Cyano and probably Dino’s outbreak problem

  • Thread starter Thread starter Mata_01
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users Tagged users None

Mata_01

Community Member
View Badges
Joined
Mar 23, 2025
Messages
55
Reaction score
12
Location
Portugal
What state or country do you live in
Other International
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
So my tank is about 6 months old, I don’t have a lot of corals (like 8) and have two clowns, a month or two ago I had a fight with Dinos, I defeat them and all seem fine.
Now two weeks ago Cyanobacteria started showing up, first I thought it was just a flow/dead spot issue so I increased the flow, but hit has been spreading.
I started a treatment with BioClear from modern reef and 2 days after started dosing biobac, during the 2 days the uv light and the skimmer were shut off, and then after turned on.
My problem is that the cyano have been increasing even with the treatment.
I have been cleaning them without changing the water and using a filter at the end of the sucking tube and then putting the water back on, I have been cleaning the filter.
My corals seem fine just my zoas and gsp haven’t been opening a lot probably because cyano is on top of them, even when I clean it regularly.
Anyone can help me?
20250826_145445_ECCA9A46-E8B6-4729-9C9B-EF5702BD835D.png


20250826_145446_84FD804E-7EED-4BF4-8B8E-DE3DC171C584.png


20250826_145446_92C2A6A3-352E-416A-B2C9-C65ED9AED051.png


20250826_145446_44F0300F-62BF-4036-A994-50AA1A1935F1.png


20250826_145446_CADDFC5D-AFE4-4447-AAE5-25C959AD0282.png


20250826_145446_A8413216-761D-42CB-8E7C-5C6A7ED6A1E3.png


20250826_145446_B445CF3B-4873-4989-8A54-5BCC22B16163.png


20250826_145446_A96CAE98-A382-4C85-972B-82878E721D81.png


20250826_145446_565D2B07-C732-448A-AC66-C7961F6904AA.png


20250826_145458_1D3D8CCE-386F-4937-955F-8CBA6EB0B3FE.png
 
I beat cyanos in my first tank with regular water changes and time. Just wait it out and don't use any chemicals to treat it. I know they look ugly but you're currently in the ugly phase of your new tank XD
 
I beat cyano by doing a blackout. The dinos disappeared for a few days but have come back. I am in the ugly phase as well. It takes close to a year for tanks to settle in. I ended another blackout this morning. Hoping the dinos are gone for good.
 
If your dog takes a big 💩 in the living room doesn’t matter if you test it or put fragrance on it still going to smell….your aquarium is filthy, clean it! Blow, scrub and remove the algae with WC or a canister filter. Don’t bother doing anything else….
 
If your dog takes a big 💩 in the living room doesn’t matter if you test it or put fragrance on it still going to smell….your aquarium is filthy, clean it! Blow, scrub and remove the algae with WC or a canister filter. Don’t bother doing anything else….
You still have to figure out why the dog crapped in the living room as well, or they will just do it again.

While your advice to clean is true, why is the algae there in the first place? new tank uglies? nutrient imbalance? Direct sunlight?

An attack from both angles will cure the problem
 
You still have to figure out why the dog crapped in the living room as well, or they will just do it again.

While your advice to clean is true, why is the algae there in the first place? new tank uglies? nutrient imbalance? Direct sunlight?

An attack from both angles will cure the problem
Yes, correct. In OP case however, this is just basic miss management. I don’t believe in nutrient imbalances or sunlight being problems. Algae can only bloom and over take when conditions are right or abundant, otherwise they die just like corals, trees, plants, or animals.
 
Yes, correct. In OP case however, this is just basic miss management. I don’t believe in nutrient imbalances or sunlight being problems. Algae can only bloom and over take when conditions are right or abundant, otherwise they die just like corals, trees, plants, or animals.
You don't believe in imbalances, yet believe that conditions must be right? What if that imbalance is the condition?

If not imbalance, what are the conditions to look for and correct?
 
You don't believe in imbalances, yet believe that conditions must be right? What if that imbalance is the condition?

If not imbalance, what are the conditions to look for and correct?
When people talk about imbalances, I believe they are referring to a no3/po4 ratio. I have had several aquarium with different nutrient ratios and all successful, if nutrients are available I think the ratios are meaningless only that one does not become limited. Which is rare however but possible with po4 and nearly impossible with regards to no3.

If not imbalance, what are the conditions to look for and correct? I seek all levels to mimic the nature reef and believe it is very unlikely, with our general habitat of overstocking, to maintain those levels without the hobbyist intervening otherwise the aquarium generally moves to nutrient rich.
 
When people talk about imbalances, I believe they are referring to a no3/po4 ratio. I have had several aquarium with different nutrient ratios and all successful, if nutrients are available I think the ratios are meaningless only that one does not become limited. Which is rare however but possible with po4 and nearly impossible with regards to no3.

If not imbalance, what are the conditions to look for and correct? I seek all levels to mimic the nature reef and believe it is very unlikely, with our general habitat of overstocking, to maintain those levels without the hobbyist intervening otherwise the aquarium generally moves to nutrient rich.
I'm currently fighting back dinos a bit... running at PO4 0.12 and between zero and .5 nitrates while dosing ammonia bicarbonate daily. Not sure why I can't keep nitrates up at the moment as the tank was running at PO4 .05 and 5 to 10 nitrates for the last month...

I had some cleanup crew die off throw things a bit whacky but dosing more ammonia seems to help.
 
I'm currently fighting back dinos a bit... running at PO4 0.12 and between zero and .5 nitrates while dosing ammonia bicarbonate daily. Not sure why I can't keep nitrates up at the moment as the tank was running at PO4 .05 and 5 to 10 nitrates for the last month...

I had some cleanup crew die off throw things a bit whacky but dosing more ammonia seems to help.
I have several books published by J Sprung, from as far back to 1994 and some more recently, who writes about dinoflagellates and their control. He is very consistent to his approach. His approach is to elevate ph with kalk, manually remove as much as possible, reduce nutrients, and discontinue WC. The reason he suggests no WC is to reduce trace elements additions to limit the bloom which he says doesn’t cause the bloom but increases it. Raising nutrients will only provide more fuel. Many believe no WC is to keep nutrients from bottoming, however it has nothing to do with it, that advice has been twisted online. Sprung doesn’t just write, “I did this and that happened”. Everything he recommends is based on his experience and backed by quoted research, it is not simply “hobby observations”.

“Dinoflagellate have much the same nutritional requirements as other macroalgae, and once introduced to the aquarium, they can subsist on extremely low levels of phosphate.” Note that Julian writes dinos subsist on low levels of phosphates similar to other macro algae, not zero nutrients which some believe.
 
If your dog takes a big 💩 in the living room doesn’t matter if you test it or put fragrance on it still going to smell….your aquarium is filthy, clean it! Blow, scrub and remove the algae with WC or a canister filter. Don’t bother doing anything else….
My friend this is my tank with every day cleaning the cyanide disappears at night and comes in the day I cleared one day the next they appear again…
 
Can you test nitrate and phosphate? This is often caused by an imbalance where one or both have zeroed...
Phosphates are at 0.07 and nitrates are at 50
 
My friend this is my tank with every day cleaning the cyanide disappears at night and comes in the day I cleared one day the next they appear again…
I set my tank up a year and a half ago with 100% dry rock, pictured is the worst of my “ugly” phase, not trying to be rude or condescending, but do a better job and you will be rewarded, I promise.

I understand it is tedious and boring but it works 100% of the time…

IMG_3570.jpeg
 
My friend this is my tank with every day cleaning the cyanide disappears at night and comes in the day I cleared one day the next they appear again…
I set my tank up a year and a half ago with 100% dry rock, pictured is the worst of my “ugly” phase, not trying to be rude or condescending, but do a better job and you will be rewarded, I promise.

I understand it is tedious and boring but it works 100% of the time…

IMG_3570.jpeg
My tank was clean to the bottom this problem started appearing when cyano appeared, then I went on vacation of a week and my tank was in this state
 
My tank was clean to the bottom this problem started appearing when cyano appeared, then I went on vacation of a week and my tank was in this state
Yes I believe it, Cyano can bloom extremely fast and seemingly take over in a matter of days. Also your nutrients are extremely high, which leads me to believe you have a lot of input without enough export. Rocks look tightly packed which collects detritus and feeds the algae. Management is flow, removal, cleaning, CUC, etc…it’s not one thing it is all things.
 
Phosphates are at 0.07 and nitrates are at 50
Ultimately I believe the biggest fix for me was adding UV.

This is specific to dinos, and UV only helps certain types of dinos.

I also did tons of sand vacuuming.
 
Phosphates are at 0.07 and nitrates are at 50
Ultimately I believe the biggest fix for me was adding UV.

This is specific to dinos, and UV only helps certain types of dinos.

I also did tons of sand vacuuming.
I do have a small Uber light
 
My tank was clean to the bottom this problem started appearing when cyano appeared, then I went on vacation of a week and my tank was in this state
Yes I believe it, Cyano can bloom extremely fast and seemingly take over in a matter of days. Also your nutrients are extremely high, which leads me to believe you have a lot of input without enough export. Rocks look tightly packed which collects detritus and feeds the algae. Management is flow, removal, cleaning, CUC, etc…it’s not one thing it is all things.
I only have one wave maker and it’s probably not enough flow I will try to get another and put them in a way that detritus doesn’t set in places
 

TOP 10 Trending Threads

HOW WOULD YOU FEEL ABOUT RECEIVING A FISH OR CORAL AS A HOLIDAY GIFT?

  • I’d love one, as long as it’s a species I chose

    Votes: 26 23.9%
  • I’d trust someone who knows my tank to choose

    Votes: 9 8.3%
  • I’d rather get a gift card and pick it myself

    Votes: 45 41.3%
  • I’d prefer gear or supplies instead

    Votes: 2 1.8%
  • Please don’t surprise me with livestock

    Votes: 27 24.8%
  • Other (Post in the comments)

    Votes: 0 0.0%
Back
Top
Home
Post thread…
Market
What's new