Calciumreactor Media: Better dissolving at Low or High PH?

World Citizen

Well-Known Member
View Badges
Joined
Jun 6, 2022
Messages
607
Reaction score
873
Location
the Netherlands
What state or country do you live in
Other International
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Hi,

Complex question. I hope someone with experience is willing to give me some pointers.

I am testing out a few calciumreactors and there seems to be a difference in how they operate.

- PH controlled
- Co2 Saturation controlled (Dastaco)

I have a question about dissolving media in reactors.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Example media: Coral bones (Coral skeleton).

A Dastaco tries to dissolve as much Co2 in the water as possible. The water is "saturated" with Co2 so the PH is as low as possible. Probably around ph 5 - 5.5.
A PH controlled reactor runs at a PH of about 7.6/7.7.

Question
Do the different elements in a Coral bone dissolve differently at different PH values?
If my effluent is 8.5/480/1380 when I dissolve at ph 7.7,
Is the effluent at the same values when dissolving at ph 5.5? Is it still 8.5/480/1380?

(incl trace and all other elements)

(I am not native English so will ask the same question in different forms with the hope of making any sense)
- If I dissolve coral skeleton at different PH levels. Do I end up with the same balance between all element?
- If we plot dissolving Calcium, Carbonate and Magnesium and all elements in a graph against PH. Do these graphs look linear or exponential? And does the shape change at different ph levels?

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Why am I asking this:

I am wondering in my effluent is in the same balance if I dissolve at ph 7.7 or 5.5. I was just wondering if you end up dissolving coral bone more equally at co2 saturation water, and end up with a better balance in effluent elements.
I can imagine all the different element in Coral bone dissolve differently at different ph values.

If so... would it be "better" to dissolve at ph 5.5 (co2 saturated water) so all the elements are dissolved at the same maximum rate of dissolving? You would dissolve a complete piece of bone with all it's element at once. Not 1 element takes slower and would remain as a leftover to dissolve.

If you run anything besides saturated (ph5.5) you could risk 1 element is dissolved slower and this can be seen as an imbalance. Even if it is a core element or a trace.



Thanks for reading... if you want to say anything... please do.

WC
 
As long as you are dissolving calcium carbonate at a rate you want without the solids turning to mush, I do not think the pH used impacts what else is there.

That said, pH 5.5 outside the norm and may not work well. Virtually nothing will happen at pH 7.7.
 
As long as you are dissolving calcium carbonate at a rate you want without the solids turning to mush, I do not think the pH used impacts what else is there.

That said, pH 5.5 outside the norm and may not work well. Virtually nothing will happen at pH 7.7.
Hi Randy,

Thanks for your time.
Do you know about the Dastaco reactors?
They are a different design of Calciumreactors. They run at a constant saturation of Co2.

I can't image you don't know them but I am a bit confused by your answer. Or maybe you are not a fan of Dastaco :)

Thanks Randy, I appreciate it.
 
I don’t know much about this type of reactor, but I see they sell special pure and dense media for it to avoid the issue I was referring to.

https://uniquecorals.com/products/dastaco2-pure-media-for-calcium-reactors-20kg-bucket
Media is made of a certain type of coarse marble mineral which is already much more dense and with less impurity than typical limestone. Because of its dense structure, DaStaCO recommends running the pH inside of the reactor at 6.0.

I’m not sure that if one is using marble, that you want to optimize release of other elements from it, but nevertheless, I don’t think the pH used will change that much.
 
I don’t know much about this type of reactor, but I see they sell special pure and dense media for it to avoid the issue I was referring to.

https://uniquecorals.com/products/dastaco2-pure-media-for-calcium-reactors-20kg-bucket
Media is made of a certain type of coarse marble mineral which is already much more dense and with less impurity than typical limestone. Because of its dense structure, DaStaCO recommends running the pH inside of the reactor at 6.0.

I’m not sure that if one is using marble, that you want to optimize release of other elements from it, but nevertheless, I don’t think the pH used will change that much.

Yeah I hope to approach this differently. I don't really care about the brand and what they say...
I am here for the difference between dissolving at low or higher PH. Independent of brand.. I referred to them because they use the full saturated method. ( I simply don't know of any other brand who do this).

Maybe the question is more simple if I take more time to learn how to say it in English :) ( I slept on this question)

Do all the elements in Coral Bone dissolve equally at all PH levels?
 
I thought I answered that. All media dissolve faster at lower pH, but at least within the pH ranges in question, the ratio of other elements to alk released will not significantly change with pH.
 
I thought I answered that. All media dissolve faster at lower pH, but at least within the pH ranges in question, the ratio of other elements to alk released will not significantly change with pH.
Thanks for the clarification.

It has been 2 days since my question, but I am still a bit confused about what I should think about these 2 approaches.

You either dissolve your media at a PH of 7.6, or you do it at a PH of 5.

I just can't ignore this.

Randy, if we build 2 tanks and run the calcium reactor at both of those approaches. It cant be the same?
 
There may well be differences, especially if using different media, but think of the process like this:

The various trace elements are trapped individually in the calcium carbonate. They are not their own mineral crystals, but individual ions bound to calcium or carbonate in the structure. Lowering the pH strips away the calcium and carbonate, freeing up each trace element ion one at a time.

To a first approximation, it does not matter how fast the calcium and carbonate are stripped away. Unless some ion is above its solubility limit in the water already, it will come out into the bulk water and be delivered to the tank. The pH does not impact that basic process, just the rate of it.
 
To be honest, I’m not a huge fan of these trace elements. Some may be useful and others useless, but never will that source alone supply all needed trace elements. It just supplies what is in the calcium carbonate, not those trace elements consumed by micro and macroalgae, soft corals, and even hard coral tissues.
 

TOP 10 Trending Threads

HOW WOULD YOU FEEL ABOUT RECEIVING A FISH OR CORAL AS A HOLIDAY GIFT?

  • I’d love one, as long as it’s a species I chose

    Votes: 26 24.5%
  • I’d trust someone who knows my tank to choose

    Votes: 9 8.5%
  • I’d rather get a gift card and pick it myself

    Votes: 43 40.6%
  • I’d prefer gear or supplies instead

    Votes: 2 1.9%
  • Please don’t surprise me with livestock

    Votes: 26 24.5%
  • Other (Post in the comments)

    Votes: 0 0.0%
Back
Top
Home
Post thread…
Market
What's new