- Joined
- Jun 6, 2022
- Messages
- 607
- Reaction score
- 873
- Location
- the Netherlands
- What state or country do you live in
- Other International
Hi,
Complex question. I hope someone with experience is willing to give me some pointers.
I am testing out a few calciumreactors and there seems to be a difference in how they operate.
- PH controlled
- Co2 Saturation controlled (Dastaco)
I have a question about dissolving media in reactors.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Example media: Coral bones (Coral skeleton).
A Dastaco tries to dissolve as much Co2 in the water as possible. The water is "saturated" with Co2 so the PH is as low as possible. Probably around ph 5 - 5.5.
A PH controlled reactor runs at a PH of about 7.6/7.7.
Question
Do the different elements in a Coral bone dissolve differently at different PH values?
If my effluent is 8.5/480/1380 when I dissolve at ph 7.7,
Is the effluent at the same values when dissolving at ph 5.5? Is it still 8.5/480/1380?
(incl trace and all other elements)
(I am not native English so will ask the same question in different forms with the hope of making any sense)
- If I dissolve coral skeleton at different PH levels. Do I end up with the same balance between all element?
- If we plot dissolving Calcium, Carbonate and Magnesium and all elements in a graph against PH. Do these graphs look linear or exponential? And does the shape change at different ph levels?
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Why am I asking this:
I am wondering in my effluent is in the same balance if I dissolve at ph 7.7 or 5.5. I was just wondering if you end up dissolving coral bone more equally at co2 saturation water, and end up with a better balance in effluent elements.
I can imagine all the different element in Coral bone dissolve differently at different ph values.
If so... would it be "better" to dissolve at ph 5.5 (co2 saturated water) so all the elements are dissolved at the same maximum rate of dissolving? You would dissolve a complete piece of bone with all it's element at once. Not 1 element takes slower and would remain as a leftover to dissolve.
If you run anything besides saturated (ph5.5) you could risk 1 element is dissolved slower and this can be seen as an imbalance. Even if it is a core element or a trace.
Thanks for reading... if you want to say anything... please do.
WC
Complex question. I hope someone with experience is willing to give me some pointers.
I am testing out a few calciumreactors and there seems to be a difference in how they operate.
- PH controlled
- Co2 Saturation controlled (Dastaco)
I have a question about dissolving media in reactors.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Example media: Coral bones (Coral skeleton).
A Dastaco tries to dissolve as much Co2 in the water as possible. The water is "saturated" with Co2 so the PH is as low as possible. Probably around ph 5 - 5.5.
A PH controlled reactor runs at a PH of about 7.6/7.7.
Question
Do the different elements in a Coral bone dissolve differently at different PH values?
If my effluent is 8.5/480/1380 when I dissolve at ph 7.7,
Is the effluent at the same values when dissolving at ph 5.5? Is it still 8.5/480/1380?
(incl trace and all other elements)
(I am not native English so will ask the same question in different forms with the hope of making any sense)
- If I dissolve coral skeleton at different PH levels. Do I end up with the same balance between all element?
- If we plot dissolving Calcium, Carbonate and Magnesium and all elements in a graph against PH. Do these graphs look linear or exponential? And does the shape change at different ph levels?
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Why am I asking this:
I am wondering in my effluent is in the same balance if I dissolve at ph 7.7 or 5.5. I was just wondering if you end up dissolving coral bone more equally at co2 saturation water, and end up with a better balance in effluent elements.
I can imagine all the different element in Coral bone dissolve differently at different ph values.
If so... would it be "better" to dissolve at ph 5.5 (co2 saturated water) so all the elements are dissolved at the same maximum rate of dissolving? You would dissolve a complete piece of bone with all it's element at once. Not 1 element takes slower and would remain as a leftover to dissolve.
If you run anything besides saturated (ph5.5) you could risk 1 element is dissolved slower and this can be seen as an imbalance. Even if it is a core element or a trace.
Thanks for reading... if you want to say anything... please do.
WC
