How far can someone take Kalkwasser

njmaddreefer

Active Member
View Badges
Joined
Apr 21, 2025
Messages
171
Reaction score
164
Location
Andover
What state or country do you live in
New Jersey
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
So, my tanks been up for 14 months. It’s got roughly 150 gallons of total water volume.

I run the tank on 6000ml of saturated kalkwasser/day. I’ve just about matched my evaporation and my tank has sort of settled there.

I have smaller Acropora colonies and consumption sort of plateaued. Is it common for SPS reefs to be able to thrive on kalkwasser alone?

I hear about reefs running kalkwasser, calcium reactors, 2 part with less coral mass, but for some reason my kalkwasser has been enough…
20261122_010250_4B09CF8A-77E6-43C1-97C3-FDE57E52031B.png
 
Do you do water changes, I have a 70 gallon total water volume tank I use 3000ml a day of Kalk form a reactor and I need to add 65 ml of alk and 65ml of calcium a day but I don’t do water changes. Tank is about 2 yrs old and no water changes in the past 4 months and only because I dealt with ich and medicated the tank and the coral didn’t take kindly with it.
 
Do you do water changes, I have a 70 gallon total water volume tank I use 3000ml a day of Kalk form a reactor and I need to add 65 ml of alk and 65ml of calcium a day but I don’t do water changes. Tank is about 2 yrs old and no water changes in the past 4 months and only because I dealt with ich and medicated the tank and the coral didn’t take kindly with it.
I've done with and without....I like the results better "with" when I can get a good routine that fits my life. :)

Let your tank's nutrient levels AND alkalinity be your guide on water changes. DON'T do them when nutrient levels are already sufficiently low. DO do them to replenish alkalinity and trace elements and to remove buildup of toxins or other undesirables from the tank. Dose when requirements for replenishing go beyond what your water change schedule can do.

Unless you're using an enhanced salt like Reef Crystals, water changes aren't going to have much impact on how much kalk you're dosing. An aggressive water change schedule with RC might, though, if the tank's nutrient levels can support it.
 
Like you I dose Kalk almost to the evaporation rate and use All For Reef to fine tune the chemistry. I use ATO for any remaining evaporation. I’m at 50 net gallons and 10 months in and see positive results along with very stable calc and alk. I do dose mag separately. You may want to try All for reef as well and see if it works for you. Good luck!!
 
I used kalk only on my last tank and it worked great, but it was not a heavy SPS tank.
 
Some add vinegar once they hit the evaporation limit, if that’s what you’re asking.

I haven’t tried that yet. I do have a carx to make up for the additional needs as I’m past the evap limit by a ways.
 
Do you do water changes, I have a 70 gallon total water volume tank I use 3000ml a day of Kalk form a reactor and I need to add 65 ml of alk and 65ml of calcium a day but I don’t do water changes. Tank is about 2 yrs old and no water changes in the past 4 months and only because I dealt with ich and medicated the tank and the coral didn’t take kindly with it.
I do water changes twice a month 🙂. 50 gallons of new water goes in.

I run my tank at 10ish dKH along with phosphates around 0.1ppm so I use Reef Crystals fine.
 
Like you I dose Kalk almost to the evaporation rate and use All For Reef to fine tune the chemistry. I use ATO for any remaining evaporation. I’m at 50 net gallons and 10 months in and see positive results along with very stable calc and alk. I do dose mag separately. You may want to try All for reef as well and see if it works for you. Good luck!!
Super cool 🙂.

I wonder if a lot of reefs out there could have much simpler setups that thrive mainly on kalkwasser alone?
 
I'm dosing 10ltrs per day(30ltr container) and do a 200ltr water change weekly on a 1000ltr system. I add 120mls vinegar into the mix. Ph will drop slightly due to the vinegar. I don't chase numbers, ie mag, ca, alk and maintain a ph, between 8.3/8.4 that is stable. I also dose FM Multi elements A&B.
The bonus just now being winter, I don't have to be concerned with evaporation just now. During the summer months it was a nightmare
But as things are growing I may find myself going back to the old skool methods 'Balling Light' because i have the equipment and it worked very well. I will still dose Kalwasser to maintain ph 👌
 
Common for kalkwasser to reach its limit. I’m way beyond my evaporation rate. Still use kalk but had to add 2 part about 1.5 years ago, iirc.
 
Super cool 🙂.

I wonder if a lot of reefs out there could have much simpler setups that thrive mainly on kalkwasser alone?

Many could, but if one needs or wants trace elements, that would have to come from another additive.

I compare methods here:

https://www.reef2reef.com/ams/pros-and-cons-of-alkalinity-and-calcium-dosing-methods.1069/
Thanks Randy, I really like the table you put together.

Excellent summary and clearly lays out pros/cons.
 
Common for kalkwasser to reach its limit. I’m way beyond my evaporation rate. Still use kalk but had to add 2 part about 1.5 years ago, iirc.
What kind of coral mass and in what size tank did it require until kalkwasser wasn’t enough?
 
Joe Yaiullo hasn't hit the limit on him 20K gallon reef at the Long Island Aquarium. He only uses KW.




Plus 👌




When I mix kalk, my test reading is 12.5 using the ph probe, I am aware you can test conductivity.
Don't care for that, i am not a pro but i consider myself experienced in the required water chemistry
 
Last edited:
What kind of coral mass and in what size tank did it require until kalkwasser wasn’t enough?
It’s a small system, a 33 gallon and a 16 gallon connected mixed reef, no sump. In Florida it’s humid so maybe less evaporation than other places. I’m always trimming SPS as growth is completely maxed out, with corals growing both on the glass and to the water line…

Some pictures:
IMG_1879.jpeg
IMG_1880.jpeg
IMG_1848.jpeg
IMG_1856.jpeg
 
Beautiful coral jungle 🙂🤙

I think it makes sense for your systems to have run out of kalkwasser capacity given the nice wall-to-wall growth, tank volume, and relative humidity.

I do notice in the humid northeast summer months my evaporation decreases when compared to the drier winter.

I guess the original point of my post is how I think in a 150 gallon plus system it can take a lot for you to reach your kalkwasser limit and I’m surprised how far I’ve been able to take saturated kalkwasser.
 

TOP 10 Trending Threads

HOW WOULD YOU FEEL ABOUT RECEIVING A FISH OR CORAL AS A HOLIDAY GIFT?

  • I’d love one, as long as it’s a species I chose

    Votes: 26 23.2%
  • I’d trust someone who knows my tank to choose

    Votes: 10 8.9%
  • I’d rather get a gift card and pick it myself

    Votes: 45 40.2%
  • I’d prefer gear or supplies instead

    Votes: 3 2.7%
  • Please don’t surprise me with livestock

    Votes: 28 25.0%
  • Other (Post in the comments)

    Votes: 0 0.0%
Back
Top
Home
Post thread…
Market
What's new