Asterina stars: harmless cleanup crew or troublemakers?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Sam7
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users Tagged users None
I was picking them out, from concern that folks said they eat corals. But real likfe happens and I couldn’t keep up. They are NOT bothering my corals, so letting them go. I expect it’s like vermithrid snails, bristleworms and other annoying but harmless critters and they will reach a tipping point and the population will self regulate.
 
In my tanks I've never had an issue with them. Their populations never exploded. I tend to keep scarlet reef hermits and/or orange tron hermits (color morph of zebra hermits) so maybe they preyed upon the asterinas. I haven't seen any impact to corals including zoas.

I have seen and maintained tanks where they really proliferated though. Target removal for a few days (scraping a bunch off the glass) was sufficient to knock them back down.
 
They are on my auto kill list. I had an infestation once and it was annoying to deal with them on the glass and they eat your calcified algae. I had the pale pink/tan type.

Recently found a somewhat larger dark grey star and that guy is in a fish bowl for the kids to keep going.
 
What’s funny is here I am wanting some and everyone having too many to keep so they’re being thrown out 😂
 
Do you leave them alone, remove them, or only act when they’re bothering corals? I had a mix of really dark colored ones and some white ones. I just kept manually removing them every night when they appeared after lights out. Still finding a few ocassionally after several months of removing them. I used a small shrimp net on the glass and long tweezers in my pipe organ corals, a very delicate operation on that coral. Fingers work well also but i try to minimize my hands in the tank.
I remove every one of them ! While they eat algae they also eat zoa and other softies. Been through this nightmare with them once too often
 
Their populations never exploded. I tend to keep scarlet reef hermits and/or orange tron hermits (color morph of zebra hermits) so maybe they preyed upon the asterinas.
Interesting, I never imagined that. My 75 is clean and free as far as I know. I wonder if my halloween hermits would have eaten any.

I did purposely introduce a single one to my 5 gal whatever tank hardly a few months ago. It has divided at least twice by now.
 
I pick them out of the DT with a long tweezer and drop them into the sump where my Harlequin Shrimp lives. Free food for the little guy.
 
I think this is another example of a critter in the hobby where we lump several different species together, despite them having different behaviors and diets, simply because we struggle to tell them apart.


Asterina is a genus containing around 15 species of starfish. As others have mentioned, we see white ones, gray ones, ones with red spots, and pink or tan varieties. There are quite a few different types in the hobby, which makes it difficult to label them all as either “good” or “bad.”


One hobbyist might have a species that feeds on corals, while another might have one that reproduces rapidly and becomes a nuisance. Personally, I have some that don’t appear to bother any of my corals and don’t seem to reproduce particularly quickly.


I think the problem is that we tend to treat them all as the same animal when they may have very different behaviors. I personally think we’ve seen something similar happen with emerald crabs in the hobby, but that’s a whole other discussion!
 
I usually just leave them alone but recently I developed a huge infestation which caused them to pretty much strip my rock clean of coralline. Started pulling our roughly 100 a night for about a week. Eventually borrowed a Harlequin which seems to have finished them off. Crazy how the asterinas sense a predator in the tank....the first night I added the shrimp there were hundreds of stars on the top of the glass trying to escape.
 
If I remember correctly, there are 13 different types of asterinas. 2 of them eat corals. I got them from a guy that had a coral farm and he had them for years with no problems. I looked at them as part of a cleanup crew. But they will multiply to what their environment can support just like snails and anything else.
 
I’ve had them for years without problems, though once in a while I noticed some zoas disappearing. I figured it could have been anything. Just recently they went on a rampage: population boom followed by them clearing out tank algae. Suddenly they turned on my zoas, pipe organ, and other soft corals like locusts. Now I’m in the tank every night picking out as many as I can.
 
They can get out of hand. I got a harlequin shrimp then they were gone….then I had trouble feeding the shrimp….
 
I have a zero tolerance approach for them, I’ve found them numerous times eating Zoas, and on one occasion one eating tracks through the flesh on the underside of a big Acropora colony…
 
I used to ignore them, but just last week I finally caught them eating my zoas. I had had a suspicion they were doing it but had never actually seen them. 100% they’ve been my problem with my coral regression. I watched a previously perfect Zoa polyp disappear after the star was done with it. Now I’m picking them out as fast as I can.
 
Starfishes explode, bought a clown shrimp, the shrimp eats them all, need buy starfishes to feed the clown shrimp, or some cold people just let them starve to death
 

TOP 10 Trending Threads

HOW WOULD YOU FEEL ABOUT RECEIVING A FISH OR CORAL AS A HOLIDAY GIFT?

  • I’d love one, as long as it’s a species I chose

    Votes: 13 37.1%
  • I’d trust someone who knows my tank to choose

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • I’d rather get a gift card and pick it myself

    Votes: 13 37.1%
  • I’d prefer gear or supplies instead

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Please don’t surprise me with livestock

    Votes: 9 25.7%
  • Other (Post in the comments)

    Votes: 0 0.0%
Back
Top
Home
Post thread…
Market
What's new