Can I add these to my current tank?

  • Thread starter Thread starter SaraJames
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users Tagged users None

SaraJames

Community Member
View Badges
Joined
Mar 23, 2026
Messages
79
Reaction score
54
Location
Wilmington
What state or country do you live in
North Carolina
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
I'm wanting to add to my 75 gallon tank but I don't want to overfill it or have fish killing each other. Due to the recent death of a clownfish and a mandarin goby (thanks to a Eibli Angel who has been moved to a different tank) I have some space. How does this look?

I currently have:
1 - Blue Hippo Tang
1 - Ocellaris Clowns
2 - Pajama Cardinals
2 - Blue Chromis
Condylactis Gigantea Purple Tip

I am looking to add some of the following:
Anthias - Queen Purple
Yellow Boxfish - ostracion cubicus
Lined Dartfish -ptereloeotris grammica
Long nose hawkfish
Pink face wrasse
Butterfly - thread fin or black and white
Mandarin Goby

5b48cdd8-6dc6-49bc-a184-c64091f2cf5d.jpg
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I'm wanting to add to my tank but I don't want to overfill it or have fish killing each other. How does this look?

I currently have:
Blue Hippo Tang
Mandarin Dragonet
2 - Ocellaris Clowns
2 - Pajama Cardinals
2 - Blue Chromis
Eibli Angel
Condylactis Gigantea Purple Tip

I am looking to add:
Anthias - Queen Purple
Yellow Boxfish - ostracion cubicus
Lined Dartfish -ptereloeotris grammica
Long nose hawkfish
Pink face wrasse
Butterfly - thread fin or black and white

5b48cdd8-6dc6-49bc-a184-c64091f2cf5d.jpg
That's a lot of fish for a 75g the anthias will require multiple feedings a day. I wouldn't recommend that many personally. It will be a heavy bioload on that size of a tank. As long as you do water changes and have oversized skimmer and other means to lower your nitrates and phosphates it should be ok but it'll be a constant battle to control your nitrates and phosphates.
 
That's a lot of fish for a 75g the anthias will require multiple feedings a dOK. I wouldn't recommend that many personally. It will be a heavy bioload on that size of a tank. As long as you do water changes and have oversized skimmer and other means to lower your nitrates and phosphates it should be ok but it'll be a constant battle to control your nitrates and phosphates.
If you had to leave some things out what would they be?
 
If you had to leave some things out what would they be?
Honestly I think your current stock list is enough for a 75g tank.

I have a 375g tank with a 90g sump and only have a blue hippo tang, white tail bristletooth tang, gem tang, Vlamingii Tang, a mystery wrasse, a possum wrasse, a fiji golden hawk fish, and 2 clown fish.

If.i had to choose the new stock list I'd
Personally skip the Anthias, box fish, and butterfly fish.
 
Hi there... almost anyone looking to answer a question like this will want to know the dimensions & gallon capacity of your tank. 😎👍🏻
 
do you dose pods or culture them (more appropriate)? If not, no to the mandarin as well.
I feed the fish every other day - 1 cube of Hikari omega enriched Brine shrimp and 1 cube of Hikari Bio-Pure Frozen Cyclopods. The anemone and the corals get Reef Nutrition Oyster Feast every other day (a few drops mixed with water for all of them).
I'll most likely cut down on the brine now that I have three less fish and delete the cyclopods until I have a fish that needs them.
 
I feed the fish every other day - 1 cube of Hikari omega enriched Brine shrimp and 1 cube of Hikari Bio-Pure Frozen Cyclopods. The anemone and the corals get Reef Nutrition Oyster Feast every other day (a few drops mixed with water for all of them).
I'll most likely cut down on the brine now that I have three less fish and delete the cyclopods until I have a fish that needs them.
You definitely need to feed more often. Several times a day preferably.
 
I used to feed daily but the LFS recommended I cut back to every other day because my nitrates were high. Now they are good.

What would you recommend?
 
I used to feed daily but the LFS recommended I cut back to every other day because my nitrates were high. Now they are good.

What would you recommend?
Not listening to your LFS if that's the advice you received.

I feed at least 3 times a day. A mixture of frozen, pellets and flakes, to two tanks a 20 and 25.
 
Not listening to your LFS if that's the advice you received.

I feed at least 3 times a day. A mixture of frozen, pellets and flakes, to two tanks a 20 and 25.
What type of pellets and flakes do you feed them?
 
IMG_0838.jpeg
 
Feeding less because of high nutrients in your tank can be ok, if your fish are already getting enough to eat. If they are not getting enough to eat, which from your description of what you're feeding them, I don't think they do, then you are going to have to get rid of the nutrients some other way.

You have a fish heavy tank. You are going to have high nutrients. My tank used to be understocked on fish, and I struggled to maintain nutrients. You need to learn how to export those nutrients either through more water changes, or getting something like a turf scrubber to eat up the nutrients and then harvesting turf algae and throwing it in the garbage.

Just my opinion. But imagine someone cut back on your food or drink because you were using the toilet more than once a day.
 
Feeding less because of high nutrients in your tank can be ok, if your fish are already getting enough to eat. If they are not getting enough to eat, which from your description of what you're feeding them, I don't think they do, then you are going to have to get rid of the nutrients some other way.

You have a fish heavy tank. You are going to have high nutrients. My tank used to be understocked on fish, and I struggled to maintain nutrients. You need to learn how to export those nutrients either through more water changes, or getting something like a turf scrubber to eat up the nutrients and then harvesting turf algae and throwing it in the garbage.

Just my opinion. But imagine someone cut back on your food or drink because you were using the toilet more than once a day.
OK here is what I am considering implementing:
2 times a day frozen
2 times a day pellets
2 times a day flakes
Weekly water changes of 10-20%?

With that said I don't understand how my tank is fish heavy if at max size the fish will add up to 36"? Especially adding in that the hippo tang would be moved to another tank when it is around 6-8".
 
Inches per gallon is the least sensible guideline for fish stocking. Imagine a 18 tailspot blennies vs one three foot mackerel. It'd be like half a pound of fish, vs 10 pounds of fish.

I personally like to feed twice a day, and I generally feed what the inhabitants can eat in a minute or two. I would generally let them tell you how much to feed them.
 

TOP 10 Trending Threads

HOW WOULD YOU FEEL ABOUT RECEIVING A FISH OR CORAL AS A HOLIDAY GIFT?

  • I’d love one, as long as it’s a species I chose

    Votes: 13 34.2%
  • I’d trust someone who knows my tank to choose

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • I’d rather get a gift card and pick it myself

    Votes: 14 36.8%
  • I’d prefer gear or supplies instead

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Please don’t surprise me with livestock

    Votes: 11 28.9%
  • Other (Post in the comments)

    Votes: 0 0.0%
Back
Top
Home
Post thread…
Market
What's new