Cyano....mb7

  • Thread starter Thread starter islander84
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users Tagged users None

islander84

Island Member
View Badges
Joined
Feb 17, 2011
Messages
1,060
Reaction score
92
Location
Clarksville TN
What state or country do you live in
Tennessee
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
i have some cyano in my tank mostly in sand bed a little on rocks not much....if i use the red slime remover and then start dosing mb 7 what is going to happen....Or does anyone have any suggestions for this situation..? i plan on dosing mb7 but wasnt sure the proper route in this situation.....thanks
 
Hello, first off I wouldnt dose Red Slimer Remover unless it is absolutely necessary. Once you start dosing Red Slime Remover you can create super cyano. What I mean by super cyano is that the cyano may develop a resistance to the antibiotics in the the Red Slime Remover. The best course of action to find the cause of the issue. Most cyano comes down to improper flow.

The best actions would be:

-Dose MB7 to compete for food with cyano
-Increase flow
-Decrease photoperiod, with at least one day of total lights out.

You can also try a combo of MB7\KZ Coral Snow. Coral Snow has worked wonders in my setup, and I have not seen cyano in months.

Oh, and ill get to your PM's here in a few. ;)

Sonny
 
+1 def mb7 gotta try that KZ coral snow.....
 
Hello, first off I wouldnt dose Red Slimer Remover unless it is absolutely necessary. Once you start dosing Red Slime Remover you can create super cyano. What I mean by super cyano is that the cyano may develop a resistance to the antibiotics in the the Red Slime Remover. The best course of action to find the cause of the issue. Most cyano comes down to improper flow.

The best actions would be:

-Dose MB7 to compete for food with cyano
-Increase flow
-Decrease photoperiod, with at least one day of total lights out.

You can also try a combo of MB7\KZ Coral Snow. Coral Snow has worked wonders in my setup, and I have not seen cyano in months.

Oh, and ill get to your PM's here in a few. ;)

Sonny

Red Slime remover doesn't have any antibiotics in it. It is an oxidizer.
 
Red Slime remover doesn't have any antibiotics in it. It is an oxidizer.

Yes, but in the process of killing the bad bacteria it kills Tue good as well. Thus, I call it ANTI-Biotic.

Sonny
 
Yes, but in the process of killing the bad bacteria it kills Tue good as well. Thus, I call it ANTI-Biotic.

Sonny

so you are saying that if you use this product that it wipes out your bacterial filtration that you have established in the sandbed and lve rock?
 
I haven't experienced bacterial populations crashing from it's use... ever. Antibiotic was a poor choice of words and/or a simple error... no big deal....
 
If u can suck out the cyano with a syringe or something and start wet skimming to reduce the nutrients. Try to see if you can increase the flow in areas with alot of cyano..
 
Red slime remover, or any of the competitors, works fine and won't hurt anything. As for the MicroBacter 7, it has a different effect and you won't have any issues dosing it afterward. Though I'm not a big fan of adding chemicals, both products work as advertised.

Jeff
 
so you are saying that if you use this product that it wipes out your bacterial filtration that you have established in the sandbed and lve rock?

I haven't experienced bacterial populations crashing from it's use... ever. Antibiotic was a poor choice of words and/or a simple error... no big deal....

While I haven't used Red Slime remover in a while, the last time I checked the main ingredient in Red Slime Removers(Erythromycin) is in fact an antibiotic.

Information of the main ingredient: Erythromycin - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

So, if Erythromycin is still the main ingredient in Red Slime Removers we can say that it is an antibiotic.

When I have used it in the past I did notice major changes in my system. My skimmer output decreased, and many corals browned out. It is IMO a last resort option, as it can wipe out an entire system. My friend JimC wiped out his system last year with red slime remover, and his setup\reefing knowledge are second to none.

Every system is different, so while it may work well for some it may not work for others. I used it for many years, but cyano would come back every 6 months. With each wave it came back stronger and strong. I spoke with Randy Holmes Farley a while back(Reef Chemist on RC) and was informed that the cyano was getting stronger and adapting to the chemicals used. I eventually had to start almost from scratch in order to rid myself of the issue.

The bottom line is that one should exhaust all options before turning to chemicals. Treating the cyano and not the cause is a recipe for disaster done the road.
 
Last edited:
Had a baby case like a light dusting on the sand and added MB7 the next morning. The cyano was gone within 24 hours after hanging out for a good 6 days.
 
I have always been wary of Chemi clean, etc. because I suspect they are antibiotics. I think the label for chemi clean says "does not contain erythromycin succinate" but erythromycin can come in other salts (not succinate), but is still erythromycin. A little shady, IMO. When used properly, concentrations aren't high enough to wipe out enough nitrosamonas sp. bacteria to cause a cycle, etc. I have lost corals to it though, and don't think I would use it again. I get the occasional cyano outbreak and use 3 day blackouts and siphoning to manage it.....keeps it from taking over at least (and this is after addressing the flow and water chemistry issues as mentioned above. Also as above, the idea of creating "super cyano" is real and scary. As with other resistance problems the "super cyano" can be passed off to other reefers. In general, humans use way to many antibiotics way to liberally and have caused a ton of problems with promoting the evolution of resistant organisms, doctors and hospitals being the main culprits, of course.
 
take sonnys advice he knows what he is talking about, trust me. ive been lucky enough to meet sonny and see his beautiful display first hand. the man is very knowledgeable. if it wasnt for sonny and jimc i would not be in this hobby today.
 
Are the directions on the mb7 bottle accurate? or does anyone have any recommendations?
 
I have cyano in my tank and dosed mb7 for the 2 weeks and it didn't clear it up. Can I keep dosing the mb7 everyday even though it says every 2 weeks now? I have reduced my photo period as well and upped my flow but it doesn't seem to go away.
 
treat the ROOT cause not the problem. I was told this MANY TIMES when I complained about cyano. My tank is 6 moths old, and I have had my issues with it. OVER FEEDING is the MAIN cause. too manny nutrients in the water. USING a chemical to kill a problem does NOT take out the root cause of the problem, it just makes it go away for a while. WHY add a potentially DANGEROUS chemical to do something if your NOT doing something about what CAUSED the problem in the forst place. Just my .. I am new but I learned about this NOT so long ago and I have gotten a handle on it. Red Sea NO3PO4X Reduced my nitrates to less than 5 and phos ZERO, and cyano is no longer Growing and what is there is kinda leaving. NO chemiclean or antibiotics are needed if you solve the CAUSE not the PROBLEM...

Yeah I used chemiclean when I first got it, it came back in a week.

I am no expert but I am learning from EVERYONE and I am bvery SURPRISED that I am the ONLY one chiming in about NOT using a chemical to treat an issue....
 
FWIW, you weren't the only one steering them clear of the chemical additive. Brightwell's MB7, the additive in question, is actually a bacterial dosing solution that will out-compete the cyano for food. Overfeeding is not the sole source of cyano, flow has a large factor in the presense of cyano as well as inefficient skimming and just overall lack of nutrient export. These nutrients can be built up from overfeeding, overstocking, as well as several other factors. Although I've never tried the KZ Marine Snow that Sonny suggested, I've used MB7 in the past with great success and I'll be sure to try the Marine Snow if I ever run into a cyano outbreak in the future. Thanks for the advice Sonny!
 
Last edited:

TOP 10 Trending Threads

HOW WOULD YOU FEEL ABOUT RECEIVING A FISH OR CORAL AS A HOLIDAY GIFT?

  • I’d love one, as long as it’s a species I chose

    Votes: 26 24.1%
  • I’d trust someone who knows my tank to choose

    Votes: 9 8.3%
  • I’d rather get a gift card and pick it myself

    Votes: 44 40.7%
  • I’d prefer gear or supplies instead

    Votes: 2 1.9%
  • Please don’t surprise me with livestock

    Votes: 27 25.0%
  • Other (Post in the comments)

    Votes: 0 0.0%
Back
Top
Home
Post thread…
Market
What's new