Attention coral experts when do you recommend beginners should add corals

DEE’S reef

Well-Known Member
View Badges
Joined
Jan 17, 2026
Messages
613
Reaction score
234
Location
warren, mi
What state or country do you live in
Michigan
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
What do you coral experts recommend when a beginner can add corals I’ve heard wait till you have some coralline algae that means the tanks stable and maturing but what do you suggest.
 
Two things, experts are few and hard to find. Secondly the presence of coraline algae is not an indicator of the potential for coral growth or success.

Soft Corals.
Toad Stool, any of the leathers are good beginner corals.
Kenya Tree, Colt, GSP, Xenia, Anthelia are all easy corals with the potential to become invasive.
Zoanthid, most popular types are forgiving.
Corallimorphia, aka Mushrooms.

Lsp Corals.
Duncan, Candy Cane, some of the more common Euphyllia and Goniopora.
 
Usually once your parameters are stable post cycle you are clear to start adding easy corals like softies etc. I usually will add clean up crew and fish before adding corals.
 
Ok I tested today
Parameter
Ph 8.2
Alk 10
Magnesium 1230
Calcium 410
Phosphate .1
Nitrate 10
Ammonia 0
Nitrite 0
Salinity 1.025
Are these parameters good
 
What do you coral experts recommend when a beginner can add corals I’ve heard wait till you have some coralline algae that means the tanks stable and maturing but what do you suggest.
On average, I’d say 1-2 months to start adding softies, 4-6 months LPS, and 8-12 months SPS.
This gives your tank time to mature and you to gain experience. Not all species are equal in each of those loose categories though, and it can vary by specific species.
 
Take been setup for 2 months sow later this week I’ll do my test again and average my test for 2 months to have something to compare to and I’ll post those numbers here
 
So I have a coralline algae starting is that a good sign to get coral or should I wait a while to get coral
 
For me, a basic understanding of what your buying, making sure your tank setup will support the needs of the corals you want to buy. Being able to keep the tank stable and know that the more coral you add or grows they will start depleting calcium and alkalinity. Start slow and watch them grow.
 
Dry rock but I added clean up crew from an established tank that was covered in coralline algae.
I also plan to start with some zoos and some mushrooms the fish store near me @DetroitReefClub has frags for 19$ and deals if you get 5 or more.
 
I always add coral before fish,and straight after cycle sps and lps
 
Two things, experts are few and hard to find. Secondly the presence of coraline algae is not an indicator of the potential for coral growth or success.
I think both of those points are debatable. As far as coralline, its presence may not be a sole signal that the tank is ready for coral, but it does demonstrate that surface biofilms have reached a certain level of maturity thst does take time to establish. It could be argued that a certain level of microbial balance is beneficial for coral introduction.

That said, I don’t see an issue with adding any coral early on as long as water chemistry is within acceptable ranges.
 
Here’s the numbers from yesterday testing
IMG_0636.jpeg

And here’s the 2 months average
IMG_0638.jpeg
 
Also is this coralline
IMG_0593.jpeg
IMG_0592.jpeg
IMG_0594.jpeg

Another thing I was thinking zoa on the top shelf rock of the cave. Could that work as like a zoa a garden.
IMG_0621.jpeg
IMG_0622.jpeg
IMG_0624.jpeg

I would also love suggestions for the arches on what to put there.
IMG_0626.jpeg
 
Stay away from Xenia and green star polyp, unless you can really isolate them somewhere. Reefer's often start with these beginner corals and then they just end up taking over the aquarium, becoming more of a problem than anything else.
 
What’s or thoughts on a zoa garden on the shelf piece on top that forms the cave. I’m also looking at rock flower anemones have any of you guys have experience with them.
 
What do you coral experts recommend when a beginner can add corals I’ve heard wait till you have some coralline algae that means the tanks stable and maturing but what do you suggest.



The fact that you’re even asking the question already puts you on a better path than most. The reality is that many new reefers just toss in a “test coral” and hope for the best.

Seeing coralline algae start to grow is a great sign. It shows the tank is capable of supporting calcareous algae, which is a strong indicator that the environment can support other calcifying life as well. In many cases, the time it takes for coralline to appear ends up being a bit of a self-fulfilling checkpoint for tank maturity.

Another useful indicator is stability after the early ugly phases. If the problematic slimes and nuisance algae have settled down and the tank has been stable for about a month, that is often a good time to try a first coral.

That said, maturity is still a moving target. Tanks started in a very sterile way often take three to four times longer to reach the same success rate as tanks where more effort was put into establishing a healthy microbiome from the start.
 
Started with live sand and doctor tims had a little problem with ammonia in the start add micro bacter 7 for a week it all the same numbers calcium and magnesium gone done a tad bit but all seems fine. I just can’t wait for the green to turn purple/pink.
 
Your pink spots resemble coralline, there's not much else it could be. Typically, healthy growing coralline starts as tiny specs on anything plastic, they will have a growth edge around them, they get bigger and connect to form sheets, then after some time of periods of growth and decline they will get thicker and new will grow over old. You will eventually hate it lol.
But I'd generally agree that coralline formation is signaling that your tank will support some of the easier corals. I'd stay away from stony corals for a good while as they are unlikely to establish themselves and grow in a young tank. What usually happens is stony corals are introduced too early and will go into a dormant state with no growth at all, while the hobbyist is thinking they are doing great but in reality they are in decline. Most corals that go into lengthy dormancy are hard to get to grow again. That's why it is generally accepted to stay away from acros and such until your tank is older.
Your tank would probably support zoanthids, mushrooms and leathers right now. You will need some more fish though, I was experiencing dormancy and growth concerns in my sps frag tank until I added a few more fish and began feeding more, the growth then exploded and took off lol. And fwiw I couldn't say what my nutrient levels are at the moment, I haven't measured them for a few months, the corals tell me everything I need to know lol..
What are your plans for the vlamingi/unicorn? You've got about another 90 days before that fish becomes a serious issue for you.
 

TOP 10 Trending Threads

HOW DO YOU HANDLE HOLIDAY DECORATING AROUND YOUR REEF?

  • I decorate the tank or stand

    Votes: 1 33.3%
  • I decorate AROUND the tank or stand

    Votes: 1 33.3%
  • I add one small seasonal touch but keep it very basic

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • I take a holiday photo, but don’t decorate the space

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • I leave the reef area as it is

    Votes: 1 33.3%
  • We don’t decorate for the holidays

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Other (Post in the comments)

    Votes: 0 0.0%
Back
Top
Home
Post thread…
Market
What's new