Best Phosphate remover

  • Thread starter Thread starter myzislow
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users Tagged users None
Ahhhhh

I think I'm going to go over to the stuff from BRS
as soon as I Use up my Rowaphos.

From looking on the BRS site, and their suggested amounts,
I think I'm using way to little Rowaphos.

I like the BRS stuff, it tumbles a little better in reactors, the DFS and Phoslock stuff was also inexpensive but was tough to get to tumble and tended to clump more, as did other brands of similar size.
 
Carbon dosing doesn't remove phosphate nearly as well as nitrates, most people end up having to use other methods still to keep phosphates low.


Initially with vodka dosing, but once you get the phosphates down they stay down without GFO unless you increase your feedings.
 
Initially with vodka dosing, but once you get the phosphates down they stay down without GFO unless you increase your feedings.

It probably depends on the system, but in a system that tends to have low/undetectable nitrates to begin with but somewhat elevated phosphate levels, I doubt just carbon dosing would be sufficient. At least with my experiementing it didn't seem like it would be.
 
It probably depends on the system, but in a system that tends to have low/undetectable nitrates to begin with but somewhat elevated phosphate levels, I doubt just carbon dosing would be sufficient. At least with my experiementing it didn't seem like it would be.

My Nitrates went to zero quick from 50 with vodka dosing and but it took a lot longer with the phosphates for me. I've been dosing for about a year and a half and my phosphates have been under control for about 9 months, but I just took GFO offline a little over 3 months ago and phosphates are still in the .03-.07 range. I kept reading about people that had been vodka dosing for about a year and stopped the GFO and figured hell if I could cut another expense. I have been playing with the lanthanum chloride recently to see if I can dose less vodka also.
 
My Nitrates went to zero quick from 50 with vodka dosing and but it took a lot longer with the phosphates for me. I've been dosing for about a year and a half and my phosphates have been under control for about 9 months, but I just took GFO offline a little over 3 months ago and phosphates are still in the .03-.07 range. I kept reading about people that had been vodka dosing for about a year and stopped the GFO and figured hell if I could cut another expense. I have been playing with the lanthanum chloride recently to see if I can dose less vodka also.

Are these readings with a hobby grade test kit or a colorimeter? Also, like I said, I think people that start dosing vodka and don't have nitrates building up will struggle more to get phosphates down. At least I'm guessing that less available nitrates to consume means less phosphates will be consumed...
 
Are these readings with a hobby grade test kit or a colorimeter? Also, like I said, I think people that start dosing vodka and don't have nitrates building up will struggle more to get phosphates down. At least I'm guessing that less available nitrates to consume means less phosphates will be consumed...


It's with a Hanna meter. My phosphates in the past read zero with test kits but most of the test kits are crap when it comes to phosphates. I was having algae problems so I knew I had phosphates. I agree that if you have phosphates and nitrates already at zero it makes a difference but I think it's more of a time issue in that it just takes longer. I feel most that dose for over a year can end up taking GFO offline unless you are feeding ungodly amounts of food. I feed my fish three times per day and coral at night every other. I was dosing amino acids in the past and cut that out to see if I can just feed heavy and get same results.
 
It's with a Hanna meter. My phosphates in the past read zero with test kits but most of the test kits are crap when it comes to phosphates. I was having algae problems so I knew I had phosphates. I agree that if you have phosphates and nitrates already at zero it makes a difference but I think it's more of a time issue in that it just takes longer. I feel most that dose for over a year can end up taking GFO offline unless you are feeding ungodly amounts of food. I feed my fish three times per day and coral at night every other. I was dosing amino acids in the past and cut that out to see if I can just feed heavy and get same results.


That's why I asked, since hobby grade tests are basically worthless...


I'm guessing you discovered that feeding was enough? Amino acids supplements are just the new trace elements supplements as far as I'm concerned.
 
Save money and get the stuff from BRS. Everything I've read says everyone is using the same stuff and bottling it with their name on it. They have the wet stuff like the ROWAphos and the dry stuff in a larger granule like the Warner stuff.

I'd say the larger granule stuff would work best for you.
1 pound (453 Grams) Bulk GFO "Pellets" Ferric Oxide - English


+1....there is no rocket science in GFO. So kiss and buy in bulk and change often imho.
 
I have tried alot of different things Zeovit, Biopellets, HC GFO from BRS and Vodka. The only combination that is working now is the Vodka and HC GFO. I have to tell you this is on a 320G tank that has some big fish ( most over 10" ) Blonde Naso, pair Crosshatch Triggers, Vlamingii Tang and a few others. I have been fighting the Nitrate and Phosphate issues for about a year. I am finally starting to get a handle on both. My Nitrates were over 100ppm and are now in the 20 -30ppm range and my Phosphates were .70 and now running .07.
 
My Nitrates went to zero quick from 50 with vodka dosing and but it took a lot longer with the phosphates for me. I've been dosing for about a year and a half and my phosphates have been under control for about 9 months, but I just took GFO offline a little over 3 months ago and phosphates are still in the .03-.07 range. I kept reading about people that had been vodka dosing for about a year and stopped the GFO and figured hell if I could cut another expense. I have been playing with the lanthanum chloride recently to see if I can dose less vodka also.
Hi haw much vodka do you does my tank 4×2×2 400 liters haw much should i dose nitrate is 50 on the sela
My Nitrates went to zero quick from 50 with vodka dosing and but it took a lot longer with the phosphates for me. I've been dosing for about a year and a half and my phosphates have been under control for about 9 months, but I just took GFO offline a little over 3 months ago and phosphates are still in the .03-.07 range. I kept reading about people that had been vodka dosing for about a year and stopped the GFO and figured hell if I could cut another expense. I have been playing with the lanthanum chloride recently to see if I can dose less vodka also.
Hi,my nitrate is 50 my tank is 4×2×2 400lt can you tell me haw much would i need to dose per day thank jeff
 

TOP 10 Trending Threads

HOW WOULD YOU FEEL ABOUT RECEIVING A FISH OR CORAL AS A HOLIDAY GIFT?

  • I’d love one, as long as it’s a species I chose

    Votes: 14 35.9%
  • I’d trust someone who knows my tank to choose

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • I’d rather get a gift card and pick it myself

    Votes: 14 35.9%
  • I’d prefer gear or supplies instead

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Please don’t surprise me with livestock

    Votes: 11 28.2%
  • Other (Post in the comments)

    Votes: 0 0.0%
Back
Top
Home
Post thread…
Market
What's new