excellent thread, there are two schools of practice developing I got this habit from watching Randy troubleshoot surface area questions in his fm
what parameter is lacking in the reef if you were to remove all sand, all that filtration all at once....which cycling param will change?
once we have that answer, we can state whether adding more live rock in the back is different from the ceramic media.
If polled, about 99% of reefers will say ammonia would be the param that changes, it gets accumulated beyond a safe zone bc we removed linked surface area.
but no seneye owners would say that...once we gained digital insight to what ammonia really does, and by extension surface area mechanics, we see that however much extra surface area we add beyond requirements is not a permanent fixture in the tank at all, its expendable. instantly.
like carrying 5 spares for a car
so you have a minimum amount of live rock already in the display that can run your current bioload, plus all the rest the tank will ever see. its probably about 1/3 of your current rock load, going off average ratios
post pics
that 1/3 of your current rock is what you can't reduce below.
Whether you hook up nine canister filters right now and cycle them in place for a year, then instantly remove them, nothing changes.
whether you double your ceramic loading, nothing changes. if you add live rock, nothing changes, its all catchpoints that need cleaning. Not any param you can accurately measure will be changed by what you remove from your surface area, just not that remaining 1/3rd amount of live rock.
post a tank pic
*for power-outage prone tanks, having too much surface area is dangerous. the extra bacteria are commanding o2 more than your whole fish loading, bigtime competitors.