first step.

I personally am a crazy recycling and reusing freak. I try to not use plastic as much as possible, reuse then recycle, compost, blah, blah. I am not perfect as I get lazy too.

However, I did start an awareness program in my area to teach kids about coral reefs. It is fun and eye opening for many. Every bit helps. I also buy captive bred and aquacultured. Maricultured is good too as it supports those in other countries "farming" for their livelihood.
Another great positive story!
I also recycle or reuse virtually everything.
Standby doesnt exist for any of my electrical goods, and I walk everywhere I can!
I believe conscious decisions can be made by everyone to change this becoming any worse
 
I agree with a lot thats been said
I feel i do a little to help some wild species, not saltwater as such, but i have been breeding the wild betta fish;betta channoides, which is critically endangered inthe wild due to palm oil plantations destroying the peat swamps they live in within their very restricted range in Borneo. But theres a lot more that could be done to help the situation with reefs and rivers alike
20200323_150335.jpg
Theres one of the babies.
 

WHICH KIND OF INVERT HAS CAUSED THE MOST MISCHIEF IN YOUR TANK?

  • Sea urchins

    Votes: 15 23.1%
  • Hermit crabs

    Votes: 11 16.9%
  • Other crabs

    Votes: 4 6.2%
  • Shrimp

    Votes: 5 7.7%
  • Snails or conchs

    Votes: 3 4.6%
  • Sea stars

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Anemones

    Votes: 12 18.5%
  • None! My inverts are model citizens. :-)

    Votes: 11 16.9%
  • Something else (tell us in the comments)

    Votes: 4 6.2%
Back
Top
Home
Post thread…
Market
What's new