Finally got my ICP tests now what?

[Fishingandreefing]

Finally got the results back for my two tanks and not sure how to read them and what I need to worry or to do.

First, “total phosphate” is the number I am looking at correct? And what’s “chrome”? My bigger tank has a chrome reading of 1,17 and the recommended range is 1,17 to 2,3 is that mean I am ok?

so based on the results, what’s next?

thanks!

 

[Randy Holmes-Farley]

chrome is presumably chromium.

Can you post the whole result?

 

[Fishingandreefing]

chrome is presumably chromium.

Can you post the whole result?

Just edited

 

[Fishingandreefing]

Anyone?

 

[Randy Holmes-Farley]

Potassium seems unusually high. Are you dosing any? If so, I'd stop.

Nothing else jumps out at me as a significant issue. I wouldn't worry about the chromium.

 

[Fishingandreefing]

Potassium seems unusually high. Are you dosing any? If so, I'd stop.

Nothing else jumps out at me as a significant issue. I wouldn't worry about the chromium.

I was dosing little bit of Tropic Marin A and K weekly but I stopped for a few weeks before sent in the icp. However, I am dosing Red Sea energy daily if not I dose acropower

for the chromium, wouldn’t it be helpful if I run through some cuprisorb just to pull the metal out?

Also “total phosphate” is the number I need to know correct?

thanks

 

[Randy Holmes-Farley]

I was dosing little bit of Tropic Marin A and K weekly but I stopped for a few weeks before sent in the icp. However, I am dosing Red Sea energy daily if not I dose acropower

for the chromium, wouldn’t it be helpful if I run through some cuprisorb just to pull the metal out?

Also “total phosphate” is the number I need to know correct?

thanks

I would not assume that it is beneficial to add a metal binder, because they bind many metals, and you are in short supply of some.

As to phosphate, you can interpret either P or phosphate (it's just a math conversion), but if you are comparing to what folks get with a test kit, they report phosphate. Yours is fine.

 

[Fishingandreefing]

I would not assume that it is beneficial to add a metal binder, because they bind many metals, and you are in short supply of some.

As to phosphate, you can interpret either P or phosphate (it's just a math conversion), but if you are comparing to what folks get with a test kit, they report phosphate. Yours is fine.

Got it but just to clarify on the phosphate reading, based on my second results, P is .218 that’s the number I need to know correct? I usually check it with the Hanna ULR phosphate checker.

 

[Randy Holmes-Farley]

Which checker? Hanna has some that read in P (phosphorus) and some that read in phosphate.

What's the difference between the two ICP tests?

 

[Treefer32]

yes, and .218 seems high if you're running Acros. My acros do not like anything above .1. At .2 some of my corals will suffer tissue loss. Trust me, I just had it happen. Went on vacation and phosphate claimed to .2 (hanna checker) and 1 of my favorite coral frags had already started dying, I didn't catch it in time.

 

[Fishingandreefing]

Which checker? Hanna has some that read in P (phosphorus) and some that read in phosphate.

What's the difference between the two ICP tests?

So i should be reading P (.218) correct?

 

[Fishingandreefing]

yes, and .218 seems high if you're running Acros. My acros do not like anything above .1. At .2 some of my corals will suffer tissue loss. Trust me, I just had it happen. Went on vacation and phosphate claimed to .2 (hanna checker) and 1 of my favorite coral frags had already started dying, I didn't catch it in time.

Yeah it’s being like that. It used to be .90 and I brought it down slowly. Now it’s always hovering around .3 by Hanna but somehow it’s lower by icp lol

 

[Randy Holmes-Farley]

So i should be reading P (.218) correct?

If the intent is to compare the checker to the ICP, then total phosphate on the ICP is the same units that the checker is producing (but not necessarily exactly the same forms of P detected).

Otherwise, its like asking if I should pay attention to temperature in Celsius or Fahrenheit.